Malonic acid, Knoevenagel reaction

Knoevenagel reaction. The condensation of an aldehyde with an active methylene compound (usually malonic acid or its derivatives) in the presence of a base is generally called the Knoevenagel reaction. Knoevenagel found that condensations between aldehydes and malonic acid are effectively catalysed by ammonia and by primary and secondary amines in alcoholic solution of the organic amines piperidine was regarded as the best catalyst. 

In the above reaction one molecular proportion of sodium ethoxide is employed this is Michael s original method for conducting the reaction, which is reversible and particularly so under these conditions, and in certain circumstances may lead to apparently abnormal results. With smaller amounts of sodium alkoxide (1/5 mol or so the so-called catal3rtic method) or in the presence of secondary amines, the equilibrium is usually more on the side of the adduct, and good yields of adducts are frequently obtained. An example of the Michael addition of the latter type is to be found in the formation of ethyl propane-1 1 3 3 tetracarboxylate (II) from formaldehyde and ethyl malonate in the presence of diethylamine. Ethyl methylene-malonate (I) is formed intermediately by the simple Knoevenagel reaction and this Is followed by the Michael addition. Acid hydrolysis of (II) gives glutaric acid (III). 

In a similar way, carbocycles having a quaternary center could be obtained from acyclic unsaturated 1,3-dicarbonyl compounds [206]. Other combinations are the domino hydroformylation/Wittig olefmation/hydrogenation described by Breit and coworkers [207]. The same group also developed the useful domino hydroformyla-tion/Knoevenagel/hydrogenation/decarboxylation process (Scheme 6/2.14) [208] a typical example is the reaction of 6/2-66 in the presence of a monoester of malonic acid to give 6/2-67 in 41 % yield in a syn anti-ratio of 96 4. Compounds 6/2-68 and 6/2-69 can be assumed as intermediates. 

The tandem-Knoevenagel-ene reaction is a powerful tool to synthesize five-and six-membered carbocycles.2 5 The process is exemplified by the diastereoselective synthesis of 4a. Compound 4a has been obtained In both enantiomeric forms and as a racemate according to the procedure described here. The sequence includes the Knoevenagel reaction of citronellal, 1, and dimethyl malonate, 2, followed by the intramolecular ene cyclization of the chiral 1,7-diene 3 to yield the trans 1,2-disubstituted products 4a and 4b. Whereas the thermal cyclization of 3 at 160°C provides 4a and 4 b in a ratio of only 89.7 10.3, the Lewis acid... 

The Knoevenagel reaction consists in the condensation of aldehydes or ketones with active methylene compounds usually performed in the presence of a weakly basic amine (Scheme 29) [116], It is well-known that aldehydes are much more reactive than ketones, and active methylene substrates employed are essentially those bearing two electron-withdrawing groups. Among them, 1,3-dicarbonyl derivatives are particularly common substrates, and substances such as malonates, acetoacetates, acyclic and cyclic 1,3-diketones, Meldrum s acid, barbituric acids, quinines, or 4-hydroxycoumarins are frequently involved. If Z and Z groups are different, the Knoevenagel adduct can be obtained as a mixture of isomers, but the reaction is thermodynamically controlled and the major product is usually the more stable one. 

Trimethoprim has also been synthesized by condensing 3,4,5-trimethoxybenzaldehyde with malonic acid dinitrile in a Knoevenagel reaction, which forms the derivative (33.1.53), which is partially reduced to the enamine (33.1.54) by hydrogen using a palladium on carbon catalyst, which upon being reacted with guanidine is transformed into trimethoprim [52,53]. 

