Indirect Empirical Approach

Several equations and empirical relationships have been formulated in an attempt to relate the apparent LNAPL thickness as measured in a monitoring well to that which actually exists in the adjacent formation. These indirect empirical approaches are summarized in Table 6.3 and discussed below. 

FIGURE 6.9 Causes for discrepancies in apparent DNAPL thickness as measures in a monitoring well in comparison with actual thickness in the formation. 

CONCAWE Factor Ranges for Various Petroleum Products 

0 Derived from NIPER 1981 diesel fuel survey. d Derived from NIPER heating oil surveys of 1981, 1982, and 1986. 

Source All data derived from various topical reports by the National Institute for Petroleum and Energy Research (NIPER), P. O. Box 2128, Bartlesville, OK 74005 modified after Gruse (1967) and Hampton (1989). 

---

Various approaches and techniques have been used for the determination of the actual thickness of LNAPL in the subsurface. These approaches essentially fall into two groups indirect empirical and direct field approaches. Both of these are further discussed in the following subsections. 

The main modes of economic evaluation have a common aim in their approach to cost measurement, which—if a societal perspective is adopted (the most appropriate in mental health contexts see below)—is to range widely across all direct and indirect costs (Table 1.1). Every resource impact and every opportunity cost are to be included. The types of evaluation differ with respect to their measurement of outcomes. In seeking to turn these economic evaluative principles into empirical studies a number of practical decisions must be taken. A fuller account of the following discussion is provided by, for example, Drummond et al (1997) and Gold et al (1996). 

A number of investigations have found that personality disorders are not very distinct from each other (on both conceptual and empirical levels) or from normal personality (Clark Watson, 1999). The lack of distinctiveness from normal personality presents a fundamental challenge to the categorical approach. However, most of this evidence is indirect (e.g., lack of clear bimodality in the distribution of scores on personality disorder criteria). Taxometrics is unique in its potential to provide direct empirical evidence that can help resolve the discontinuity question. Surprisingly, only one taxometric study has been conducted on this topic to date. 

For the van der Waals component no such analytical theory exists. Aqvist and co-workers assumed that a similar linear treatment would work for these interactions but with a different empirical factor, to be determined from calibration experiments. There was some indirect evidence that this approach would be reasonable. For example, the experimental free energies of solvation for various hydrocarbons (e.g. n-alkanes) depend in an approximately linear fashion on the length of the carbon chain. In addition, the mean van der Waals solute-solvent energies from molecular dynamics simulations did show a linear variation with chain length (the slope of the line varying according to the solvent). 

Empirical equilibrium coupling constants can be compared as a benchmark with calculated equilibrium coupling constants obtained with various methods. A comparison of these empirical equilibrium constants with calculated equilibrium constants suggested that the restricted-active-space self-consistent field (RASSCF) method is the best approach for calculating the indirect nuclear spin-spin coupling constants of small molecules, and that the second-order polarization propagator approximation (SOPPA) and DFT are similar in performance. 

In scientific work the problem of determining or predicting an obscure property of an object or an event often arises. The property is called obscure because only indirect measurements can be made that are known or supposed to be related to the property in question. If a theoretical relationship between the measurements and the property is not completely known a method of data interpretation may be used which is sometimes called "educated guess" C1533. In this approach an empirical relationship is derived from a collection of objects for which the interesting property and the indirect measurements are known. This relationship is then used to predict the obscure property of unknown objects. 

One way to reduce the computational cost of DFT (or WFT) calculations is to recognize that the core electrons of an atom have only an indirect influence on the atom chemistry. It thus makes sense to look for ways to precompute the atomic cores, essentially factoring them out of the larger electronic structure problem. The simplest way to do this is to freeze the core electrons, or to not allow their density to vary from that of a reference atom. This frozen core approach is generally more computationally efficient. One class of frozen core methods is the pseudopotential (PP) approach. The pseudopotential replaces the core electrons with an effective atom-centered potential that represents their influence on valence electrons and allows relativistic effects important to the core electrons to be incorporated. The advent of ultrasoft pseudopotentials (US-PPs) [18] enabled the explosion in supercell DFT calculations we have seen over the last 15 years. The projector-augmented wave (PAW) [19] is a less empirical and more accurate and transferable approach to partitioning the relativistic core and valence electrons and is also widely used today. Both the PP and PAW approaches require careful parameterizations of each atom type. 

An empirical pseudopotential method (EPM) calculation (23) was done to reproduce the gap and the reflectivity spectrum adjusting the pseudopotential form factors. This study led to a minimum direct gap at L and the lowest conduction state was obtained at Ff. A band stmcture calculation using a semi-ab initio approach (10) obtained an indirect gap (Hs Ff) of 2.0 eV and a comparable direct gap (Hs Tj) of approximately 2.0 eV. The minimum band gaps of BP have been reliably estimated from the experimental optical absorption. However, the direct band gaps and other excitation energies must be estimated from structure in the optical response versus frequency. The accuracy of the resulting experimental values depends on the correct identification of features in, e.g., the reflectivity with particular transitions between band states. Then the GW results may be more reliable estimates than the experimental direct band gaps. 

A model is developed initially based on the Principal-Agent Theory. The results of the empirical study are incorporated in the development of this model. The model is then employed to evaluate the effects of the instruments on opportunistic behaviour, both the direct and the indirect effects. The indirect effects are evaluated by introducing the construct asyrmnetric information as a mediating variable. The model is then tested against data from a questionnaire-based study. A structural equation modelling approach is employed as this is considered to be especially suited for this purpose. 

---