Catalysis, proposed mechanism

The proposed mechanism by which chlorinated dioxins and furans form has shifted from one of incomplete destmction of the waste to one of low temperature, downstream formation on fly ash particles (33). Two mechanisms are proposed, a de novo synthesis, in which PCDD and PCDF are formed from organic carbon sources and Cl in the presence of metal catalysts, and a more direct synthesis from chlorinated organic precursors, again involving heterogeneous catalysis. Bench-scale tests suggest that the optimum temperature for PCDD and PCDF formation in the presence of fly ash is roughly 300°C. 

Finally, students can be critics of published work, and perhaps have already encountered papers in the literature with questionable features. I invite reference to the paper, On the Mechanism of Catalysis by Ribonuclease Cleavage and Isomerization of the Dinucleotide UpU Catalyzed by Imidazole Buffers [Anslyn, E. Breslow, R. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1989, III, 4473 1482]. A useful exercise is to list any flaws. Any such criticisms can then be compared with those raised in the article, Imidazole Buffer-Catalyzed Cleavage and Isomerization Reactions of Dinucleotides The Proposed Mechanism Is Incompatible with the Kinetic Measurements [Haim, A. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1992,114, 8383-8388]. 

The proposed mechanism for the hydrosilylation of olefins catalyzed by chloroplatinic acid is outlined in Fig. 6. Catalysis by square-planar or trigonal bipyramidal rf complexes can be similarly described (54, 55, 105). 

A proposed mechanism (Scheme 5-44) begins with deprotonation of dimethyl phosphite to give an Al-phosphito complex (32) which can react with the aldehyde via either a chelate or open transition state, the latter possibly involving cooperative action of two aluminum centers, consistent with the observation of co-catalysis. Following P-C bond formation, several possible rearrangements could regenerate the achve catalyst and form the product... 

The concept of simultaneous turn over between catalytic functions in multi-functional catalysis is widely accepted (for instance, in bi-functional metal/acid transformation of alkanes), and this aspect of the proposed mechanism is a normal behaviour in steady state. 

This mechanism is based on the known importance of hydroxides in other deposition reactions, such as the anomalous codeposition of ferrous metal alloys [38-39], Salvago and Cavallotti claim an analogy with the mechanism of Ni2 + reduction from colloids in support of their proposed mechanism. There is no direct evidence for the hydrolyzed species, however. Furthermore, the mechanism does not explain two experimentally observed facts Ni deposition will proceed if the Ni2 + and the reducing agent are in separate compartments of a cell [36, 37] and P is not deposited in the absence of Ni2 +. The chemical mechanism does not take adequate account of the role of the surface state in catalysis of the reaction. It has no doubt been the extreme oversimplification, by some, of the electrochemical mechanism that has led other investigators to reject it. 

Fig. 3. Proposed mechanism of polymerization of dicarboxylic acid divinyl ester and glycol through lipase catalysis...

Based on these observations and several other experimental results with cofeeding of ethene and 1-alkene,9 the selectivity of branched hydrocarbons,11 and the different promoter effects of Li-, Na-, K-, and Cs-carbonate/oxide,1213 a novel mechanism has been proposed that is consistent with these various experimental results.14 The formulation of this mechanism follows the knowledge of analogous reactions in homogeneous catalysis and gives a detailed insight in the crucial step of C-C linkage formation. The aim of this work is to discuss in detail these experiments and their relationship to the proposed mechanism. 

Even more efficient bimetallic cooperativity was achieved by the dinuclear complex 36 [53]. It was demonstrated to cleave 2, 3 -cAMP (298 K) and ApA (323 K) with high efficiency at pH 6, which results in 300-500-fold rate increase compared to the mononuclear complex Cu(II)-[9]aneN at pH 7.3. The pH-metric study showed two overlapped deprotonations of the metal-bound water molecules near pH 6. The observed bell-shaped pH-rate profiles indicate that the monohydroxy form is the active species. The proposed mechanism for both 2, 3 -cAMP and ApA hydrolysis consists of a double Lewis-acid activation of the substrates, while the metal-bound hydroxide acts as general base for activating the nucleophilic 2 -OH group in the case of ApA (36a). Based on the 1000-fold higher activity of the dinuclear complex toward 2, 3 -cAMP, the authors suggest nucleophilic catalysis of the Cu(II)-OH unit in 36b. The latter mechanism is comparable to those of protein phosphatase 1 and fructose 1,6-diphosphatase. 

