Non-linear free energy relationships

Non-linear free energy relationships and transient intermediates... 

Alternative definitions are an intermediate is diagnosed if the observed rate constant on one side of the break-point in a non-linear free energy relationship is less than that calculated from the correlation on the other side. Another definition is that a stepwise mechanism gives a non-linear correlation with a convex upwards curvature to the free energy line in this case the sense of convexness must be defined. 

Sketch the three main types of non-linear free energy relationships to illustrate a change in mechanism according to the equation, assuming that linear correlations for and have either positive or negative slopes or combinations of both. 

A trap for the unwary is not to investigate fully the cause of the U-shaped non-linear free energy relationship. Young and Jencks [105c] studied the reaction of hydroxide with acetophenone bisulphites (Eqn. 124)... 

If a change in rate-limiting step occurs during variation of a substituent then a non-linear free-energy relationship will occur the separate limbs of the correlation will obey equations of the type (Eqn. 128)... 

Quite early on (p. 361) in this discussion of linear free energy relationships consideration was restricted to the side-chain reactions of m- and p-substituted benzene derivatives. The reactions of o-substituted benzene derivatives, and indeed of aliphatic compounds, were excluded because of the operation of steric and other effects, which led to non-linear, or even to apparently random, plots. 

Non-Marcusian linear free energy relationships (if I may again be permitted that barbarism) provide direct evidence for this type of potential surface in octahedral ligand substitution reactions. Both dissociative (e.g., the chloropentaamine of cobalt(III)) and associative systems (e.g., chloropentaaquo chromium(III)) may have values of slopes for the linear free energy relationships indicating non-Marcusian behavior. 

The maximal concentration of a putative intermediate in the simplest mechanism (Scheme 11.15) may be obtained from estimates of the rate constants using linear free energy relationships. This concentration of the intermediate could then be assessed by a suitable analytical method and, provided there is confidence in the estimated rate constants, the non-observation of an intermediate would be good evidence for excluding a stepwise process. As far as we are aware, this direct procedure has not been achieved but it is relevant to studies of concertedness [11]. 

The procedure adopted to portray the scope and utility of a linear free-energy relationship for aromatic substitution involves first a determination of the p-values for the reactions. These parameters are evaluated by plotting the values of log (k/ka) for a series of substituted benzenes against the values based on the solvolysis studies (Section IV, B). The resultant slope of the line is p, the reaction constant. The procedure is then reversed to assess the reliability and validity of the Extended Selectivity Treatment. In this approach the log ( K/ H) observations for a single substituent are plotted against p for a variety of reactions. This method assays the linear or non-linear response of each substituent to variations in the selectivity of the reagents and conditions. Unfortunately, insufficient data are available to allow the assignment of p for many reactions. It is more practical in these cases to adopt the Selectivity Factor S as a substitute for p and revert to the more empirical Selectivity Treatment for an examination of the behavior of the substituents. 

Linear Free Energy Relationships. - Kibby and Hall studied the dehydration of fifteen acyclic alcohols on a stoicheiometric (HA) hydroxyapatite [Caio(P04)6(OH)2] and a non-stoicheiometric (NHA) hydroxyapatatite for which Ca/P= 1.58. The former gave both dehydrogenation and dehydration but the latter gave only dehydration. In the case of the NHA catalyst the dehydration rate constants correlated with the Taft constants for a-carbon substitution giving p = — 5 at 230 °C, a-propanol being the reference alcohol so that the Taft equation was of the form (equation 2). 

The cause of the scatter is the non-systematic influence of the substituent on the microscopic environment of the transition structure. The linear free energy relationship between product state XpyH (Equation 22) and the transition structure (Xpy. .. PO32 . . . isq) will be modulated by second-order non-systematic variation because the microscopic environment of the reaction centre in the standard (XpyH ) differs slightly from that (Xpy-PO ) in the reaction under investigation giving rise to specific substituent effects. These effects are mostly small. An unusually dramatic intervention of the microscopic medium effect may be found in Myron Bender s extremely scattered Hammett dependence of the reaction of cyclodextrins with substituted phenyl acetates.22 The cyclodextrin reagent complexes the substrate and interacts... 

During the last two decades, our group has smdied solvent effects on the process development in different molecular solvents (aprotic and protic, polar and non-polar) or in their binary mixtures, correlating the kinetic data of this reaction with empirical solvent parameters (E, n, a and 3) through Linear Free Energy Relationship s - LFER s - simple and multiparametric equations. The principal S Ar reactions studied comprise l-halo-2,4-dinitrobenzene or l-halo-2,6-dinitrobenzene as substrates and primary and secondary amines as nucleophiles. For the 1-fluoro-dinitrobenzenes derivatives, the reaction can exhibit base catalysis, which is normally solvent dependent. In general, solvent effects were related to reaction rates, mechanisms and catalysis. These studies were extented employing ILs as reaction media. 

Variation of Substrate Structure. Whereas linear free energy relationships play a central role in the determination of non-enzymic mechanisms, they are much less important for enzymes, for two reasons. First, enzymes have evolved to bind their natural substrates, and substituents introduced in an attempt merely to alter electron demand at the transition state may have many other interactions with the enzyme protein. The result is very noisy Hammett and Bronsted plots. Whereas conclusions can be drawn from non-enzymic rates varying over a factor of 3, with enzyme reactions, to see any trend above the noise it is usually necessary to have rates ranging over several orders of magnitude. 

A mainstay of the classical partition model is the experimental observation that the major thermodynamic driving force for sorption is the hydrophobic effect. The hydrophobic effect results from gain in free energy when non- or weakly-polar molecular surface is transferred out of the polar medium of water 2-4), The hydrophobic effect is manifested by a linear free energy relationship (LFER) between the NOM-normalized partition coefficient (A om) and the w-octanol-water partition coefficient K ) [i.e.. In nom a n + b where a and b are regression constants], or the inverse of the compound s liquid (or theoretical subcooled liquid) saturated water solubility CJ) [i.e.. In AT om = -c In + d. ... 

Ferrari M, Ravera F (2010) Surfactants and wetting at superhydrophobic smfaces water solutions and non aqueous liquids. Adv Coll Interf Sci 161 22-28 Freitas AA, Quina FH, CarroU FA (1997) Estimation of water-organic interfacial tensions. A linear free energy relationship analysis of interfacial adhesion. J Phys Chem B 101 7488-7493 Guerrero MI, Davis HT (1980) Gradient theory of surface tension of water. Ind Eng Chem Fund 19 309-311... 

As in all linear free-energy relationships, the Hammett equation expresses the similarity of behaviour among two or more sets of reactions. Various types of non-linear behaviour between rates and a-values may be encountered and include random deviations due to experimental error, mechanistic change, enhanced resonance and variable resonance interactions. 

Purcell and coworkers obtained good correlations between the IR and H NMR methods by the use of 1,1,1,3,3,3-hexafluoropropanol and phenol as acids . Taddei and colleagues have reported that with CHCI3 as the donor, a free energy relationship is established between the association constants and the H NMR chemical shift values of CHCI3 in the presence of Lewis bases. However, a non-linear relationship has been observed for several other Lewis bases and CHCI3 by other authors . 

Free energy relationships are predominantly linear, even slightly curved plots are rare, and there are several cases where the free energy relationships are linear over very large ranges of rate constant. The existence of non-systematic scatter of data points (see Section 6.4) can make it difficult to demonstrate curvature (or its absence) even when the data points are for structurally similar reagents. 

---