The collision hypothesis

We have seen that the radiation hypothesis is not supported by experiment and that it can not be used to explain the fact that unimolecular reaction rates are uninfluenced by collisions. When investigators found this avenue of explanation closed they resumed consideration of the collision hypothesis. As early as 1922 Lindemann suggested that since a time interval exists between activation, of a molecule and its dissociation the apparent connection between the two phenomena would ordinarily be lost. This view was received with increasing favor as the radiation hypothesis became more and more discredited. Rodebush7 in 1923 howed that the known facts could be explained on the basis of collisions 

Lindemann s suggestion was amplified in 1926 by Hinshel-wood8 and by Fowler and Rideal.9 Independently and practically simultaneously Rice and Ramsperger10 proposed the fairly complete mathematical treatment for the collision theory which accounted for all the facts and predicted quantitatively the decrease in reaction velocity constant at decreased pressures. Kassel11 amplified these theories still further and introduced a refinement based on the quantum theory. 

These concepts may be transferred to gas phase reactions by imagining that the pump corresponds to the activation of molecules by collision, that the overflow pipe corresponds to the deactivation of activated molecules by collision, and that the discharge 

The mathematical approach to the collision theory is better. If the initial molecules are represented by A, activation is produced according the reaction 

The activated molecule A may become deactivated or it may decompose to give the products B with a specific reaction rate fa, thus 

---

This time, the collision hypothesis is conserved in the energetic sense and involves two reactant molecules forming the activated complex, but the latter only contains one molecule A, and the second molecule is used to transfer energy. The crossing of the pass will therefore lead to the reaction product provided a transmission coefficient exists. We will later return to this. Thus, the elementary reaction will be represented by ... 

Vacuum Flow When gas flows under high vacuum conditions or through very small openings, the continuum hypothesis is no longer appropriate if the channel dimension is not very large compared to the mean free path of the gas. When the mean free path is comparable to the channel dimension, flow is dominated by collisions of molecules with the wall, rather than by colhsions between molecules. An approximate expression based on Brown, et al. J. Appl. Phys., 17, 802-813 [1946]) for the mean free path is... 

During the early years of physieal ehemistry, Ostwald did not believe in the existence of atoms... and yet he was somehow ineluded in the wild army of ionists. He was resolute in his scepticism and in the 1890s he sustained an obscure theory of energetics to take the place of the atomic hypothesis. How ions could be formed in a solution containing no atoms was not altogether clear. Finally, in 1905, when Einstein had shown in rigorous detail how the Brownian motion studied by Perrin could be interpreted in terms of the collision of dust motes with moving molecules (Chapter 3, Section 3.1.1), Ostwald relented and publicly embraced the existence of atoms. 

Assuming the contribution of the potential energy curves which have not been taken into account to be almost constant with the collision energy, such calculations could provide a relative estimate of the variation of the double capture cross-sections with the collision energy. The results presented in Fig. 7 seem to be coherent with this hypothesis and to corroborate a cascade effect for the double electron capture process. 

The earlier assumption that Luna was a body which had been captured by the Earth can now be regarded as relatively unlikely. The same is true for the double planet hypothesis , according to which Luna and the Earth were formed at the same time from condensing primordial matter (Taylor, 1994). There are, however, still disagreements on the point in time at which the collision occurred and on the masses and the physical states of the heavenly bodies involved (Halliday and Drake, 1999). 

Lewis wrote to Paul Ehrenfest that he thought he had "hit upon something pretty fundamental." But Lewis had difficulty publishing his paper, "On the Theory of Reaction Rate," which the editor and referees of the Journal of the American Chemical Society worried was too speculative and insufficiently oriented toward experimental verification.96 Lewis ended by rejecting the radiation hypothesis, even issuing a press release to announce that a decision now had been made between the two rival theories of violent collision and radiation absorption in favor of the former. 97... 

Hypothesizing Write a hypothesis using the collision theory, reaction rate, and reactant concentration to explain your results. 

If the original hypothesis of Chapman and his collaborators is correct, namely that the excited chlorine molecules are deactivated by simple collision with oxygen independently of the water formation, then the fact that oxygen has a specific effect different from other foreign gases is very important. It is, indeed, a problem of very general importance whether such specific transfers of energy are common. The assumption that they are not... 

The Boltzmann //-theorem generalizes the condition that with a state ol a system represented by its distribution function /. a quantity H. defined as the statistical average of In /, approaches a minimum when equilibrium is reached. This conforms lo the Boltzmann hypothesis of distribution in the above in that S = —kH accounts for equilibrium as a consequence of collisions which change the distribution toward that of equilibrium conditions. 

Energy-resolved rate constant measurements near the threshold for diplet methylene formation from ketene have been used to provide confirmation of the fundamental hypothesis of statistical transition state theory (that rates are controlled by the number of energetically accessible vibrational states at the transition state).6 The electronic structure and aromaticity of planar singlet n2-carbenes has been studied by re-election coupling perturbation theory.7 The heats of formation of three ground-state triplet carbenes have been determined by collision-induced dissociation threshold analysis.8 The heats of formation of methylene, vinylcarbene (H2C=CHCH), and phenylcarbene were found to be 92.2 3.7, 93.3 3.4, and 102.8 33.5 kcal mol-1, respectively. 

The BE was found intuitively. Here, the hypothesis of molecular chaos, that is, the assumption that any pair of particles enters the collision process uncorrelated (statistical independence) is the most important one. Only this assumption allows the formulation of a closed equation for the single-particle distribution function. 

Because low amplitude RF burst waveforms do not significantly modify the z-mode amplitudes of ions, the intensities would be expected to reflect the z-mode amplitude distribution just before excitation. This gives us one means of checking the above hypothesis by allowing the z-mode amplitudes to relax via ion-molecule collisions, the relative peak intensities should change. Indeed, at long delay, the high frequency peak increases at the expense of the low frequency peak. 

The most natural source of energy for the activation of molecules is molecular collision, but since the rate is independent of the number of collisions it would appear at first sight that the simple collision mechanism can not be responsible for the activation. Three hypotheses have been proposed to account for the activation process the radiation hypothesis, the elaborated collision hypothesis, and the hypothesis of chain reactions. 

We have seen that neither the requirements for activation energy nor the fact that the rates of unimolecular reactions are independent of collision frequency can be explained on the basis of the simple collision hypothesis or the radiation hypothesis. The elaborated collision hypothesis is able to explain them on the assumption of a time-lag in complex molecules between activation and decomposition. In this way a single molecule can collect energy from many successive collisions and store up a sufficient amount for activation. Just because a given hypothesis accounts for the facts, is no reason to consider that the hypothesis has been proved. There may be other hypotheses which will account equally well for the facts. The hypothesis of chain reaction offers a competing hypothesis which up to the present time has been increasing in favor. 

---