Concerted reactions, and

In the pure concerted reaction there is no need to invoke the cationic or anionic intermediates in describing the transition state, but it now becomes evident that some deviation from this idealized route may be possible, and then we need a way to comment upon and to measure the extent to which the cationic or anionic character is mixed in in the transition state. This is now widely accomplished with the aid of energy surfaces of the type shown schematically in Fig. 5-19. Depending on the nature of the surface, the reaction path may follow a route far from the diagonal representing the pure concerted reaction, and the primary goal is to identify the location of the transition state on this surface. 

Dihydrothiophene-1,1-dioxides (42) and 2,17-dihydrothiepin-1,1-dioxides (43) undergo analogous 1,4 and 1,6 eliminations, respectively (see also 17-38). These are concerted reactions and, as predicted by the orbital-symmetry rules (p. 1067), the former is a suprafacial process and the latter an antarafacial process. The rules also predict that elimination of SO2 from episulfones cannot take place by a concerted mechanism (except antarafacially, which is unlikely for such a small ring), and the evidence shows that this reaction occurs by a non-concerted pathway.The eliminations of SO2 from 42 and 43 are examples of cheletropic reactions, which are defined as reactions in which two a bonds that terminate at a single atom (in this case the sulfur atom) are made or broken in concert. 

The trans compound cannot be formed by a concerted reaction from the 33t-7t state because the predominant level perturbation is the almost degenerate interaction of K(jr) and 0(jr), that would give cis geometry of product. Since the trans adduct must be formed via biradical intermediate (the only other possibility), it has usually been convenient to suppose that the cis adduct is also formed from the same biradical intermediate. Another choice of mechanism is that cis compound is formed via a concerted reaction, and the trans compound arises from a biradical pathway. In this case, the spin prohibition could be outweighed by two factors, the favorable geometry and the stabilizing first-order perturbation. 

Explain the difference between a concerted reaction and a stepwise reaction. 

Cyclotetramerization to form cyclooctatetraene occurs only with nickel.46,63 68 The best catalysts are octahedral Ni(II) complexes, such as bis(cyclooctatetraene) dinickel.46 Internal alkynes do not form cyclooctatetraene derivatives but participate in cooligomerization with acetylene. Of the possible mechanistic pathways, results with [l-13C]-acetylene81 favor a stepwise insertion process or a concerted reaction, and exclude any symmetric intermediate (cyclobutadiene, benzene). The involvement of dinuclear species are in agreement with most observations.46,82-84... 

Figure 13-1 Schematic representation of energy versus reaction coordinate for (A) a concerted reaction and (B) a stepwise reaction involving formation of an unstable intermediate. Curve B has been drawn to have the highest energy point (the transition state) come before the intermediate is formed. For many processes the highest energy point comes after the intermediate is formed. If the highest energy point comes after the intermediate is formed, then the intermediate will be more or less in equilibrium with the reactants.

The Woodward-Hoffmann rules also allow the prediction of the stereochemistry of pericyclic reactions. The Diels-Alder reaction is an example of (re4s + re2s) cycloaddition. The subscript s, meaning suprafacial, indicates that both elements of the addition take place on the same side of the re-system. Addition to opposite sides is termed antarafacial. The Woodward-Hoffmann rules apply only to concerted reactions and are derived from the symmetry properties of the orbitals involved in the transition state. These rules may be summarised as shown in Table 7.1. 

The recent developments in homogenous Mn(salen)- and Cr(salen)-mediated asymmetric epoxidation, with a variety of co-oxidants, have been reviewed. The possible mechanistic pathways (including concerted reaction and metallooxetane intermediate formation) and trajectory of alkene approach are discussed on the basis of experimental results and theoretical calculations.18... 

An acetal tethered compound can easily be prepared by treatment of equimolar amounts of a 2-propenyl ether derivative of a saccharide with a sugar hydroxyl in the presence of a catalytic amount of acid. Activation of the anomeric thio moiety of the tethered compound with N-iodosuccinimide (NIS) in dichloromethane results in the formation of the p-linked disaccharide. In this reaction, no a-linked disaccharide is usually detected. It is of interest to note that when this reaction was performed in the presence of methanol, no methyl glycosides are obtained. This experiment indicates that the glycosylation proceeds via a concerted reaction and not a free anomeric oxocarbenium ion. 

This is again a concerted reaction and again we know that by proton labelling. One of the two enantiotopic protons (Hs in the diagram) is lost from the bottom face of the allylic CH2 group while the new proton is added to the top face of the alkene. This is an anti rearrangement overall. 

Fig. 2. Plots of bond indices for two new bonds formed in a cycloaddition for synchronous and simultaneous concerted reactions, and for a nonconcerted process...

Orbital symmetry effects are observed in concerted reactions, that is, in reactions where several bonds are being made or broken simultaneously. Woodward and Hoffmann formulated rules, and described certain reaction paths as symmetry-allowed and others as symmetry-forbidden. All of this applies only to concerted reactions, and refers to the relative ease with which they take place. A symmetry-forbidden reaction is simply one for which the concerted mechanism is very difficult, so difficult that, if reaction is to occur at all, it will probably do so in a different way by a different concerted path that is symmetry-allowed or, if there is none, by a stepwise, non-concerted mechanism. In the following brief discussion, and in the problems based on it, we have not the space to give the evidence indicating that each reaction is indeed concerted but there must be such evidence, and gathering it is often the hardest job the investigator has to do. 

Two reaction mechanisms have been proposed for these dihydroxylations (pathway a or b, Figure 7.23), either a concerted [3+2] cycloaddition of the olefins on osmium-diamine complex 7.33 or a stepwise reversible [2+2] cycloaddition followed by a rearrangement [559,1350], An X-ray crystal structure of the resulting osmic ester 2.89A shows its symmetrical structure. Houk s calculations [1351] are in favor of a concerted reaction, and his transition state model is reactant-like, with steric interactions dictating the face selectivity of osmylation. 

Two alkyls in the /1 position are prohibitive lot the concerted reaction and mesityl oxide does not add primary Orignard reagents 1.4. This steric hindrance is overcome by the bulky /-bulylmag-ncsiutn chloride. A 2s < yield of the overcrowded 4.4.s. s-icirninclliyl-Tlie iiionc is obtained, which obviously is formed.. Scheme 1.10. by recombination ol magnesium mesityl oxide ketyl and /-butyl radical alter an initial homolysis ]86. ... 

The issue of the concertedness of the D-A reaction has been studied and debated extensively. It has been argued that there might be an intermediate that is diradical in character. D-A reactions are almost always stereospecific, which implies that if an intermediate exists, it cannot have a lifetime sufficient to permit rotation or inversion. The prevailing opinion is that the majority of D-A reactions are concerted reactions and most theoretical analyses agree with this view. ° It is recognized that in reactions between unsymmetrical alkenes and dienes, bond formation might be more advanced at one pair of termini than at the other. This is deseribed as being an asynchronous... 

The loss of benzaldehyde can also be written as a concerted reaction, and there is no experimental evidence to distinguish the possibilities, aside from the preponderance of cleavage reactions for related substrates. However, a concerted loss of benzaldehyde would require either a simultaneous a-cleavage reaction or a direct pyramidal inversion to account for the isomerization reaction. The isolated product, 77, is presumed to derive from secondary photolysis of the mixed sulfenic/carboxylic anhydride 75. 

---