Additive effects substituents

Historically, the discovery of one effective herbicide has led quickly to the preparation and screening of a family of imitative chemicals (3). Herbicide developers have traditionally used combinations of experience, art-based approaches, and intuitive appHcations of classical stmcture—activity relationships to imitate, increase, or make more selective the activity of the parent compound. This trial-and-error process depends on the costs and availabiUties of appropriate starting materials, ease of synthesis of usually inactive intermediates, and alterations of parent compound chemical properties by stepwise addition of substituents that have been effective in the development of other pesticides, eg, halogens or substituted amino groups. The reason a particular imitative compound works is seldom understood, and other pesticidal appHcations are not readily predictable. Novices in this traditional, quite random, process requite several years of training and experience in order to function productively. 

Only the bisected conformation aligns the cyclopropyl C—C orbitals for effective overlap. Crystal structure determinations on two cyclopropylmethyl cabons with additional stabilizing substituents, C and D, have confirmed file preference for the bisected geometry. The crystal structures of C and D are shown in Fig. 5.8. 

Nitroalkanes show a related relationship between kinetic acidity and thermodynamic acidity. Additional alkyl substituents on nitromethane retard the rate of proton removal although the equilibrium is more favorable for the more highly substituted derivatives. The alkyl groups have a strong stabilizing effect on the nitronate ion, but unfavorable steric effects are dominant at the transition state for proton removal. As a result, kinetic and thermodynamic acidity show opposite responses to alkyl substitution. 

When this stereoelectronic requirement is combined with a calculation of the steric and angle strain imposed on the transition state, as determined by MM-type calculations, preferences for the exo versus endo modes of cyclization are predicted to be as summarized in Table 12.3. The observed results show the expected qualitative trend. The observed preferences for ring formation are 5 > 6, 6 > 7, and 8 > 7, in agreement with the calculated preferences. The relationship only holds for terminal double bonds. An additional alkyl substituent at either end of the double bond reduces the relative reactivity as a result of a steric effect. 

The steric requirements of the enhanced interaction between arylsulfinyl or arylsulfonyl groups and the benzene ring in bis(4-hydroxyphenyl)sulfoxides or sulfones were examined by Oae and colleagues through the introduction of methyl groups in two or four of the positions ortho to SO or S02. As in the work described earlier for S02Me, effective values for the combined influence of the substituents o (obs.) were determined and compared with o (calc.) computed on the basis of strict additivity of substituent effects on the dissociation... 

Various phenallcylamines were shown to produce either DOM-like or AMPH-like stimulus effects the structure-activity requirements for these activities are different from the standpoints of aromatic substitution patterns, terminal amine substituents, and optical activity. Thus, it has been possible to formulate two distinct SARs. It should be realized, however, that phenalkylamines need not produce only one of these two types of effects certain phenallcylamines can produce pharmacological effects like neither DOM nor AMPH. Moreover, they can produce effects that are primarily peripheral, not central, in nature (Glennon 1987a). The fact that an agent produced DOM- or AMPH-like effects does not imply that it carmot produce an additional effect conversely, if an agent does not produce either DOM- or AMPH-like stimulus effects, it is not necessarily inactive. 

Another type of steric effect results from interactions between diene substituents. Adoption of the s-cis conformation of the diene in the TS brings the d.v-oricnlcd 1- and 4-substituents on a diene close together. /(-1,3-Pcnladicnc is 103 times more reactive than 4-methyl-l,3-pentadiene toward the very reactive dienophile tetracyanoethylene. This is because the unfavorable interaction between the additional methyl substituent and the C(l) hydrogen in the s-cis conformation raises the energy of the TS.20... 

It is still not clear whether steric constraints can modify the magnitude of bromine bridging. There is at least one example that suggests that this is possible. Non-additive kinetic substituent effects and cis-dibromoadducts imply that the intermediate of cis-cyclooctene bromination in methanol is a /J-bromocarbocation (Dubois and Fresnet, 1974). 

The additivity of substituent effects, demonstrated by (16), was the first kinetic evidence for a symmetrical charge distribution in the rate-limiting transition states of alkene bromination. 

Surprising is the absence of evidence for additional stability of 85 over 83. Electron donation from the electron-rich a bonds of the cyclopropyl ring to the carbene s vacant p orbital is widely believed to stabilize cyclopropylcarbenes.4 One would therefore expect 85, with an additional cyclopropyl substituent, to react more slowly than either parent carbene 83 or dimethylcarbene, but all three lifetimes are comparable. The lifetimes of 83-85 need to be redetermined in inert (fluorocarbon) solvents in order to reveal their innate differences. Note, however, that the effect of cyclopropyl substitution is apparent upon comparison of 83 (r 24 ns) to MeCH (r < 0.5 ns).89110... 

Other papers in the series Chemometrical Analysis of Substituent Effects are on additivity of substituent effects in dissociation of 3,4-178 or 3,5-179disubstituted benzoic acids in organic solvents and on the ort/zo-effect180. In the last-mentioned, data for the dissociation of ortto-substituted benzoic acids in 23 solvents are combined with data on the reactions with DDM (Section IV.C) and with other rate and equilibrium data bearing on the behaviour of o/t/ o-substituents to form a matrix involving data for 69 processes and 29 substituents. 

Now we turn to a discussion of the influence of a-substitution at C(6) or C(7) on the chemical reactivity of the lactam ring (Table 5.4,B). This substitution has been introduced mainly to improve lactamase stability (see Sect. 5.2.2.2). The insertion of an additional a-substituent at C(6) or C(7) of penicillins or cephalosporins, respectively, has a relatively small effect on the rate of base hydrolysis [82] [83], 6a-Methoxypenicillin is hydrolyzed at a rate that is approximately half that observed for the unsubstituted parent penicillin. This decrease is due mainly to unfavorable steric interaction between the... 

It is clear that any kind of addition polymerization of the norbornenyl double bond will benefit from the electronic stabilization provided by a conjugating substituent. A simple radical addition process such as is known for both styrene and acrylate monomers may be a reasonable analogy to our system. Whether this effect alone is enough to account for our observations is not clear. A possible additional effect, at least in the case of the phenyl substituted monomers, is suggested below as part of our work on polymer structure. 

It is evident from the data in Table 6 that, with only one exception (entry 13), the combination of two captor or two donor substituents does not produce an additive effect, whereas, without exception, the captodative combinations display synergetic behaviour. Thus, the delocalization of the unpaired spin density in captodative radicals is markedly increased in comparison to pure additive superposition of capto and dative effects. This result is all the more significant since two identical substituents do not... 

The experimental result seems to support this model. Table 11 lists values for rotational barriers in some allyl radicals (Sustmann, 1986). It includes the rotational barrier in the isomeric 1-cyano-l-methoxyallyl radicals [32]/ [33] (Korth et al., 1984). In order to see whether the magnitude of the rotational barriers discloses a special captodative effect it is necessary to compare the monocaptor and donor-substituted radicals with disubstituted analogues. As is expected on the basis of the general influence of substituents on radical centres, both captor and donor substituents lower the rotational barrier, the captor substituent to a greater extent. Disubstitution by the same substituent, i.e. dicaptor- and didonor-substituted systems, do not even show additivity in the reduction of the rotational barrier. This phenomenon appears to be a general one and has led to the conclusion that additivity of substituent effects is already a manifestation of a special behaviour, viz., of a captodative effect. The barrier in the 1-cyano-l-methoxyallyl radicals [32]/... 

---