Mirror symmetry elements

Naturally chiral surfaces can be created from achiral crystalline materials. The bulk structures of many crystalline materials such as metals are highly symmetric, contain one or more mirror symmetry elements and thus, are not chiral. Although it may seem counterintuitive, such achiral bulk structures can, nonetheless, expose surfaces with chiral atomic structures. These are planes whose normals do not lie in one of the bulk mirror planes. The classification of the symmetry of surfaces of a variety of bulk crystal structures has recently been reviewed by Jenkins et al. and they have identified all planes in those crystal structures that are chiral [9,10]. As a simple example consider the two surfaces illustrated in Fig. 4.1. These are the two enantiomers of the (643) surfaces of a face centered cubic lattice. 

It is the mentioned symmetry properties additional to the discrete translational symmetry that lead to a classification of the various possible point lattices by five Bravais lattices. Like the translations, these symmetry operations transform the lattice into itself They are rigid transforms, that is, the spacings between lattice points and the angles between lattice vectors are preserved. On the one hand, there are rotational axes normal to the lattice plane, whereby a twofold rotational axis is equivalent to inversion symmetry with respect to the lattice point through which the axis runs. On the other hand, there are the mirror lines (or reflection lines), which he within the lattice plane (for the three-dimensionaUy extended surface these hnes define mirror planes vertical to the surface). Both the rotational and mirror symmetry elements are point symmetry elements, as by their operation at... 

Since the presence of a plane of symmetry in a molecule ensures that it will be achiral, one a q)ro h to classification of stereoisomers as chiral or achiral is to examine the molecule for symmetry elements. There are other elements of symmetry in addition to planes of symmetry that ensure that a molecule will be superimposable on its mirror image. The trans,cis,cis and tmns,trans,cis stereoisomers of l,3-dibromo-rranj-2,4-dimethylcyclobutaijte are illustrative. This molecule does not possess a plane of symmetry, but the mirror images are superimposable, as illustrated below. This molecule possesses a center of symmetry. A center of symmetry is a point from which any line drawn through the molecule encouniters an identical environment in either direction fiom the center of ixnimetry. 

When a molecule is symmetric, it is often convenient to start the numbering with atoms lying on a rotation axis or in a symmetry plane. If there are no real atoms on a rotation axis or in a mirror plane, dummy atoms can be useful for defining the symmetry element. Consider for example the cyclopropenyl system which has symmetry. Without dummy atoms one of the C-C bond lengths will be given in terms of the two other C-C distances and the C-C-C angle, and it will be complicated to force the three C-C bonds to be identical. By introducing two dummy atoms to define the C3 axis, this becomes easy. 

This compound does not possess a plane of symmetry, but it does have a center of inversion. If we invert everything around the center of the molecule, we regenerate the same thing. Therefore, this compound will be superimposable on its mirror image, and the compound is meso. You will rarely see an example like this one, but it is not correct to say that the plane of symmetry is the only symmetry element that makes a compound meso. In fact, there is a whole class of symmetry elements (to which the plane of symmetry and center of inversion belong) called S axes, but we will not get into this, because it is beyond the scope of the course. For our purposes, it is enough to look for planes of symmetry. 

The occurrence of twinned crystals is a widespread phenomenon. They may consist of individuals that can be depicted macroscopically as in the case of the dovetail twins of gypsum, where the two components are mirror-inverted (Fig. 18.8). There may also be numerous alternating components which sometimes cause a streaky appearance of the crystals (polysynthetic twin). One of the twin components is converted to the other by some symmetry operation (twinning operation), for example by a reflection in the case of the dovetail twins. Another example is the Dauphine twins of quartz which are intercon-verted by a twofold rotation axis (Fig. 18.8). Threefold or fourfold axes can also occur as symmetry elements between the components the domains then have three or four orientations. The twinning operation is not a symmetry operation of the space group of the structure, but it must be compatible with the given structural facts. 

In Fig. 18 the transition coordinates (Section 6.6.) of the three calculated transition states are shown for illustration of the above discussion. These eigenvectors give a quantitative picture of the atomic motions (towards the minima linked by the transition states) when crossing the respective barriers along the minimum energy path. As expected the transition coordinates of the Cs- and C2 -conformations are symmetric with respect to the mirror plane and the twofold axis, respectively, indicating the conservation of these symmetry elements during the associated transitions. (The transition coordinate of the Cj-form... 

Collectively, the symmetry elements present in a regular tetrahedral molecule consist of three S4 axes, four C3 axes, three C2 axes (coincident with the S4 axes), and six mirror planes. These symmetry elements define a point group known by the special symbol Td. 

