Polarization correlation problem

F. Jordan, M. Gilbert, J. P. Malrieu, and U. Pincelli, Theor. Chim. Acta, 15, 211 (1969). Localized Bond Orbitals and the Correlation Problem. IV. Stability of the Perturbation Energies with Respect to Bond Hybridization and Polarity. 

We consider first the Sn2 type of process. (In some important Sn2 reactions the solvent may function as the nucleophile. We will treat solvent nucleophilicity as a separate topic in Chapter 8.) Basicity toward the proton, that is, the pKa of the conjugate acid of the nucleophile, has been found to be less successful as a model property for reactions at saturated carbon than for nucleophilic acyl transfers, although basicity must have some relationship to nucleophilicity. Bordwell et al. have demonstrated very satisfactory Brjinsted-type plots for nucleophilic displacements at saturated carbon when the basicities and reactivities are measured in polar aprotic solvents like dimethylsulfoxide. The problem of establishing such simple correlations in hydroxylic solvents lies in the varying solvation stabilization within a reaction series in H-bond donor solvents. 

Here kref corresponds to e = , a change from that used in Eqs. (9-29)—(9-30). Because (e - l)/(2e + 1) is proportional to 1/e, except at very low e (see Problem 9-5), these formulations are equivalent. An example of these treatments is presented in Fig. 9-1, which shows the data from Table 9-2, for reaction (9-2). The slope of the plot of ln k versus 1/e is negative, which is consistent with the obvious fact that the transition state is more polar than the reagents. The agreement is not spectacular, but it rarely is in this correlation. The problem is that dipole-dipole interactions are rather small, and other forces (van der Waals and repulsive interactions) are not entirely negligible. 

The main classes of plasticizers for polymeric ISEs are defined by now and comprise lipophilic esters and ethers [90], The regular plasticizer content in polymeric membranes is up to 66% and its influence on the membrane properties cannot be neglected. Compatibility with the membrane polymer is an obvious prerequisite, but other plasticizer parameters must be taken into account, with polarity and lipophilicity as the most important ones. The nature of the plasticizer influences sensor selectivity and detection limits, but often the reasons are not straightforward. The specific solvation of ions by the plasticizer may influence the apparent ion-ionophore complex formation constants, as these may vary in different matrices. Ion-pair formation constants also depend on the solvent polarity, but in polymeric membranes such correlations are rather qualitative. Insufficient plasticizer lipophilicity may cause its leaching, which is especially undesired for in-vivo measurements, for microelectrodes and sensors working under flow conditions. Extension of plasticizer alkyl chains in order to enhance lipophilicity is only a partial problem solution, as it may lead to membrane component incompatibility. The concept of plasticizer-free membranes with active compounds, covalently attached to the polymer, has been intensively studied in recent years [91]. 

Finally, we note that we have mostly limited attention so far to the self-consistent reaction field limit of dynamical solvent polarization, which is the only one that has been generally implemented (see next Section). Nevertheless, there are problems where the solute-solvent dynamical correlation must be considered, and we will address that topic in Section 5. 

It is noticeable that correlation-consistent basis sets are not able to accurately reproduce the bond distances and energies of the excited states in II symmetry, which may be attributed to the relatively inadequate p-space. The problem was eliminated in the case of H-73 basis set. The polarization set that was purposefully optimized to correlate with the 2p orhitals of hydrogen atoms greatly improved the bond lengths and excitation energies, and reduced the errors to be within 100 cmof exact values. 

---