Substitution, electrophilic hardness

Frontier orbital theory predicts that electrophilic substitution of pyrroles with soft electrophiles will be frontier controlled and occur at the 2-position, whereas electrophilic substitution with hard electrophiles will be charge controlled and occur at the 3-position. These predictions may be illustrated by the substitution behaviour of 1-benzenesulfonylpyr-role. Nitration and Friedel-Crafts acylation of this substrate occurs at the 3-position, whereas the softer electrophiles generated in the Mannich reaction (R2N=CH2), in formylation under Vilsmeier conditions (R2N=CHC1) or in formylation with dichloromethyl methyl ether and aluminum chloride (MeO=CHCl) effect substitution mainly in the 2-position (81TL4899, 81TL4901). Formylation of 2-methoxycarbonyl-l-methylpyrrole with... 

Careful studies by C. Eabom have shown that electrophilic aromatic substitution of silicon is faster than substitution of hydrogen. Thus a silicon in an aromatic ring directs substitution with hardly any rearrangement. This technique is particularly useful for preparation of specifically deuterated arenes as protolysis (deuterolysis) or aryl silanes is rapid. 

To the extent that the N+ correlation is successful it means that the pattern of nucleophilic reactivity is not influenced by the nature of the electrophilic center at which substitution takes place. On the other hand, according to the concepts of the theory of hard and soft acids and bases (HSAB) as applied to nucleophilic substitution reactions (Pearson and Songstad, 1967) one would expect that a significant change in the HSAB character of the electrophilic center as an acid should lead to changes in the pattern of nucleophilic reactivity observed. Specifically, in substitutions occurring at soft electrophilic centers, soft-base nucleophiles should be more reactive relative to other nucleophiles than they are in substitutions at harder electrophilic centers, and in substitutions at hard electrophilic centers hard-base nucleophiles should appear relatively more reactive compared to other nucleophiles than they do in substitutions at softer electrophilic centers. 

For pyrroles with electron acceptor substituents in the 1-position electrophilic substitution with soft electrophiles can be frontier orbital controlled and occur at the 2-position, whereas electrophilic substitution with hard electrophiles can be charge controlled and occur at the 3-position. 

Nickel catalysts have been shown to promote allylic substitutions with hard organometallic nucleophiles and allylic ethers or acetals as the electrophiles [38, 105, 106]. In a series of investigations, Hoveyda has documented the use of chiral nickel catalysts for asymmetric allylic substitution reactions [38]. A brilliant illustration is the conversion of acetal 120 into cyclohexanone 123 (90 %, 92 % ee) by employment of EtMgBr in the presence of a chiral Ni catalyst prepared in situ from diphosphine 121 (Equation 11) [106]. 

If acetoxylation were a conventional electrophilic substitution it is hard to understand why it is not more generally observed in nitration in acetic anhydride. The acetoxylating species is supposed to be very much more selective than the nitrating species, and therefore compared with the situation in (say) toluene in which the ratio of acetoxylation to nitration is small, the introduction of activating substituents into the aromatic nucleus should lead to an increase in the importance of acetoxylation relative to nitration. This is, in fact, observed in the limited range of the alkylbenzenes, although the apparently severe steric requirement of the acetoxylation species is a complicating feature. The failure to observe acetoxylation in the reactions of compounds more reactive than 2-xylene has been attributed to the incursion of another mechan-104... 

O-Alkylation of A-unsubstituted /3-lactams to give the corresponding 2-alkoxy-l- etines can be achieved by reaction of the azetidin-2-ones with hard electrophiles (trialkyloxonium tetrafluoroborates) followed by treatment with base (cf. Section 5.09.4.3.1) (67JHC619, 69LA(725)124). In contrast, reaction of the A-unsubstituted azetidin-2-ones (73) or their derived anions with a variety of softer electrophiles results in A-substitution, and some representative reactions are illustrated in Scheme 7. 

