Electron substituent effects

Fig. 1. Trends in effects of 4- and 5-substituenls (expressed as an a variation of R) on the proiomeric equilibrium calculated using the HMO method. When curves do not cross no inversion of protomeric equilibrium is expected to be induced by electronic substituent effects, 4-R-(----) 5-R-(-----). F,E formation energy (see Table 1).

HMO calculations have been ultilized in the search for substituted thiepins liable to be good candidates for synthesis due to electronic substituent effects.7 Based on these results, the presence of at least two carboxy groups and one fluorine group give an increased resonance energy per electron to positive values, indicating at least some thermal stability. 

Very recently there has been an experimental and theoretical study of electronic substituent effects in 4-aminoaryl (4-substituted aryl) sulfones146. PMR, 13C NMR and infrared measurements were involved and semi-empirical all-valence CNDO/2 calculations, with and without sulfur d orbitals, were carried out. Various correlations between spectral results and substituent constants are presented. There is good agreement between experimental and theoretical data, which does not depend on the inclusion or exclusion of the sulfur d orbitals from the calculations. 

Evidence is provided by this analysis that (a) structural considerations discriminate among at least four practical classes of pi delocalization behavior, each of which has limited generality (b) the blend of polar and pi delocalization effect contributions to the observed effect of a substituent is widely variable among different reaction or data sets (the contributions may be opposite as well as alike in direction), depending upon structural considerations and the nature of the measurement (c) solvent may play an important role in determination of the observed blend of effects (d) it is the first three conditions which lead to the deterioration of the single substituent parameter treatment as a means of general and relatively precise description of observed electronic substituent effects in the benzene series. 

Riichardt, Ch., and Beckhaus, H.-D. Sterie and Electronic Substituent Effects on the Carbon-Carbon Bond. 130. 1-22(1985). 

While tocopherylacetic aicd (51), the lower Crhomologue of 3-(5-tocopheryl)-propionic acid (50) showed a changed redox behavior (see Section 6.5.1), compound 50 displayed the usual redox behavior of tocopherol derivatives, that is, formation of both ortho- and para-quinoid oxidation intermediates and products depending on the respective reaction conditions. Evidently, the electronic substituent effects that... 

Wedekind and Stauwe" studied the oxidation of 3-substituted formazans and concluded that ease of oxidation depended on the steric effects of the 3-substituent. More recently, Hegoraty et al. 100 studied the reaction of formazans with bromine. It proceeds via an odd-electron species such as 52 favoring an electronic substituent effect (Scheme 5). The rate of reaction increases with electron-donating substituents. Similar conclusions have been reached using thalium(III) as the oxidant.101,102... 

Some time later the feasibility of obtaining 170 spectra for natural abundance samples at relatively low concentration was demonstrated55,56. This was an important step because intermolecular interactions can markedly affect chemical shifts and, if only electronic substituent effects are to examined, then all extraneous influences must be minimized. 

The influence of the solvent on the regioselectivity is perfectly described by FMO theory142. As mentioned above, the regioselectivity is determined by orbital coefficients on the terminal carbons of the diene and dienophile which, in turn, are determined by the electronic substituent effects. These can be modified by electron donation or electron withdrawal by the solvent or additives like Lewis acids. 

Topsom, 1976) and to treat them separately. In this review we will be concerned solely with polar or electronic substituent effects. Although it is possible to define a number of different electronic effects (field effects, CT-inductive effects, jt-inductive effects, Jt-field effects, resonance effects), it is customary to use a dual substituent parameter scale, in which one parameter describes the polarity of a substituent and the other the charge transfer (resonance) (Topsom, 1976). In terms of molecular orbital theory, particularly in the form of perturbation theory, this corresponds to a separate evaluation of charge (inductive) and overlap (resonance) effects. This is reflected in the Klopman-Salem theory (Devaquet and Salem, 1969 Klop-man, 1968 Salem, 1968) and in our theory (Sustmann and Binsch, 1971, 1972 Sustmann and Vahrenholt, 1973). A related treatment of substituent effects has been proposed by Godfrey (Duerden and Godfrey, 1980). 

A detailed comparison of the rearrangement of 1,3-radicai cations and carbocations derived from tricyclo [3.3.0.0 " ] octanes has shown (by eiectron-transfer oxidation and protonation, respectiveiy) that electronic substituent effects on the diyi sites profoundly influence the regioseiectivities of the Wagner-Meerwein 1,2-shifts. The... 

The nature and position of substitution has a profound influence upon the oxepin-arene oxide equilibrium position. The effect of substituents on the relative energies of each valence tautomer has been calculated (80JA1255) and these theoretical results are in accord with the limited experimental data which are available. In general terms, oxepins substituted at the 3-position are less favored than the corresponding arene oxides, while the reverse obtained for 2- and 4-substituted oxepins. This substituent effect has been rationalized in terms of a preference for the maximum number of alternative resonance contributors. The influence of both 7r donating and v withdrawing substituents oh the oxepin contribution is summarized in Scheme 2. This latter effect may be considered as an electronic substituent effect. 

A problem that has challenged chemists for years is the determination of the electronic influence that substituents exert on the rate and course of a reaction. One of the difficulties involved in determining electronic substituent effects is that if the substituent is located close to the reaction center it may affect the reaction by purely steric processes, so that electronic effects are masked if placed far away in order to avoid steric problems, the electronic effects will be severely attenuated. 

---