Collision theory testing

Tests of the collision theory consist of comparisons between calculated and experimental values of the preexponential factor, the comparison often being made in terms of a ratio P defined by... 

The abundant experimental data on ionic clusters reacting with neutral molecules has been used to test some of these collision theories. In the next subsection, we briefly review several papers where comparisons between measured and theoretical rate coefficients have been made, and we summarize some of the important conclusions concerning the reactivity of clusters. 

Paige ME, Harris CB. A generic test of gas phase isolated binary collision theories for vibrational relaxation at liquid state densities based on the rescaling properties of collision frequencies. J Chem Phys 1990 93 3712-3713. 

We may say that the work which has been done after the war has somewhat changed our views about the physical grounds of chemical kinetics. We have learned that the old a posteriori experimental evidence of the collision theory has proved to be unsafe, being grounded upon ill-defined quantities, such as the diameter to be used in the rate expressions. This has been particu-lary evident for thermal dissociation reactions, where the knowledge of the activation energy makes possible a real test. 

Cachapuz, A.E.C., Maskill, R. (1987). Detecting changes with learning in the organization of knowledge Use of word association tests to follow the learning of collision theory. International Journal of Science Education, 9, 491-504. 

The activation energy is defined by a=—7 dln/ (T)/d(l/T). Substituting the rate coefficient expression of equation (60), collision theory predicts that Fa — Vq+ /2RT, and in addition, from equation (58) it predicts that A — ( nksT/exp(l/2). Thus, the SCT model predicts that both the activation energy and the pre-exponential factor are temperature dependent quantities. To test collision theory, experimentally determined values of Fa and A can be compared with the above... 

Among four-atom reactions this system has become a prototype test case for the comparison between quantum state resolved dynamics experiments and bimolecular collision theory. In 1973 the first semi-empirical LEPS and BEBO PESs were constructed by Zellner and Smith [56]. The subsequent development of a global H-HOH(A ground state PES in 1980 [20b], based on ab initio calculations [20ak was favoured by the fact that three of the four atoms involved are H atoms. The... 

The collision theory is a useful one not only in the sense that it has provided insight into the nature of chemical reactions, but also because it is a theory that can be readily tested. The mark of a scientific theory is that it can be tested and falsified. So far, collision theory has been supported by experimental evidence, but if new data were produced that could not be explained using the collision theory then it would need to be modified or dismissed in favour of a new theory that did explain all the evidence. Currently collision theory is the best explanation of the experimental data produced so far (at this working level). It should be noted here that we have not begun to distinguish between elementary and complex, multi-step reactions. That discussion is developed in Chapter 16 with the introduction of the idea of the rate-determining step in a sequence of stages. This is an example of how the theory is modified to explain more complex situations. Note that unimolecular reactions are an apparent exception which require special treatment. 

With respect to ion-molecule reactions, the development of pulsed supersonic flows in Rennes (see Section 2.6.5) will also offer the possibility of achieving very low pressures in the supersonic flow and therefore will open the way to a revival of the ion-molecule CRESU apparatus by the use of a selective injection of ions which will be directly derived from expertise gained previously. Studies at temperatures close to 1K will be a decisive test in comparing present collision theories and are obviously of major importance. 

We can test this collision theory approximation by comparing the value calculated for the elementary reaction... 

Experiments have also played a critical role in the development of potential energy surfaces and reaction dynamics. In the earliest days of quantum chemistry, experimentally determined thermal rate constants were available to test and improve dynamical theories. Much more detailed information can now be obtained by experimental measurement. Today experimentalists routinely use molecular beam and laser techniques to examine how reaction cross-sections depend upon collision energies, the states of the reactants and products, and scattering angles. 

For many years this reaction was quoted as the classic example of an elementary bimolecular reaction, and used as a test of collision and transition state theories, but it has now been shown to be a complex non-chain reaction. 

The research of Roy Jackson combines theory and experiment in a distinctive fashion. First, the theory incorporates, in a simple manner, inertial collisions through relations based on kinetic theory, contact friction via the classical treatment of Coulomb, and, in some cases, momentum exchange with the gas. The critical feature is a conservation equation for the pseudo-thermal temperature, the microscopic variable characterizing the state of the particle phase. Second, each of the basic flows relevant to processes or laboratory tests, such as plane shear, chutes, standpipes, hoppers, and transport lines, is addressed and the flow regimes and multiple steady states arising from the nonlinearities (Fig. 6) are explored in detail. Third, the experiments are scaled to explore appropriate ranges of parameter space and observe the multiple steady states (Fig. 7). One of the more striking results is the... 

Even in the domain of inorganic redox chemistry relatively little use has been made of the full potential of the Marcus theory, i.e. calculation of A, and A0 according to (48) and (52) and subsequent use of (54) and (13) to obtain the rate constant (for examples, see Table 5). Instead the majority of published studies are confined to tests of the Marcus cross-relations, as given in (62)-(65) (see e.g. Pennington, 1978), or what amounts to the same type of test, analysis of log k vs. AG° relationships. The hesitation to try calculations of A is no doubt due to the inadequacy of the simple collision model of Fig. 4, which is difficult to apply even to species of approximately spherical shape. 

Pressure-dependent rate constants for the syn-anti conformational process in larger alkyl nitrites provide a further test of the ability of RRKM theory to successfully model the kinetics of the internal rotation process in these molecules. Solution of the Lindemann mechanism shows that at the pressure where the rate constant is one-half of its limiting high-pressure value, Pm, the frequency of deactivating collisions is comparable to , the average rate that critically... 

Here, / is in amu A2, M is in amu, d is in A, a is in A-1, and v is in cm-1. The second exponential term results from a correction for the change in velocity due to the increase in rotational energy. The steric factor, Z0, is introduced as in V-T theory to account for noncolinear collision orientations. Moore tested this equation, along with two other more approximate forms, on a series of molecules having one or more H (or D) atoms. He also examined V-R transfer for collisions of dissimilar molecules, such as C02-CH4, C12-HC1, and CH4-Ar. Twenty-five different molecules having small moments of inertia were fitted with a single curve represented by equation (71) using a = 2.94 A-1 and Z0 = 5.0, with at least qualitative success. 

Latex stability will be determined by the combined effect of two factors the probability of collision between particles and the fraction of the encounters between particles which lead to permanent contact. Tha first factor, the collision frequency, will increase with increasing particle size and particle number. It will also increase with increasing shear rate. The influence of various test conditions on the second factor ought to be discussed on the basis of the DLVO theory of colloid stability. 

Trapping atoms at these extremely low temperatures for several seconds should allow the study of low-energy collisions, the ways that atoms attract each other to form aggregates, and of other properties that would provide tests of the fundamental theories of matter. ... 

---