Thermodynamics reversibility

If an appreciable current flows between the electrode and the solution, thus disturbing the reversible thermodynamic equilibrium conditions, the electrode is said to be polarized and the system is then operating under irreversible conditions. 

Definition of Absolute Temperature.— The temperatures of two bodies are proportional to the quantities of heat respectively taken in and given out in localities at one temperature and at the other, respectively, by a material system subjected to a complete cycle of perfectly reversible thermodynamic operations, and not allowed to part with or take in heat at any other temperature or, the absolute values of two temperatures are to one another in the proportion of the heat taken in to the heat rejected in a perfect thermodynamic engine working with a source and refrigerator at the higher and lower of the temperatures respectively. ... 

As we have seen before, exact differentials correspond to the total differential of a state function, while inexact differentials are associated with quantities that are not state functions, but are path-dependent. Caratheodory proved a purely mathematical theorem, with no reference to physical systems, that establishes the condition for the existence of an integrating denominator for differential expressions of the form of equation (2.44). Called the Caratheodory theorem, it asserts that an integrating denominator exists for Pfaffian differentials, Sq, when there exist final states specified by ( V, ... x )j that are inaccessible from some initial state (.vj,.... v )in by a path for which Sq = 0. Such paths are called solution curves of the differential expression The connection from the purely mathematical realm to thermodynamic systems is established by recognizing that we can express the differential expressions for heat transfer during a reversible thermodynamic process, 6qrey as Pfaffian differentials of the form given by equation (2.44). Then, solution curves (for which Sqrev = 0) correspond to reversible adiabatic processes in which no heat is absorbed or released. 

It is very well known that Pt is one of the best metal catalysts for hydrogen as well as for organic oxidations. Nevertheless, a comparison of the electrochemical behavior of hydrogen and any of these organic substances shows large differences. While hydrogen establishes its reversible thermodynamic potential with platinum in an aqueous acidic solution very quickly, the reversible potential of the other fuels could never be experimentally observed. 

Hysteresis was generally observed in the compression-expansion cycles of the force-area isotherms, indicating that the timescale for relaxation of the fully compressed film back to its expanded state was slower than the movement of the barrier of the Langmuir trough. Our studies, like many others, imply that monolayers are metastable and that reversible thermodynamics can only be applied to their analysis with caution. 

The isomers of the simplest allene, 1,2-propadiene 1, are propyne 2 and cydopro-pene 3 (Scheme 1.2). Their isomerization engergies have been measured and calculated [2-4]. Compound 2 is clearly the most stable isomer, 1 lies 2.1 kj higher and 3 about 22.3 kj. Hence in principle, if reversible, thermodynamics of an equilibrium should favor the alkyne. However, several factors can influence this in two ways, i.e. a change of the relative thermodynamic stability, for example by substituents, or a... 

The working of the cell under reversible thermodynamic conditions does not follow Carnot s theorem, so that the theoretical energy efficiency, deflned as the ratio between the electrical energy produced (—AG°) and the heat of combustion (—AH°) at constant pressure, is... 

If we choose a set of standard conditions (cf. Section 2.3) and one convenient half-cell to serve as a reference for all others, then a set of standard half-cell EMFs or standard electrode potentials E° (Appendix D)1-9 can be measured while drawing a negligible electrical current, that is, with the cell working reversibly so that the equations of reversible thermodynamics... 

The foregoing considerations are based on the concepts of reversible thermodynamics the electrochemical cells are considered to be operating reversibly, which means in effect that no net current is drawn. Real cell EMFs, however, can differ substantially from the predictions of the Nernst equation because of electrochemical kinetic factors that emerge when a nonnegligible current is drawn. An electrical current represents electrons transferred per unit of time, that is, it is proportional to the extent of electrochemical reaction per unit of time, or reaction rate. The major factors that can influence the cell EMF through the current drawn are... 

The dissolution reaction is Pt - Pt2+ + 2e and the value of its reversible thermodynamic potential is 1.2 V on the normal hydrogen scale. The evolution of O2 in acid solution at a current density of, say, 100 mA cm, needs an overpotential on platinum of nearly 1.0 V, i.e., the electrode potential would be >2.0 V. It follows feat at these very anodic potentials platinum would tend to dissolve, although its dissolution would be slowed down by fee fact feat it forms an oxide film at fee potentials concerned. Nevertheless, fee facts stated show feat fee alleged stability of Pt may be more limited than is often thought. This is an important practical conclusion because dissolved Pt from an anode may deposit on fee cathode of fee cell, and instead of having fee surface one started wife as fee cathode, it becomes in fact what is on its surface, platinum. 

In order to take into account the spontaneity and irreversibility of real processes (heat always goes from a hot substance to a cold one, but not the reverse), thermodynamics invokes the notion of the entropy S. In statistical terms entropy is defined as the probability of accessible states for each molecule in the system ... 

