Introducing the Organic HACCP project

5 Benefits and drawbacks of using CCP-based systems at the level of a supply chain 

From the consumer s perspective, cost is an important characteristic of the food and the best buy is the product that is considered to have the best ratio of quality and price. So consumers should welcome any measure that will improve quality at no extra cost or reduce the cost at no reduction in quality. In principle, using a CCP-based system at the level of a supply chain is supposed to do just that, since it will ensure that the controls are taking place at the steps where they can be implemented most effectively, thus eliminating superfluous double or triple testing of the same thing, or unnecessary waste when food is discarded because its safety is uncertain. 

For example, protection of the milk supply from contamination with antibiotics can be done at a relatively low cost at the farm, where the main costs are recurrent costs related to ensuring that the milk from treated cows 

If both the farms and the dairy are covered by a reliable control system, the everyday monitoring will take place at the optimal CCP at the farm and analysis of milk samples at the dairy will only be needed at low frequency for verification of the system (Principle 6). This will ensure that there are no antibiotic residues in the milk sold by the dairy, with minimal expenses for control. In fact, the most expensive item will be the cost of the unannounced inspections at the farms to monitor the integrity of the system. However, if not all the farms are covered by a sufficiently good control system, the dairy will have to add the extra costs of its own independent system, in order to be able to take responsibility for this quality aspect. So the main benefit of a supply chain-based system is that it provides full control at the lowest cost. The main drawback is that the more entities that are involved, the greater is the risk that one of them will experience a system failure and this can have disastrous consequences for all those other entities that rely on the defaulting entity for their product control. 

---