The Pechmann and Knoevenagel reactions have been widely used to synthesise coumarins and developments in both have been reported. Activated phenols react rapidly with ethyl acetoacetate, propenoic acid and propynoic acid under microwave irradiation using cation-exchange resins as catalyst <99SL608>. Similarly, salicylaldehydes are converted into coumarin-3-carboxylic acids when the reaction with malonic acid is catalysed by the montmorillonite KSF <99JOC1033>. In both cases the use of a solid catalyst has environmentally friendly benefits. Methyl 3-(3-coumarinyl)propenoate 44, prepared from dimethyl glutaconate and salicylaldehyde, is a stable electron deficient diene which reacts with enamines to form benzo[c]coumarins. An inverse electron demand Diels-Alder reaction is followed by elimination of a secondary amine and aromatisation (Scheme 26) <99SL477>. 

Titanium(IV) chloride is used as the catalyst in a Knoevenagel reaction between various 2,2-disubstituted 3-hydroxypropanals and malonic acid or its esters. The products are substituted dihydropyran-2-ones (536) (79LA751). The reaction, which occurs cleanly and in good yield, utilizes an excess of the titanium halide and is thought to involve a cyclic complex which undergoes an ester exchange to a lactone complex (Scheme 198). 

The synthesis of 2,2-dimethylsuccinic acid (Expt 5.135) provides a further variant of the synthetic utility of the Knoevenagel-Michael reaction sequence. Ketones (e.g. acetone) do not readily undergo Knoevenagel reactions with malonic esters, but will condense readily in the presence of secondary amines with the more reactive ethyl cyanoacetate to give an a, /f-unsaturated cyanoester (e.g. 15). When treated with ethanolic potassium cyanide the cyanoester (15) undergoes addition of cyanide ion in the Michael manner to give a dicyanoester (16) which on hydrolysis and decarboxylation affords 2,2-dimethylsuccinic acid. 

This reaction type leading to oc,/ -unsaturated acids and esters is exemplified in the Perkin reaction (Section 6.12.3, p. 1036) and the Knoevenagel reaction (Section 5.11.6, p. 681). The Doebner reaction, which is illustrated in this section, is the condensation of an aldehyde with malonic acid in pyridine solution, often in the presence of a trace of piperidine. The reaction mechanism involves the addition of a malonate anion to the aldehydic carbonyl carbon atom followed by the elimination of water accompanied by decarboxylation. 

Compound 85 was dehydrogenated at 300° over palladium black under reduced pressure to a pyridine derivative 96 which was independently synthesized by the following route. Anisaldehyde (86) was treated with iodine monochloride in acetic acid to give the 3-iodo derivative 87. The Ullmann reaction of 87 in the presence of copper bronze afforded biphenyldialdehyde (88). The Knoevenagel condensation with malonic acid yielded the unsaturated diacid 91. The methyl ester (92) was also prepared alternatively by a condensation of 3-iodoanisaldehyde with malonic acid to give the iodo-cinnamic acid (89), followed by the Ullmann reaction of its methyl ester (90). The cinnamic diester was catalytically hydrogenated and reduced with lithium aluminium hydride to the diol 94. Reaction with phosphoryl chloride afforded an amorphous dichloro derivative (95) which was condensed with 2,6-lutidine in liquid ammonia in the presence of potassium amide to yield pyridine the derivative 96 in 27% yield (53). 

Malonic acid itself can react with aldehydes in the presence of piperidine by way of a Knoevenagel condensation. A decarboxylation occurs after the condensation, and this decarboxylation cannot be avoided. Figure 13.55 shows how the overall reaction can be employed for the synthesis of cinnamic or sorbic acid. This reaction sequence occurs under much milder conditions than the Perkin synthesis of cinnamic acids. (The Perkin synthesis consists of the condensation of aromatic aldehydes with acetic acid anhydride in the presence of sodium acetate.)... 

