Refinement of molecular model

Some common applications of energy minimization in macromolecular systems are relieving strain in experimentally obtained structures, refinement of molecular models, or in search protocols aimed at finding the global energy minimum of the system. 

Biological fibers, such as can be formed by DNA and fibrous proteins, may contain crystallites of highly ordered molecules whose structure can in principle be solved to atomic resolution by x-ray crystallography. In practice, however, these crystallites are rarely as ordered as true crystals, and in order to locate individual atoms it is necessary to introduce stereochemical constraints in the x-ray analysis so that the structure can be refined by molecular modeling. 

This workbook contains over 200 problems that will allow you to build and refine your understanding of chemistry from the molecule s eye view . This is achieved by basing every problem on a set of molecular models that you view and manipulate on your own personal computer. We believe that this combination of problems-i-models will improve your understanding of molecular structure and the relationship between molecular structure and other properties. More importantly, we believe that when you do the problems in this workbook you will gain a much better grasp of the conceptual basis of organic chemistry, and that this will make the rest of your study of organic chemistry more satisfactory and ultimately more successful. 

In Chapter 9, we considered a simple picture of metallic bonding, the electron-sea model The molecular orbital approach leads to a refinement of this model known as band theory. Here, a crystal of a metal is considered to be one huge molecule. Valence electrons of the metal are fed into delocalized molecular orbitals, formed in the usual way from atomic... 

The distance of each reflection from the center of the pattern is a function of the fiber-to-film distance, as well as the unit-cell dimensions. Therefore, by measuring the positions of the reflections, it is possible to determine the unit-cell dimensions and, subsequently, index (or assign Miller indices to) all the reflections. Their intensities are measured with a microdensitometer or digitized with a scanner and then processed.8-10 After applying appropriate geometrical corrections for Lorentz and polarization effects, the observed structure amplitudes are computed. This experimental X-ray data set is crucial for the determination and refinement of molecular and packing models, and also for the adjudication of alternatives. 

As described in Section 9.4, the determination and refinement of molecular conformations comprehends three main methods DG, MD and SA. Other techniques like Monte Carlo calculations have only a limited applicability in the field of structure elucidation. In principle, it is possible to exclusively make use of DG, MD or SA, but normally it is strongly suggested to combine these methods in order to obtain robust and reliable structural models. Only when the results of different methods match a 3D structure should be presented. There are various ways of combining the described techniques and the procedural methods may differ depending on what kind of molecules are investigated. However, with the flowchart in Fig. 9.13 we give an instruction on how to obtain a reliable structural model. 

Using the pitch, symmetry, monomer geometries and other stereochemical constraints, a number of types of molecular model can be constructed. Typical dilemmas are whether the molecular helix is left- or right-handed, whether the molecule is a single helix or coaxial double-helix (and in the later case whether the two chains in the duplex are parallel or antiparallel), or whether, if there are two or more molecules in the unit cell, the molecules are parallel or antiparallel. Solution of a structure therefore involves refinement and adjudication All candidate models are refined until the fit with the measured x-ray amplitudes or steric factors allows one model to be declared significantly superior to the others by some standard statistical test. 

Whenever appropriate, we demonstrate how experimental observations lead to the proposal and refinement of scientific models. The extensive art program helps students to bridge these macroscopic and molecular worlds. 

Each refined orientation of the probe received a correlation coefficient that shows how well it fits the Patterson map of ALBP. The orientation receiving the highest correlation coefficient was taken as the best orientation of the probe, and then used to refine the position of the probe in the ALBP unit cell. The orientation and position of the model obtained from the molecular replacement search was so good that refinement of the model as a rigid body produced only slight improvement in R. The authors attribute this to the effectiveness of the Patterson correlation refinement of model orientation, stage two of the search. 

The phase problem and the problem of arbitration. Fibrous structures are usually made up of linear polymers with helical conformations. Direct or experimental solution of the X-ray phase problem is not usually possible. However, the extensive symmetry of helical molecules means that the molecular asymmetric unit is commonly a relatively small chemical unit such as one nucleotide. It is therefore not difficult to fabricate a preliminary model (which incidently provides an approximate solution to the phase problem) and then to refine this model to provide a "best" solution. This process, however, provides no assurance that the solution is unique. Other stereochemically plausible models may have to be considered. Fortunately, the linked-atom least-squares approach provides a very good framework for objective arbitration independent refinements of competing models can provide the best models of each kind the final values of n or its components (eqn. xxiv) provide measures of the acceptability of various models these measures of relative acceptability can be compared using standard statistical tests (4) and the decision made whether or not a particular model is significantly superior to any other. 

Tests (and no doubt refinement) of this model will require better definition of the structure of the oxidized and reduced derivatives of the OEC. Efforts along these lines are in progress in several laboratories and the prospects for ultimately understanding the molecular details of this reaction seem quite good. 

The next refinement of the model takes into account that the shape of most molecular species differs from being rod-like typical nematogenic molecules are given in Table 4.6-1. The resulting behaviour of such a bi-axial molecule is often associated with hindered rotation, however it can also be understood from a rigid-body model where different moments of inertia lead to oscillations of different angular amplitudes in spite of identical (thermal) excitation and identical repulsive forces (Korte, 1983). This can be summarized by order parameters defined as above but referring to one of the two shorter. 

The driving force behind the rapid development of powder diffraction methods over the past 10 years is the increasing need for structural characterization of materials that are only available as powders. Examples are zeolite catalysts, magnets, metal hydrides, ceramics, battery and fuel cell electrodes, piezo- and ferroelectrics, and more recently pharmaceuticals and organic and molecular materials as well as biominerals. The emergence of nanoscience as an interdisciplinary research area will further increase the need for powder diffraction, pair-distribution function (PDF) analysis of powder diffraction pattern allows the refinement of structural models regardless of the crystalline quality of the sample and is therefore a very powerful structural characterization tool for nanomaterials and disordered complex materials. 

Molecular dynamics methods are primarily used for the refinement of structural models (Li et al., 1997) or the analysis of molecular interactions (Cappelli et al., 1996 Kothekar et al., 1998). In both cases the time scales to be simulated are within range of current computing technology. Another application area is the study of allosteric movements of proteins (Tanner et al., 1993). Molecular Dynamics approaches to protein-ligand docking are described in Chapter 7 of Volume I. 

Molecular replacement is followed by rigid-body refinement of each model, where individual domains have been specified. After a preliminary short restrained refinement of each protein model, the best model to carry forward to subsequent... 

In such studies the form of the N=XY fragments was also subjected to refinement It has been shown that deviations from linear structures, if they occur, should not exceed 10°. However, even such a possibility makes the choice of molecular models quite a complicated problem. The electron diffraction data have been found to be consistent with two sets of parameters for the C1N=C=0 molecule, depending on the assumption of linear or bent geometry for the N=C=0 group. The authors of prefer the bent model since it gives a better fit with the microwave data and the results of semi-empirical CNDO/2 calculations. 

The method of Karle (1980) was used for phasing (section 9.4) as implemented by Hendrickson (1985). Prior to fitting a molecular model, the noise in the electron density map was reduced by solvent flattening (figure 9.16). The interpreted map followed by refinement of the model yielded an -factor of 22% at 1.8 A resolution. 

---