To provide further illustrations of the use of symmetry elements and operations, the ammonia molecule, NH3, will be considered (Figure 5.6). Figure 5.6 shows that the NH3 molecule has a C3 axis through the nitrogen atom and three mirror planes containing that C3 axis. The identity operation, E, and the C32 operation complete the list of symmetry operations for the NH3 molecule. It should be apparent that... 

If we now consider a planar molecule like BF3 (D3f, symmetry), the z-axis is defined as the C3 axis. One of the B-F bonds lies along the x-axis as shown in Figure 5.9. The symmetry elements present for this molecule include the C3 axis, three C2 axes (coincident with the B-F bonds and perpendicular to the C3 axis), three mirror planes each containing a C2 axis and the C3 axis, and the identity. Thus, there are 12 symmetry operations that can be performed with this molecule. It can be shown that the px and py orbitals both transform as E and the pz orbital transforms as A, ". The s orbital is A/ (the prime indicating symmetry with respect to ah). Similarly, we could find that the fluorine pz orbitals are Av Ev and E1. The qualitative molecular orbital diagram can then be constructed as shown in Figure 5.10. 

In the case of MAP, the concept of chirality was used so as to prevent centrosymmetry a chiral molecule cannot be superimposed on its image by a mirror or center of symmetry so that a crystal made only of left or right-handed molecules can accomodate neither of these symmetry elements. This use of the chirality concept ensures exclusion of a centrosymmetric structure. However as we shall see in the following, the departure of the actual structure from centrosymmetry may be only weak, resulting in limited nonlinear efficiencies. A prerequisite to the introduction of a chiral substituent in a molecule is that its location should avoid interfering with the charge-transfer process. 

Finally, reference must be made to the important and interesting chiral crystal structures. There are two classes of symmetry elements those, such as inversion centers and mirror planes, that can interrelate. enantiomeric chiral molecules, and those, like rotation axes, that cannot. If the space group of the crystal is one that has only symmetry elements of the latter type, then the structure is a chiral one and all the constituent molecules are homochiral the dissymmetry of the molecules may be difficult to detect but, in principle, it is present. In general, if one enantiomer of a chiral compound is crystallized, it must form a chiral structure. A racemic mixture may crystallize as a racemic compound, or it may spontaneously resolve to give separate crystals of each enantiomer. The chemical consequences of an achiral substance crystallizing in a homochiral molecular assembly are perhaps the most intriguing of the stereochemical aspects of solid-state chemistry. 

Lord Kelvin lla> recognized that the term asymmetry does not reflect the essential features, and he introduced the concept of chiralty. He defined a geometrical object as chiral, if it is not superimposable onto its mirror image by rigid motions (rotation and translation). Chirality requires the absence of symmetry elements of the second kind (a- and Sn-operations) lu>>. In the gaseous or liquid state an optically active compound has always chiral molecules, but the reverse is not necessarily true. 

The rac-isomers have a twofold axis and therefore C2-symmetry. The meso-isomer has a mirror plane as the symmetry element and therefore Cs-symmetry. For polymerisation reactions the racemic mixture can be used since the two chains produced by the two enantiomers are identical when begin- and end-groups are not considered. Note When catalysts of this type are to be used for asymmetric synthesis, e.g. as Lewis acids in Diels-Alder reactions, separation of the enantiomers is a prerequisite [25],... 

For symmetry determinations, the choice of the pertinent technique among the available techniques greatly depends on the inferred crystallographic feature. A diffraction pattern is a 2D finite figure. Therefore, the symmetry elements displayed on such a pattern are the mirrors m, the 2, 3, 4 and 6 fold rotation axes and the combinations of these symmetry elements. The notations given here are those of the International Tables for Crystallography [1]. 

These symmetries are then compared with figure 4c which gives the live possible DF symmetries as well as the symmetry elements present in the specimen. The second case is particularly interesting. It corresponds to a two-fold rotation inside a disk (named 1r) due to a horizontal mirror present in the specimen. 

The complete charge array is built by the juxtaposition of this cell in three dimensions so that to obtain a block of 3 x 3 x 3 cells, the cluster being located in the central cell. In that case the cluster is well centered in an array of475 ions. Practically and for computational purposes, the basic symmetry elements of the space group Pmmm (3 mirror planes perpendicular to 3 rotation axes of order 2 as well as the translations of the primitive orthorhombic Bravais lattice) are applied to a group of ions which corresponds to 1/8 of the unit cell. The procedure ensures that the crystalline symmetry is preserved. 

