Heuristics screening

The third and very valuable discovery that the new phthalazine (PHAL) and pyrimidine (PYR) ligand classes (32-35, Figure 2) out-perform the monomeric ligands under identical conditions emerged from a heuristic screening process. The PHAL class in particular has become the first choice for most olefin classes. The PYR class is usually superior for terminal olefins, while the IND class is ideally suited for cA-disubstituted olefins. These ligands are commercially available or can be made easily from relatively inexpensive starting materials. 

Virtual screening applications based on superposition or docking usually contain difficult-to-solve optimization problems with a mixed combinatorial and numerical flavor. The combinatorial aspect results from discrete models of conformational flexibility and molecular interactions. The numerical aspect results from describing the relative orientation of two objects, either two superimposed molecules or a ligand with respect to a protein in docking calculations. Problems of this kind are in most cases hard to solve optimally with reasonable compute resources. Sometimes, the combinatorial and the numerical part of such a problem can be separated and independently solved. For example, several virtual screening tools enumerate the conformational space of a molecule in order to address a major combinatorial part of the problem independently (see for example [199]). Alternatively, heuristic search techniques are used to tackle the problem as a whole. Some of them will be covered in this section. 

Every currently available virtual screening approach in structure- or ligand-based design is heuristic and thus will neither provide any quality guarantee nor an error bound on the obtained results. In every case, the fundamental model describing similarity or... 

The following examples illustrate the application of high-throughput screening tools together with heuristic search algorithms in the development of new enhanced catalyst for two fields of industrial interest, olefin epoxidation and the isomerization of light paraffins. 

Nath and Motard (1978) present a closely related algorithm but also include an heuristically invented screening function to order the list of neighbors. They also invent a neighboring... 

Simplistic and heuristic similarity-based approaches can hardly produce as good predictive models as modern statistical and machine learning methods that are able to assess quantitatively biological or physicochemical properties. QSAR-based virtual screening consists of direct assessment of activity values (numerical or binary) of all compounds in the database followed by selection of hits possessing desirable activity. Mathematical methods used for models preparation can be subdivided into classification and regression approaches. The former decide whether a given compound is active, whereas the latter numerically evaluate the activity values. Classification approaches that assess probability of decisions are called probabilistic. 

For nearly ideal mixtures, insights based on marginal vapor flows permit the development of a. simple. screening criterion computed using only relative volatilities and component feed flowrates to find the better column sequences from among the many possible. This criterion explains several of the traditional heuristics. 

Hodes, L., Hazard, G.F., Geran, R.I. and Richman, S. (1977). A Statistical-Heuristic Method for Automated Selection of Drugs for Screening. J.Med.Chem.,20,469-475. 

Hodes, L. (1981a). Computer-Aided Selection of Compounds for Antitumor Screening Validation of a Statistical-Heuristic Method. JChem.Inf.Comput.Sci., 21,128-132. 

Heuristic methods were developed by well-experienced engineers and researchers. The first attempt to develop a systematic heuristic approach for the synthesis of multicomponent separation sequences was made by Siirola and Rudd. Common example is hierarchical heuristic approach.Heuristic rules are applied at five design levels to generate and evaluate the alternatives using economic criteria. The hierarchical heuristic method emphasizes the strategy of decomposition and screening. It allows for a quick location of flowsheet structures that are often near ... 

The Evaluation is an overall measure for the applicability and importance of a Claim. The Evaluation class is not further specified in the Evaluation module. Instead, tailored measurement units can be defined depending on the nature of the decision problem in consideration. For instance, in the early stages of a design process, a coarse-grained evaluation of Claims is sufficient because not much knowledge about relevant aspects of a design problem is available and heuristics as well as screening and short-cut methods are applied. 

Hodes, L. (1981a) Computer-aided selection of compounds for antitumor screening validation of a statistical-heuristic method. /. Chem. Inf. Comput. Sci., 21, 128-132. 

---