The stereoselectivity of cyclization reactions conducted under conditions of thermodynamic control can often be reliably predicted by estimation or calculation of the energy differences between the diastereomers of the cyclization product (H) or its immediate precursor (G). It has been shown that, even in cases where the (G) to (H) step is not reversible, thermodynamic control of the diastereomer ratio can be influenced through the use of cyclization substrates in which the neutralization step (G to H) is the slow step, thus allowing for equilibration of the diastereomers of (G). Thermodynamic equilibration of dia-stereomeric products will occur only if the reaction reverses to starting materials (A), or interconversion of the diastereomers of the intermediates (B) or (C) occurs in some other way (e.g. the C to D interconversion can equilibrate diastereomers if E = X). 

Fig. 7. PDC-calibration curves for polystyrene in cyclohexane measured 3> at eight temperatures, as indiciated, and an overall rate of the column liquid of 15 cm3/h (ordinate is normalized as indicated). The 15 °C-calibration curve dyn is measured, whereas the dashed curve 15 °C therm is extrapolated from the measured part of the dyn curve (cf. Fig. 8), and corresponds to reversible-thermodynamic equilibrium of the PDC-column. The difference between both curves shows a pronounced PDC-effect at 15 °C for P = 1082. Elution volume V = Ve and zero volume V0 = are expressed in counts (1 count = 0.51423 cm3). For the definition of r0 see Eq. (5 b)...

Fig. 8. Reversible-thermodynamic regions of the calibration curves from Fig. 7 drawn in detail up to the point of inflexion (ordinate is not normalized here, the intersections with the ordinate are equal to —In r0(T), obtained by a spline extrapolation)...

The reversible entropy change, related to Eq. (7), follows from the statement Gs = Gg of the reversible thermodynamic equilibrium in the column ... 

The pronounced discrepancy between the measured dynamic 15 °C-elution curve and its extrapolated reversible-thermodynamic part, shown in Fig. 7, represents a direct proof of the inadequacy of the reversible Eq. (3) in the dynamic region of the column (PDC-effect). Moreover, the experiment shows immediately that the polymer of the mobile phase has to dissolve in the gel layer within the transport zone to a considerably higher extent than is allowed by the partition function (4) in a reversible-thermodynamic equilibrium between the gel and the sol at the same column temperature. As a consequence, a steady state, i.e. a flow-equilibrium, must be assumed in the system sol/gel within the considered transport zone, governing the polymer trans-... 

It is well known that a flow-equilibrium must be treated by the methods of irreversible thermodynamics. In the case of the PDC-column, principally three flows have to be considered within the transport zone (1) the mass flow of the transported P-mer from the sol into the gel (2) the mass flow of this P-mer from the gel into the sol and (3) the flow of free energy from the column liquid into the gel layer required for the maintenance of the flow-equilibrium. If these flows and the corresponding potentials could be expressed analytically by means of molecular parameters, the flow-equilibrium 18) could be calculated by the usual methods 19). However, such a direct way would doubtless be very cumbersome because the system is very complicated (cf. above). These difficulties can be avoided in a purely phenomenological theory, based on perturbation calculus applied to the integrated transport Eq. (3 b) of the PDC-column in a reversible-thermodynamic equilibrium. 

The concentration c depends on the shape of the concentration profile in the transport zone of Fig. 13. If the perturbation calculus (see Sect. 3.2.2) is applied to the reversible-thermodynamic equilibrium in the zone, and if further the spreading of the zone remains small, then c = vcs with v 1 is approximately valid. 

Entropy Balance Near the Reversible-Thermodynamic Equilibrium... 

The entropy production (150 vanishes in the reversible-thermodynamic equilibrium where all generalized forces and all flows vanish in the system sol/gel ... 

In this case, the system of Eqs. (14) is complete so that the matrix (15e) represents a symmetrical Onsager matrix the equality L12 = L2l with kg = kg then yields the condition of the reversible-thermodynamic equilibrium in the PDC-column... 

The calculation of the phenomenological function a(P T) of the flow-equilibrium from the measured calibration curves, shown in Figs. 7 and 8, is based on a nonlinear fit of Eq. (19) to these curves. It proceeds by the same method 4) as applied to the calculation of the reversible-thermodynamic data from Table 2 in Section 3.1 the phenomenological function a(P T), obtained in this way, is shown in Table 3 b. With this, the relative perturbation, 8Q/K, of the thermodynamic equilibrium by the transport can be calculated according to Eq. (20). 

There are two inconveniences connected with model (a) How to explain in such a kinetic scheme that the transported P-mer does not belong to the gel itself, although it evidently causes the concentration jump c, - c, + 5c, on the sharp boundary surface between sol and gel This dicrepancy only vanishes in the reversible-thermodynamic equilibrium where 5c, - 0 and 5Q/K - 0 for any P however, A - 0 (and not A -+ 1, as should be expected) is obtained from Eq. (27c) in this case, because ks must stay finite and positive in the reversible polymer transport. 

Fig. 18. Arrhenius-plot of the rate constants kg for the retarded polymer transfer from the gel into the sol (full lines), and ks for the corresponding reversible-thermodynamic equilibrium in that transport (dashed lines), see Fig. 17...

Both expressions (29 a, b) reduce to the zero solvation term P = 0 at the theta point, where 8Q/K - 0, kg - kg and e, -> 0 for any P. After eliminating it, the relationship between the chain contributions to the heat of polymer transfer gel - sol in a flow-equilibrium and in a reversible-thermodynamic equilibrium can be obtained ... 

---