Enthalpy transition state

In multistep reactions, each step has its own transition state. The step with the highest-enthalpy transition state is the slowest step and determines the overall reaction rate. 

Conformer I has a less crowded, lower-enthalpy transition state than conformer II. Its A// is less and reaction rate greater this accounts for the greater amount of trans isomer obtained from conformer I and the smaller amount of cis isomer from conformer II. 

Because of kinetic control, the intermediate with the lowest-enthalpy transition state (TS) is formed in the greatest amount. Since this step is endothermic, the Hammond principle says that the intermediate resembles the TS. We then evaluate the relative energies of the intermediates op vs. m) and predict that the one with the lowest enthalpy has the lowest AH and is formed in the greatest yield. 

A quantitative theory of rate processes has been developed on the assumption that the activated state has a characteristic enthalpy, entropy and free energy the concentration of activated molecules may thus be calculated using statistical mechanical methods. Whilst the theory gives a very plausible treatment of very many rate processes, it suffers from the difficulty of calculating the thermodynamic properties of the transition state. 

There are available from experiment, for such reactions, measurements of rates and the familiar Arrhenius parameters and, much more rarely, the temperature coefficients of the latter. The theories which we use, to relate structure to the ability to take part in reactions, provide static models of reactants or transition states which quite neglect thermal energy. Enthalpies of activation at zero temperature would evidently be the quantities in terms of which to discuss these descriptions, but they are unknown and we must enquire which of the experimentally available quantities is most appropriately used for this purpose. 

Z7. The cotr arison of activation parameters for reactions in two different solvents requires consideration of differences in solvation of both the reactants and the transition states. This can be done using a potential energy diagram such as that illustrated below, where A and B refer to two different solvents. By thermodynamic methods, it is possible to establish values which correspond to the enthalpy... 

An interpretation of activation parameters has led to the conclusion that the bromination transition state resembles a three-membered ring, even in the case of alkenes that eventually react via open carbocation intermediates. It was foimd that for cis trans pairs of alkenes tiie difference in enthalpy at the transition state for bromination was greater than the enthalpy difference for the isomeric alkenes, as shown in Fig. 6.2. This... 

Fig. 6.2. Enthalpy differences of starting alkenes and transition states in bromination.

The rearrangement of the simplest possible case, 1,5-hexadiene, has been studied using deuterium labeling. The activation enthalpy is 33.5kcal/mol, and the entropy of activation is — 13.8eu. The substantially negative entropy reflects the formation of the cyclic transition state. 

Further studies by Garcia, Mayoral et al. [10b] also included DFT calculations for the BF3-catalyzed reaction of acrolein with butadiene and it was found that the B3LYP transition state also gave the [4+2] cycloadduct, as happens for the MP2 calculations. The calculated activation energy for lowest transition-state energy was between 7.3 and 11.2 kcal mol depending on the basis set used. These values compare well with the activation enthalpies experimentally determined for the reaction of butadiene with methyl acrylate catalyzed by AIGI3 [4 a, 10]. 

The transition-state model is generally somewhat more accurate than the collision model (at least with p = 1). Another advantage is that it explains why the activation energy is ordinarily much smaller than the bond enthalpies in the reactant molecules. Consider, for example, the reaction... 

This correlation between /7-values for rates and equilibria reflects a long-established principle of physical organic chemistry, the so-called Hammond postulate (Hammond, 1955 see also Farcasiu, 1975). This postulate states that in a series of related reactions the transition state becomes more product-like as the positive enthalpy differences between reagents and products increase. 

When Wiberg and Pracht (1972b) synthesized 3,3-di-(trimethylsilyl)-l-phenyltri-azene by reacting benzenediazonium chloride with sodium di-(trimethylsilyl)amide they found a faintly yellow compound if the reaction was carried out at -78 °C and an orange form at — 20 °C. NMR spectra were consistent with (Z)/( )-stereoiso-merism. Measurement of the isomerization rates at various temperatures in ether and in pentane indicates that the mechanism involves an inversion transition state (13.5) and not a rotation, because the free reaction enthalpies are independent of the polarity of the solvent. 

The possibility of an entropy-enthalpy relationship for the reaction was examined and found to give a correlation coefficient of only 0.727 which was however improved to 0.971 if only the external contributions to these parameters were used, i.e. these contributions arising from solvent interactions only. If compounds with substituents ortho to the amino group were excluded, this further improved to 0.996 and is likely therefore to be real [cf. the comments on p. 9). It was argued that the different amounts of desolvation of the aromatic on going to the transition state would depend upon the substituent, and that the resultant greater freedom for solvent molecules would mean decreased interaction energy or increased enthalpy so that the linear relationship follows. 

Some quantities associated with the rates and mechanism of a reaction are determined. They include the reaction rate under given conditions, the rate constant, and the activation enthalpy. Others are deduced reasonably directly from experimental data, such as the transition state composition and the nature of the rate-controlling step. Still others are inferred, on grounds whose soundness depends on the circumstances. Here we find certain features of the transition state, such as its polarity, its stereochemical arrangement of atoms, and the extent to which bond breaking and bond making have progressed. 

The activation parameters bring out several features. Note that the activation enthalpy and activation energy for kn, which represents a very rapid reaction, are quite small. Of course, a fast reaction can have a higher activation energy, if the value of AS is more positive, so as to compensate. The activation entropy associated with k is particularly large and negative, as is most often the case for a second-order reaction that occurs by a bimolecular step. In such cases, AS reflects the loss of entropy from the union of the two reaction partners into a single transition state. 

The activation parameters from transition state theory are thermodynamic functions of state. To emphasize that, they are sometimes designated A H (or AH%) and A. 3 4 These values are the standard changes in enthalpy or entropy accompanying the transformation of one mole of the reactants, each at a concentration of 1 M, to one mole of the transition state, also at 1 M. A reference state of 1 mole per liter pertains because the rate constants are expressed with concentrations on the molar scale. Were some other unit of concentration used, say the millimolar scale, values of AS would be different for other than a first-order rate constant. 

Acid-base catalysis, 232-238 Brqnsted equation for, 233-236 general, 233, 237 mechanisms for, 237 specific, 232-233, 237 Activated complex (see Transition state) Activation enthalpy, 10, 156-160 for composite rate constants, 161-164 negative, 161 Activation parameters, 10 chemical interpretation of, 168-169 energy of activation, Ea, 10 enthalpy of activation (A// ), 10, 156-160... 

When equation (9) is applied to the transition state of the biphenyl system, it gives directly the isotopic difference in the activation enthalpy per interacting pair of atoms, provided we make the reasonable assumption that initial-state steric effects are independent of isotopic substitution in the 6- and 6 -positions. Since there are two pairs of interacting atoms in the coplanar transition state, the final expression is... 

It is seen from Fig. 3 that the barrier of the chain-branching rearrangement 9 11 and 12 has about the same height as that of the carbonylation of 11 and 12, if [CO] = 1 mole litre. Under the experimental conditions where [CO] is about 10 mole litre", the carbonylation (decarbonyla-tion) step is rate-determining, however, and the transition state of highest free-enthalpy is therefore the same as in Fig. 2. 

A//, the enthalpy of activation, is the difference in bond energies, including strain, resonance, and solvation energies, between the starting compounds and the transition state. In many reactions, bonds have been broken or partially broken by the time the transition state is reached the energy necessary for this is A//. It is trae that additional energy will be supplied by the formation of new bonds, but if this occurs after the transition state, it can affect only AH and not A//. ... 

---