Hydride transfer from [(bipy)2(CO)RuH]+ occurs in the hydrogenation of acetone when the reaction is carried out in buffered aqueous solutions (Eq. (21)) [39]. The kinetics of the reaction showed that it was a first-order in [(bipy)2(CO)RuH]+ and also first-order in acetone. The reaction proceeds faster at lower pH. The proposed mechanism involved general acid catalysis, with a fast pre-equilibrium protonation of the ketone followed by hydride transfer from [(biPy)2(CO)RuH]+. 

The concerted delivery of protons from OH and hydride from RuH found in these Shvo systems is related to the proposed mechanism of hydrogenation of ketones (Scheme 7.15) by a series of ruthenium systems that operate by metal-ligand bifunctional catalysis [86]. A series of Ru complexes reported by Noyori, Ohkuma and coworkers exhibit extraordinary reactivity in the enantioselective hydrogenation of ketones. These systems are described in detail in Chapters 20 and 31, and mechanistic issues of these hydrogenations by ruthenium complexes have been reviewed [87]. 

Scheme 4-38. Proposed mechanism for asymmetric aminohydroxylation. Sequence of steps in the first catalysis cycle (left) (1) addition (a1), (2) reoxidation (O), (3) hydrolysis (h1) in the second catalysis cycle (right) (1) addition (a2), (2) hydrolysis (h2), (3) reoxidation (O). The first cycle proceeds with high ee, the second with low ee. L = chiral ligand X = CH3SO2. ... 

Scheme 5 Proposed mechanism for the catalysis of the dimerization of terminal alkynes by the mixed hafnacarborane complex. Reproduced by permission of the American Chemical Society from Organometallics 1997, 16, 4508.

A very successful example for the use of dendritic polymeric supports in asymmetric synthesis was recently described by Breinbauer and Jacobsen [76]. PA-MAM-dendrimers with [Co(salen)]complexes were used for the hydrolytic kinetic resolution (HKR) of terminal epoxides. For such asymmetric ring opening reactions catalyzed by [Co(salen)]complexes, the proposed mechanism involves cooperative, bimetallic catalysis. For the study of this hypothesis, PAMAM dendrimers of different generation [G1-G3] were derivatized with a covalent salen Hgand through an amide bond (Fig. 7.22). The separation was achieved by precipitation and SEC. The catalytically active [Co "(salen)]dendrimer was subsequently obtained by quantitative oxidation with elemental iodine (Fig. 7.22). 

The tetrazole-catalysed alcoholysis of simple dialkylphosphoramidates (267) in THE to yield trialkylphosphites (268) occurs via nucleophilic catalysis (Scheme 29). The proposed mechanism sees tetrazole acting first as an acid catalyst to give the protonated intermediate (269), which then reacts with tetrazolide anion to yield the tetrazolylphosphite (270) alcoholysis of the latter (270) then yields the final product, the trialkylphosphite (268). ... 

Figure 12. Proposed mechanism for cooperative catalysis in asymmetric ring opening of epoxide by dendimeric frame work.

Fig. 7.17 Proposed mechanism for non-specific esterase catalysis involving a serine residue.

Scheme 6.53 Proposed mechanism for the 53-catalyzed asymmetric Pictet-Spengler-type cyclization of P-indolyl ethyl hydroxylactams Hydroxylactam (1) forms chlorolactam (2) followed by chiral N-acyliminium chloride-thiourea complex (3) and the observed product generated by intramolecular cyclization catalysis and enantioinduction result from chloride abstraction and anion binding.

Typical examples referring to titanium derivatives are alkoxides with TBHP and titanosilicate (in particular TS-1) in the presence of H202. Based on this latter system, ENICHEM" commercialized a procedure for hydroxylation of phenol to cathecol and hydroquinone. Other activated arenes are also hydroxylated by TS-1 and hydrogen peroxide". Interestingly, for TS-1 catalysis a mechanism similar to that proposed... 

The mechanism of the acid-catalysed breakdown of hemiorthoesters Electron releasing substituents when attached to the pro-acyl carbon have a smaller effect on fcH+ for the breakdown of hemiorthoesters than of orthoesters (see p. 67 above) which suggest that these two classes of compounds react by different mechanisms and that the transition state for breakdown of the hemiorthoesters has less carbocationic character. Jencks and his coworkers (Funderburk et al., 1978) proposed mechanism (5) for the breakdown of hemiacetals and a similar mechanism (6) can be written for the breakdown of hemiorthoesters. This would explain (i) the general acid catalysis observed... 

---