Silica-alumina, surface groups

Silica, alumina, and silica-alumina surfaces are of great importance for catalysis and chromatography. Reactivity of these materials is determined by the structure of the surface and its relative acidity, and considerable effort is being expended to characterize it. Of particular interest are the surface hydroxyl groups. Among the methods used for their study the most powerful are IR spectroscopy and titration with acid-base indicators. Conventional NMR can cope with the observation of adsorbed species, where a considerable amount of motional averaging is present MAS NMR must be used to study the surface directly. 

The question of the acidity of silica, alumina and silica-alumina surfaces has always been of great interest to catalytic scientists. Previously, transmision infrared spectroscopy, particularly of pyridine adsorption, has been used to distinguish the presence of Lewis and Bronsted acid sites on oxide surfaces (24). The frequency shift of the surface OH group during adsorption now... 

Until recently, when Peri 155) reported on a model of the silica-alumina surface, there were no detailed models for the surfaces of mixed oxides available. Beside the presence of Br nsted and Lewis acid sites, Peri 156) had proposed the existence of a sites on the Si02—A1203 surface, which he described as acid-base pair sites rather than simple Lewis acid sites. Various molecules, such as acetylene, butene, and HC1, are adsorbed very selectively on these a sites, whereas NH3 and H20 are also held by many other sites 157). To rationalize the formation of these sites, Peri 155) developed a semiquantitative surface model for certain silica-aluminas, which were prepared by reaction of A1C13 with the surface silanol groups of silica and subsequent hydrolysis and dehydration. The model is entirely based on a surface model of silica, which suggests an external surface resembling a (100) face of the cristobalite structure 158). It should be mentioned in this connection that Peri s surface model of silica may... 

Here a surface Lewis acid (denoted by j) abstracts a hydride ion from the methylene group adjacent to the double bond. This mechanism is in accord with the essential Lewis acid nature of the silica-alumina surface and is consistent with the previously demonstrated ability of this surface to abstract hydride ions from tertiary hydrocarbons. Since an alkenyl carbonium ion is stabilized by resonance to a greater extent than is a saturated carbonium ion, it may well be the most stable species which could form in the chemisorption of an aliphatic olefin or its precursor. It seems reasonable, therefore, to presume that such species may be involved in heterogeneous acid catalysis to a greater extent than has been generally recognized. This chemisorption process does not, of course, exclude the more conventional acid addition to the double bond which may occur under suitable circumstances but rather, it introduces an alternate path which may well exert a considerable influence on the overall course of catalytic reactions. Thus, for example, since a substituted ally lie carbonium ion may be converted to a conjugated diene by loss of a proton, it may be an important intermediate in the formation... 

Many solids have foreign atoms or molecular groupings on their surfaces that are so tightly held that they do not really enter into adsorption-desorption equilibrium and so can be regarded as part of the surface structure. The partial surface oxidation of carbon blacks has been mentioned as having an important influence on their adsorptive behavior (Section X-3A) depending on conditions, the oxidized surface may be acidic or basic (see Ref. 61), and the surface pattern of the carbon rings may be affected [62]. As one other example, the chemical nature of the acidic sites of silica-alumina catalysts has been a subject of much discussion. The main question has been whether the sites represented Brpnsted (proton donor) or Lewis (electron-acceptor) acids. Hall... 

Still another type of adsorption system is that in which either a proton transfer occurs between the adsorbent site and the adsorbate or a Lewis acid-base type of reaction occurs. An important group of solids having acid sites is that of the various silica-aluminas, widely used as cracking catalysts. The sites center on surface aluminum ions but could be either proton donor (Brpnsted acid) or Lewis acid in type. The type of site can be distinguished by infrared spectroscopy, since an adsorbed base, such as ammonia or pyridine, should be either in the ammonium or pyridinium ion form or in coordinated form. The type of data obtainable is illustrated in Fig. XVIII-20, which shows a portion of the infrared spectrum of pyridine adsorbed on a Mo(IV)-Al203 catalyst. In the presence of some surface water both Lewis and Brpnsted types of adsorbed pyridine are seen, as marked in the figure. Thus the features at 1450 and 1620 cm are attributed to pyridine bound to Lewis acid sites, while those at 1540... 

Summarizing, it can be said that the existence of surface hydroxyl groups on silica-alumina is beyond doubt. However, in chemical reactions all of the hydroxyl groups behave just like silanol groups on silica. No conclusive evidence for the existence of hydroxyl groups bonded to aluminum ions was ever obtained. The most that can be said is that surface silanol groups are much more stable than A1—OH groups. 

In a volume otherwise heavily concerned with mechanistic questions, the editors have included a contribution (H. P. Boehm) from another sphere of investigative interest which struck us as having the quality of the imported spice to stimulate new interests within the accustomed sphere of catalytic gastronomy. It concerns the chemical nature of the surface groups on a series of materials (e.g. silica, alumina) which happen to be so frequently and universally used by the catalytic researcher. 

In summary, the NMR data indicate that the protons remaining on silica gel and silica-alumina after dehydration at 500° are present as SiOH groups which are distributed randomly about the surface of the solid. 

Halides (chloride, in particular) also react promptly with surface OH groups, as has been shown for [W(=CCMe3)Cl3(dme)] and several inorganic oxides (silica, alumina, silica-alumina, niobia) [5-7]. The same was observed for the reaction of [V(=0)Cl3] with silica in this case, using a large excess of the vanadium complex, one mole of HCl is released per mole of grafted vanadium [8]. 

When a more acidic oxide is needed, amorphous silica-alumina as weU as meso-porous molecular sieves (MCM-41) are the most common choices. According to quantum chemical calculations, the Bronsted acid sites of binary sihca-alumina are bridged hydroxyl groups (=Si-OH-Al) and water molecules coordinated on a trigonal aluminum atom [63]. Si MAS NMR, TPD-NH3 and pyridine adsorption studies indicate that the surface chemistry of MCM-41 strongly resembles that of an amorphous sihca-alumina however, MCM-41 has a very regular structure [64, 65],... 

---