It can be assumed that the small amount of piperidine in the reaction mixture is completely protonated by malonic acid because piperidine is more basic than pyridine. Hence, only the less basic pyridine is available for the formation of the malonic acid enolate D from free malonic acid and for the formation of the malonic acid dianion from the malonic acid mono-carboxylate C. The pKa value of malonic acid with regard to its C,H acidity should be close to the pKa value of malonic acid diethyl ester (p= 13.3). The pKa value of malonic acid monocarboxylate C with regard to its C,H acidity should be larger by at least a factor 10. Hence, the concentration of the malonic acid enolate D in the reaction mixture must be by many orders of magnitude higher than that of any malonic acid dianion. Due to the advantages associated with this enormous concentration D could be the actual nucleophile in Knoevenagel condensations. 

Fig. 13.56. Mechanism of the Knoevenagel condensations in Figure 13.55. The C,H( )-acidic reaction partneris malonicacidin the form of the malonic acid enolate D (malonic acid "monoanion"). The decarboxylation proceeds as a fragmentation of the pyridinium-substituted malonic acid carboxylate F to furnish the ,/Tunsaturated ester (G) and pyridine. This fragmentation resembles the decomposition of the sodium salts H of ,/Tdibrominated carboxylic acids to yield the a,/Tunsaturated bromides I and sodium bromide.

As one sees, not even a single molecule of the most reactive enolate F is present in the reaction flask, and it can be concluded safely that the Knoevenagel reaction does not proceed via enolate F. The second most nucleophilic species is enolate E, and its concentration is 1015 times smaller than the concentration of the least nucleophilic enolate D. The enolate D also does not occur in high concentration, but at least there is 10 s mole of this species for every mole of malonic acid employed. Based on these numbers, it would seem reasonable to assume that the malonic acid monoenolate D is the most effective nucleophile in the Knoevenagel condensation under consideration. 

The reaction under these conditions is sometimes called the Knoevenagel reaction after its nine-leenth century inventor, and presumably uses the enolate anion of the monocarboxylate of the malonic acid. Though this enolate is dianion, its extensive delocalization and the intramolecular hydrogen bond make it really quite stable. 

The catalysts were evaluated in two reactions - the base catalysed epoxidation of electron deficient alkenes),[15] and in the Linstead variation of the Knoevenagel condensation to give 3-nonenoic acid. This reaction utilises malonic acid, and leads to an unusual dehydration, giving the P/y-unsaturated acid, rather than the more typical a,P-enoic acid.[21-24] The product can be used as a precursor to the lactone, which is a flavour component of coconut oil. 

The second reaction type investigated is the Linstead-Knoevenagel condensation of malonic acid with heptanal (Scheme 4). The product from this is a precursor to the lactone, a component of coconut oil. 

Isatins fail to yield Knoevenagel condensation products with malonic acid419. However, malonic acid can be condensed with isatin in a mixture of ethanol and pyridine, in which the initial condensation product suffers decarboxylation, furnishing an acetic acid derivative. This can be converted to the acid chloride and submitted to a Friedel-Crafts acylation reaction, yielding acetophenone derivatives420. Alternatively the oxoindolinylidene acetic acid derivative can be treated with an arene in the presence of AICI3 to yield. sy />o[indoline-3,3 -indan]-2,l-dione derivatives. ... 

The first reaction is easier not only because it is a Knoevenagel reaction and not a Michael process, but also because the C-H bond in ethyl cyanoacetate is considerably more acidic than in diethyl malonate. It should be noted that there are few, if any, examples of shape-selectivity with such base catalysts. 

Selenophene-2-aldehyde takes part in the Hantzsch synthesis [Eq. (I)]108 and reacts readily with ammonia, aromatic amines and diamines,109 hippuric, barbituric, and malonic acids, malononitrile,70 and rhodanine.109 /3-(Selenien-2-yl)acrylic acid has been obtained from selenophene-2-aldehyde by the Perkin reaction and by Knoevenagel condensation with malonic acid.70 Esters of /9-(selenien-2-yl)acrylic acid are easily formed by condensation of the aldehyde... 

Substituted malonic acids are obtained by alkaline hydrolysis of alkyl-cyano esters prepared either by direct alkylation or by reduction of unsaturated cyano esters from the Knoevenagel reaction. ... 

---