Heterogeneous asymmetric catalysis solid catalysts

The enantioselective hydrogenation of prochiral substances bearing an activated group, such as an ester, an acid or an amide, is often an important step in the industrial synthesis of fine and pharmaceutical products. In addition to the hydrogenation of /5-ketoesters into optically pure products with Raney nickel modified by tartaric acid [117], the asymmetric reduction of a-ketoesters on heterogeneous platinum catalysts modified by cinchona alkaloids (cinchonidine and cinchonine) was reported for the first time by Orito and coworkers [118-121]. Asymmetric catalysis on solid surfaces remains a very important research area for a better mechanistic understanding of the interaction between the substrate, the modifier and the catalyst [122-125], although excellent results in terms of enantiomeric excesses (up to 97%) have been obtained in the reduction of ethyl pyruvate under optimum reaction conditions with these Pt/cinchona systems [126-128],... 

The first reported attempts of what was then called "absolute or total asymmetric synthesis" with chiral solid catalysts used nature (naturally ) both as a model and as a challenge. Hypotheses of the origin of chirality on earth and early ideas on the nature of enzymes strongly influenced this period [15]. Two directions were tried First, chiral solids such as quartz and natural fibres were used as supports for metallic catalysts and second, existing heterogeneous catalysts were modified by the addition of naturally occuring chiral molecules. Both approaches were successful and even if the optical yields were, with few exceptions, very low or not even determined quantitatively the basic feasibility of heterogeneous enantioselective catalysis was established. 

In a similar vein, a series of papers published between 2002 and 2008 contains spectacular claims of highly enantioselective asymmetric additions of water to styrenes, unsaturated carboxylic acids, or simple terminal alkenes [34-Al]. The catalysts used are of the heterogeneous type and based on chiral biopolymers such as wool, gelatin, or chitosan as solid supports (sometimes in combination with silica or ion-exchange resins) that are doped with transition metal salts. This series of papers contains spectacular claims, insufficient experimental data, and erroneous chemical structures for the biopolymers used. As earlier work from the same group of authors on asymmetric catalysis on bio-polymeric supports is irreproducible [42], one is well advised to await independent confirmation of those results. 

Chiral separation or sorption is another important technique in chirotechnology. In fact, due to the high cost of chiral catalysts, industries generally prefer chiral separation over asymmetric catalysis to obtain optically pure compounds. As in asymmetric heterogeneous catalysis, a chiral selector (a chiral molecule in optically pure form) can be immobilized on a solid support to make a chiral stationary phase (CSP) of use in direct chiral separation. The basic principle of chiral separation is that the chiral selector interacts differently with the enantiomers of a racemic or enantioenriched mixture to form transient diastereoisomeric species of different stability, and this fine distinction leads to the separation of enantiomers during elution. This topic has also produced a huge number of papers and the readers are referred to the previous reviews for more knowledge on this field [70-73]. 

Asymmetric catalysis can be homogeneous or heterogeneous and can take place either in the organic phase or (as recently found) in the aqueous phase. Table 9.5 presents a broad classification of the major categories of asymmetric catalysis. The most common is homogeneous catalysis in the aqueous phase, and the most recent and novel is the use of aqueous phase catalysts immobilized on solid supports. The various categories are considered in the following sections. 

Nickel and other transition metal catalysts, when modified with a chiral compound such as (R,R)-tartaric acid 5S), become enantioselective. All attempts to modify solid surfaces with optically active substances have so far resulted in catalysts of only low stereoselectivity. This is due to the fact that too many active centers of different structures are present on the surface of the catalysts. Consequently, in asymmetric hydrogenations the technique of homogeneous catalysis is superior to heterogeneous catalysis56). However, some carbonyl compounds have been hydrogenated in the presence of tartaric-acid-supported nickel catalysts in up to 92% optical purity55 . 

Simple L-alanine, L-valine, L-norvaline, L-isolecucine, L-serine and other linear amino acids [ 121 ] or chiral amino acids with a binaphthyl backbone [ 122] and peptides have also been used as asymmetric catalysts [123,124,125,126]. Solid-supported proline-terminated peptides have been used for heterogeneous catalysis of the asymmetric aldol reaction [ 127]. Apart from proline and derivatives, other cyclic compounds such as 5,5-dimethyl thiazolidinium-4-car-boxylate (DMTC) [128], 2-fert-butyl-4-benzyl imidazolidinones [129], (l/ ,25)-2-aminocy-clopentanecarboxylic acid [130], (5 -5-(pyrrolidin-2-yl)tetrazole, (5)-l,3-thiazolidine-4-car-boxylic acid, (5)-5,5-dimethyl-l,3-thiazolidine-4-carboxylic acid, and (5)-hydroxyproline are effective catalysts in asymmetric aldol reactions [126,131,132,133,134,135]. 

---