Reactivity and orientation in electrophilic aromatic substitution can also be related to the concept of hardness (see Section 1.2.3). Ionization potential is a major factor in determining hardness and is also intimately related to the process of (x-complex formation when an electrophile interacts with the n HOMO to form a new a bond. In MO terms, hardness is related to the gap between the LUMO and HOMO, t] = (sujmo %omo)/2- Thus, the harder a reactant ring system is, the more difficult it is for an electrophile to complete rr-bond formation. 

Bromination at 450°C hardly occurs, but when the pumice is impregnated with ferrous or cuprous bromide a much better yield of 2,4,6-tribromopyridine is obtained. When pyridine is brominated at 180°C in the presence or absence of impregnated pumice only 2-bromo- and 2,6-dibromopyridine are formed. These facts are not consistent with an electrophilic substitution, which should take place at the 3-position, On the other hand, the high temperature coefficient of the reaction (cf. Table XV) and the fact that ultraviolet light has no effect on the reaction argue against a simple free-radical sub-stitutiond ... 

Direct fluorinations with elemental fluorine still are not feasible on an industrial scale today they are even problematic when carried out on a laboratory-scale [49-53]. This is caused by the difficulty of sustaining the electrophilic substitution path as the latter demands process conditions, in particular isothermal operation, which can hardly be realized using conventional equipment. As a consequence, uncontrolled additions and polymerizations usually dominate over substitution, in many cases causing large heat release which may even lead to explosions. 

The order is approximate only as it is found to vary slightly from one substitution process to another, depending to some extent on the nature of the attacking electrophile. Thus, hardly surprisingly, substituents such as NR3 will be particularly deactivating in substitution reactions where the attacking electrophile is itself positively charged, e.g. NOz ( c.h,y/ c.h. = 1-5 x 10 8 for nitration when R = Me). 

Bowman has surveyed the reactions of cx-substituted aliphatic nitro compounds with nucleophiles, which undergo either S l substitution or polar reaction (Scheme 5.16).118 The reactions between a wide variety of nucleophiles and BrCH2N02 are shown in Scheme 5.17.119a b All the thiolates, PhS02 and I attack Br to liberate the anion of nitromethane. The hard nucleophiles, MeO , OH, and BH4 attack the hard H+ electrophilic center. Phosphorous nucleophiles attackthe oxygen electrophilic center, and only Me2S attacks the carbon electrophilic center. 

As shown in the previous sections, a (cr-allenyl)palladium species, which is formed from a propargyl electrophile and a Pd(0) catalyst, reacts with a hard carbon nucleophile in a manner analogous to the Pd-catalyzed cross-coupling reaction to give a substituted allene. The results indicate that the reactivity of the (cj-allenyl)palladium species is similar to that of an alkenylpalladium intermediate. Indeed, it was found that the (cr-allenyl)palladium species reacted with olefins to give vinylallenes, a reaction process that is similar to that of the Heck reaction of alkenyl halides [54]. 

There would seem to be two positions one can take with respect to the interpretation of the behavior revealed by Figs 1 and 2. The first, which would undoubtedly be favored by proponents of HSAB, is that the large deviations of the points for soft-base nucleophiles in Fig. 2 show that HSAB considerations do play an important role in determining the relative order of reactivity of a series of nucleophiles in nucleophilic substitutions at different electrophilic centers when those centers differ significantly in their degree of hardness , and that the failure to observe sizeable deviations from the correlation line in Fig. 1... 

In order to clarify the different behavior of anion 2 and 3 (Scheme 4.10) toward DMC, various anions with different soft/hard character (aliphatic and aromatic amines, alcohoxydes, phenoxides, thiolates) were compared with regard to nucleophilic substitutions on DMC, using different reaction conditions. Results were in good agreement with the hard-soft acid-base (HSAB) theory. Accordingly, the high selectivity of monomethylation of CH2 acidic compounds and primary aromatic amines with DMC can be explained by two different subsequent reactions, which are due to the double electrophilic character of DMC. The first... 

---