Ethyl 5-fluoropentanecarboxylate

From a study of the fluoroacetates so far mentioned, it appears that any compound which can give rise to fluoroacetic acid (or the fluoroacetate ion), either by hydrolysis or by oxidation (or both), is toxic. The toxic grouping is thus F-CH2-CO, and any substitution in this radical destroys the toxicity as far as relatively simple compounds are concerned. We had reached this conclusion by May 1943.1 We subsequently showed that esters of / -fluoropropionic acid were non-toxic, whereas esters of y-fluorobutyric acid were shown by American workers to be toxic. In 19442 we reported the synthesis of ethyl 5-fluoro-pentanecarboxylate, F,[CH2]g C02Et (I). This is a stable, colourless liquid and we showed that it possessed very potent toxic properties of the fluoroacetate type. By subcutaneous injection of the propylene glycol solution into mice the l.d. 50 was 4 mg./kg. Methyl fluoroacetate (II) may be taken as a convenient standard (p. 115) and has a l.d. 50 of about 6 mg./kg. for saline solutions, and 15 mg./kg. for propylene glycol solution.3 Therefore ethyl 5-fluoropentanecarboxylate was about 7 times as toxic as methyl fluoroacetate (molecule for molecule).4... 

The very high toxicity of ethyl 5-fluoropentanecarboxylate and its derivatives and the fluoroacetate-like symptoms produced seemed to us to be of particular interest, since by a process of /9-oxidation in the animal body 5-fluoropentanecarboxylic acid would readily give rise to the toxic fluoroacetic acid. Similar remarks apply to y-fluorobutyric acid and its derivatives prepared independently by American workers. The non-toxicity of /9-fluoropropionic acid and its derivatives may, on the other hand, be due to the inability of this acid to give the toxic fluoroacetic acid by a process of /9-oxidation. 

Ethyl 9 fluorononanecarboxylate (VII) was found to be even more toxic than ethyl 5 fluoropentanecarboxylate by injection into rabbits, the l.d. 50 for a propylene glycol solution of (VII) being 0-2 mg./kg. Mice and rats were sbghtly more resistant, but exhibited convulsions of the general fluoroacetate type. On account of the high boiling-point of the material, no inhalation experiments were attempted. 2 Fluoroethyl 9 fluorononanecarboxylate (VIII) was found to be no more toxic than the corresponding ethyl ester by injection into mice. Each had a l.d. 50 of about 10 mg./kg. This anomaly is discussed later. 

---