Solvation effects group additivity

The design of novel Lewis acidic reagents for additions to nonconjugated carbonyls, based on structural information, has attracted much attention in recent years. An excellent overview of this subject has recently appeared, in which the mechanistic aspects of and various models for carbonyl addition processes are Wghlighted. In particular, attention was directed towards the ab initio treatment of solvation effects in additions to the carbonyl group. 37 These calculations indicated that in the addition of water... 

The effect of a carboxy group is illustrated by the reactivity of 2-bromopyridine-3- and 6-carboxylic acids (resonance and inductive activation, respectively) (cf. 166) to aqueous acid under conditions which do not give hydroxy-debromination of 2-bromopyridine and also by the hydroxy-dechlorination of 3-chloropyridine-4-car-boxylic acid. The intervention of intermolecular bifunctional autocatalysis by the carboxy group (cf. 237) is quite possible. In the amino-dechlorination (80°, 4 hr, petroleum ether) of 5-carbethoxy-4-chloropyrimidine there is opportunity for built-in solvation (167) in addition to electronic activation. This effect of the carboxylate ion, ester, and acid and its variation with charge on the nucleophile are discussed in Sections I,D,2,a, I,D,2,b, and II,B, 1. A 5-amidino group activates 2-methylsulfonylpyridine toward methanolic am-... 

An experimental Acan be derived from the temperature dependence of the second-order rate constant, which yielded a value of 25.9 kcal/mol.59 Although it appears that this disagrees with the computed free energy of activation (16.6 kcal/ mol) for the reaction of H3N + CH3SH2 in water, the difference actually originates from the intrinsic reactivity of the two reactions. The additional methyl group substitutions both on the nucleophile and substrate raise the gas-phase barrier by 10 kcal/mol to a value of 10.5 kcal/mol at the HF/6-31G(d) level. Taking the methyl substitution effect into account, the computed solvation effect in fact is in accord with experiment,59 which is about 15 kcal/mol (25.9 — 10.5 kcal/mol). 

---