Density-functional theory limitation

Chapter 6, Selecting an Appropriate Theoretical Method, discusses the model chemistry concept introduced in Chapter 1 in detail. It covers the strengths, computational cost and limitations of a variety of popular methods, beginning with semi-empirical models and continuing through Hartree-Fock, Density Functional Theory, and electron correlation methods. 

Because of the complexity of the pathway, the sensitivity of the reagents involved, the heterogeneous nature of the reaction, and the limitations of modern experimental techniques and instrumentation, it is not surprising that a compelling picture of the mechanism of the Simmons-Smith reaction has yet to emerge. In recent years, the application of computational techniques to the study of the mechanism has become important. Enabling theoretical advances, namely the implementation of density functional theory, have finally made this complex system amenable to calculation. These studies not only provide support for earlier conclusions regarding the reaction mechanism, but they have also opened new mechanistic possibilities to view. 

The attractive potential exerted on the electrons due to the nuclei - the expectation value of the second operator VNe in equation (1-4) - is also often termed the external potential, Vext, in density functional theory, even though the external potential is not necessarily limited to the nuclear field but may include external magnetic or electric fields etc. From now on we will only consider the electronic problem of equations (1 -4) - (1 -6) and the subscript elec will be dropped. 

Efforts to tame the unfavorable scaling of electronic structure methods are not limited to density functional theory. For a general summary of the current state of the art see the review by Goedecker, 1999. 

Becke, A. D., 1999, Exploring the Limits of Gradient Corrections in Density Functional Theory , J. Comput. 

Density functional theory (DFT),32 also a semi-empirical method, is capable of handling medium-sized systems of biological interest, and it is not limited to the second row of the periodic table. DFT has been used in the study of some small protein and peptide surfaces. Nevertheless, it is still limited by computer speed and memory. DFT offers a quantum mechanically based approach from a fundamentally different perspective, using electron density with an accuracy equivalent to post Hartree-Fock theory. The ideas have been around for many years,33 34 but only in the last ten years have numerous studies been published. DFT, compared to ab initio... 

The identification of unknown chemical compounds isolated in inert gas matrices is nowadays facilitated by comparison of the measured IR spectra with those computed at reliable levels of ab initio or density functional theory (DFT). Furthermore, the observed reactivity of matrix isolated species can in some instances be explained with the help of computed reaction energies and barriers for intramolecular rearrangements. Hence, electronic structure methods developed into a useful tool for the matrix isolation community. In this chapter, we will give an overview of the various theoretical methods and their limitations when employed in carbene chemistry. For a more detailed qualitative description of the merits and drawbacks of commonly used electronic structure methods, especially for open-shell systems, the reader is referred to the introductory guide of Bally and Borden.29... 

Bersuker, I. B. On the limitations of the density functional theory in electronic structure calculations, IntJ. Quantum Chem., submitted (1995),... 

If the main limitations of HF theory are overcome by the introduction of electron correlation, those of density functional theory are expanded by the use of more accurate functionals. These functionals, that improve the uniform gas description of the LDA approach, are labeled as non-local or Generalize Gradient Approximation (GGA). 

On the other hand, high-level computational methods are limited, for obvious reasons, to very simple systems.122 Calculations are likely to have limited accuracy due to basis set effects, relativistic contributions, and spin orbit corrections, especially in the case of tin hydrides, but these concerns can be addressed. Given the computational economy of density functional theories and the excellent behavior of the hybrid-DFT B3LYP123 already demonstrated for calculations of radical energies,124 we anticipate good progress in the theoretical approach. We hope that this collection serves as a reference for computational work that we are certain will be forthcoming. 

---