Rates, reaction solvent polarity effect

The solvent dependence of the reaction rate is also consistent with this mechanistic scheme. Comparison of the rate constants for isomerizations of PCMT in chloroform and in nitrobenzene shows a small (ca. 40%) rate enhancement in the latter solvent. Simple electrostatic theory predicts that nucleophilic substitutions in which neutral reactants are converted to ionic products should be accelerated in polar solvents (23), so that a rate increase in nitrobenzene is to be expected. In fact, this effect is often very small (24). For example, Parker and co-workers (25) report that the S 2 reaction of methyl bromide and dimethyl sulfide is accelerated by only 50% on changing the solvent from 88% (w/w) methanol-water to N,N-dimethylacetamide (DMAc) at low ionic strength this is a far greater change in solvent properties than that investigated in the present work. Thus a small, positive dependence of reaction rate on solvent polarity is implicit in the sulfonium ion mechanism. 

Figure 1.18 Solvent polarity effect in an Sn 1 reaction. Increasing the polarity of the solvent stabihzes the charge separation formed in the transition state, lowering the activation energy and increasing the rate of reaction...

The symbol k or K is the rate or equilibrium constant, respectively, for a side-chain reaction of a meta- or para-substituted benzene derivative, and or Kf> denotes the statistical quantity (intercept term) approximating to k or K for the parent or unsubstituted compound. The substituent constant o measures the polar (electronic) effect of replacing H by a given substituent (in the meta- or para-position) and is, in principle, independent of the nature of the reaction. The reaction constant p depends on the nature of the reaction (including conditions such as solvent and temperature) and measures the susceptibility of the reaction to polar effects. Hammett chose the ionization of benzoic... 

Zwitterions [32] and biradicals [33] have been also proposed as intermediates. These mechanistic possibilities were insufficient for rationalizing the lack of correlation between the reaction rates and solvent polarity [14,31], An early theoretical study by Goddard [33] favored a biradical intermediate. However, isotope effect studies [34], the lack of Markovnikov-type directing effects [14,31], and the fact that radical scavengers have no effect on the reaction eliminated a biradical mechanism for the singlet-oxygen-alkene ene reaction. 

The controversy about the timing of bond formation in cycloadditions continues. Although stepwise reactions involving zwitterionic intermediates can be detected more or less reliably by solvent polarity effects on rates, the distinction between mechanisms involving diradical intermediates or no intermediates at all (concerted pathways) is a more subtle one. Whereas the articles of debate were formerly experimental data, the discussion has now expanded into the theoretical realm. 

Kinetic measurements also show that the solvolysis is of the SnI-type small solvent polarity effects were found in the correlation with the ionizing power parameter qts, with a small m value of 0.12, characteristic of a reaction of a cationic substrate to give a cationic product. Furthermore, the rate data show that the leaving group ability of the phenyliodonio group is about 10 times as great as triflate or 10 -fold higher than iodide. ... 

The rearrangement of allylic thiocyanates while also a first-order process shows a much smaller dependence of rate on solvent polarity . The results of the effects of substituents, solvent and salt effects on the rate of reaction seem to indicate that the rearrangement of allylic thiocyanates essentially occurs by way of a nonionic cyclic mechanism , viz. 

In the first step, the carbon centered radical is generated. The second step involves the addition of this radical to the protonated ring. The third step consists of the rearomatization of the radical adduct by oxidation. The rates of addition of alkyl and acyl radicals to protonated heteroaromatic bases are much higher than those of possible competitive reactions, particularly those with solvents. Polar effects influence the rates of the radical additions to the heteroaromatic ring by decreasing the activation energy as the electron deficiency of the heterocyclic ring increases. 

A negligible pressure effect on the diastereoselectivity was also observed for the cycloaddition of the enamine carbaldehyde (81a) carrying an electron-withdrawing group at position 3 and 61a to yield the dihydropyrans 82 and 83 (Scheme 8.21). This reaction was again studied by direct quantitative infrared spectroscopy up to 300 MPa between 45 and 95 °C in different solvents. The activation volume was found to be —(25.1 1.7) cm mol in dichloromethane and —(25.0 + 1.8) cm mol in isodurene. Thus, in this reaction solvent polarity had no influence on the pressure dependence of the rate coefficient in addition, the ratio of the two diastereo-meric products is not changed under high pressure thus the AAV value is very small (AAV < 1 cm mol ). 

In order to establish the mechanism of the reaction, the solvent effect on the reaction of pyridinyl radical with dibromomethane was investigated. As the results listed in Table 1 show, there is no solvent effect on the rate of the reaction. How could one reconcile the formation of a salt with the lack of solvent polarity effect on the rate Since the initial state (Py + RX) is not very polar (pyridinyl radical with a 1-ethyl group is soluble in n-hex ine, BrCH2Br has a dipole moment of ca. 1 Debye), the lack of... 

Solvent Effects on the Rate of Substitution by the S 2 Mechanism Polar solvents are required m typical bimolecular substitutions because ionic substances such as the sodium and potassium salts cited earlier m Table 8 1 are not sufficiently soluble m nonpolar solvents to give a high enough concentration of the nucleophile to allow the reaction to occur at a rapid rate Other than the requirement that the solvent be polar enough to dis solve ionic compounds however the effect of solvent polarity on the rate of 8 2 reactions IS small What is most important is whether or not the polar solvent is protic or aprotic Water (HOH) alcohols (ROH) and carboxylic acids (RCO2H) are classified as polar protic solvents they all have OH groups that allow them to form hydrogen bonds... 

Equation 4 can be classified as S, , ie, substitution nucleophilic bimolecular (221). The rate of the reaction is influenced by several parameters basicity of the amine, steric effects, reactivity of the alkylating agent, and solvent polarity. The reaction is often carried out in a polar solvent, eg, isopropanol, which may increase the rate of reaction and make handling of the product easier. 

A number of investigations concerning the effect of added electrolytes and change in the solvent polarity have been reported (see ref. 25 pp. 17-19 for a more detailed account). The addition of neutral salts causes a large increase in the rate of reaction in both the one and two-proton mechanisms. In addition, the effect of increasing the water content in a dioxan-water solvent, provided that the concentration of water is above a certain threshold value, also produces a large increase in... 

After the discovery of the remarkable acceleration of some Diels Alder reactions performed in water, a number of polar non-aqueous solvents and their salty solutions were investigated as reaction medium. This revolutionized the concept that the Diels-Alder reaction is quite insensitive to the effect of the medium and emphasized that a careful choice of the solvent is crucial for the success of the reaction. The polarity of the reaction medium is an important variable which also provides some insights into the mechanism of the reaction. If the reaction rate increases by using a polar medium, this means that the transition state probably has polar character, while the absence of a solvent effect is generally related to an uncharged transition state. 

We have seen how the polarity of the solvent influences the rates of Sn 1 and Sn2 reactions. The ionic strength of the medium has similar effects. In general, the addition of an external salt affects the rates of SnI and Sn2 reactions in the same way as an increase in solvent polarity, though this is not quantitative different salts have different effects. However, there are exceptions though the rates of SnI reactions are usually increased by the addition of salts (this is called the salt effect), addition of the leaving-group ion often decreases the rate (the common-ion effect, p. 395). 

---