The elements of mirror symmetry d, m, and c can be removed in different ways, resulting in different classes of chiral polymers. Plane d containing the polymer chain is eliminated by the presence, in the main chain, of tertiary carbon atoms —CHR—), or of quaternary atoms with different substituents (—CR R"—), or with equal chiral substituents (—CR R —). Mirror glide plane c does not exist in isotactic structures, nor in syndiotactic ones in which the substituents are chiral and of the same configuration, 75 (33, 263). The perpendicular planes, m, are eliminated by the presence of chiral substituents of the same sign in syndiotactic, 75 (33, 263) or isotactic structures, 76 (263) or if the two directions of the chain are rendered nonreflective. This last condition can be realized in different ways some of which follow (264) ... 

Separating the even and odd components of the function F, by means of the projection operators F- and F produces functions that transform according to irreducible representations Ag and A of the group Ci, which consists of symmetry elements E and i. An analogous technique could be used to con-stmct functions symmetric and antisymmetric with respect to a mirror plane or a dyad. 

The elementary unit cell can be quite easily described starting from the four mineral ion sites of the crystal F, Ca f+, Ca(ll)2+ and P04 , where the symbols I and II represent the two different crystallographic sites of the cations, with the application of all the symmetry operations relevant to the space group P63/m. Among the principal symmetry elements, one can cite mirror planes perpendicular to the c-axis (at z = 1/4 and 3/4), which contain most of the ions of the structure (F , Ca +(ll), P04 ), three-fold axes parallel to the c-axis (at x = 1/3, y = 2/3 and x = 2/3, y = 1/3) along which are located the Ca + (I) ions, screw axes 63 at the corners of the unit cell and parallel to the c-axis and screw axes 2i parallel to the c-axis and located at the midpoints of the cell edges and at the centre of the unit cell itself [3]. 

Leucophane is a relatively rare berylhum silicate. Of interest are the trace amounts of rare earth elements in its chemistry, especially cerium which substitutes for some calcium. Its true symmetry is triclinic, pedion class which is the lowest symmetry possible in a three dimensional system. The only symmetry element is translational shift as it lacks any mirrors, rotations, or even a center. The symmetry is noted by a 1. Ce ", Eu +, Sm +, Dy +, Tb ", Nd " " and Mn " centers characterize steady-state luminescence spectra of leucophane (Gorobets and Rogojine 2001). Time-resolved luminescence spectra contain additionally Eu and Tm " " centers (Fig. 4.25). 

If the molecule contains symmetry elements such as a mirror plane (cr) or a twofold rotation axis (C2), additional tools in NMR spectroscopy are available (see Section 4.I.3.4.)313. 

Actions such as rotating a molecule are called symmetry operations, and the rotational axes and mirror planes possessed by objects are examples of symmetry elements. 

Few measurements or calculations of all 16 scattering matrix elements have been reported. There are only four nonzero independent elements for spherical particles and six for a collection of randomly oriented particles with mirror symmetry (Section 13.6). It is sometimes worth the effort, however, to determine if the expected equalities and zeros really occur. If they do not, this may signal interesting properties such as deviations from sphericity, unexpected asymmetry, or partial alignment some examples are given in this section. But we begin with spherical particles. 

For incident unpolarized light to be (partially) circularly polarized upon scattering by a collection of particles, the scattering matrix element S4l must not be zero. It was shown in Section 13.6 that the scattering matrix for a collection (with mirror symmetry) of randomly oriented particles has the form... 

Based on extensive studies of the symmetry in crystals, it is found that crystals possess one or more of the ten basic symmetry elements (five proper rotation axes 1,2,3, 4,6 and five inversion or improper axes, T = centre of inversion i, 2 = mirror plane m, I, and 5). A set of symmetry elements intersecting at a common point within a crystal is called the point group. The 10 basic symmetry elements along with their 22 possible combinations constitute the 32 crystal classes. There are two additional symmetry... 

For example, if two atoms that are related by a plane of mirror symmetry move onto that plane, they fuse to become a single atom. Thus atoms that lie on elements of symmetry (special positions) will occur less frequently in the building block than ones that lie on positions with no symmetry. The higher the... 

An atom that is repeated ma times in the unit cell is said to occupy a general position in the crystal, but an atom that lies on a symmetry element such as a mirror plane will be repeated less frequently because the symmetry operation of... 

The symmetry elements that intersect at a Wyckoff position determine its site symmetry. For example, a Wyckoff position that lies on the intersection of two mirror planes has mm2 (C2v) symmetry (Fig. 10.6(a)) while one that lies at the intersection of a mirror plane and a three-fold rotation axis along its normal has 3/m (Csh) symmetry (Fig. 10.6(b)). An atom lying on a general position has no symmetry other than a one-fold axis which is represented by the symbol 1 (Ci). 

---