Group theory permutations

The stereochemistry of reactions has to be handled in any detailed modeling of chemical reactions. Section 2.7 showed how permutation group theory can be used to represent the stereochemistry of molecular structures. We will now extend this approach to handle the stereochemistry of reactions also [31]. 

Let us first repeat the essential features of handling the stereochemistry of molecular structures by permutation group theory ... 

Figure 3-23. The treatment ofthe stereochemistry ofa further S,y2 reaction by permutation group theory.

The stereochemistry of reactions can also be treated by permutation group theory for reactions that involve the transformation of an sp carbon atom center into an sp carbon atom center, as in additions to C=C bonds, in elimination reactions, or in eIcctrocycHc reactions such as the one shown in Figure 3-21. Details have been published 3l]. 

The stereochemistry of reactions can be treated by means of permutation group theory. 

The example demonstrates that the concepts in chemistry rely heavily on notions from group theory, specifically the concept, introduced in Sec. 11, of the equivalence of configurations with respect to a permutation group. The cycle index and the main theorem of Sec. 16 play a role. 

The use of the conventional spin formulation in conjunction with a spin-free Hamiltonian HSF merely assures symmetry adaptation to a given spin-free permutational symmetry [Asp] without recourse to group theory. In fact, one may symmetry adapt to a given spin-free permutational symmetry without recourse to spin. This is the motivation behind the Spin-Free Quantum Chemistry series.107-116 In this spin-free formulation one uses a spatial electronic ket which is symmetry adapted to a given spin-free permutational symmetry by the application of an appropriate projector. The Pauli-allowed partitions are given by eq. (2-12) and the correspondence with spin by eqs. (2-14) and (2-15). Finally, since in this formulation [Asp] is the only type of permutational symmetry involved, we suppress the superscript SF on [Asp],... 

For the two-spin system the only symmetry operation is the interchange of the two nuclei, and the correct linear combinations, and could be constructed by inspection. When three or more symmetrically equivalent nuclei are present, the symmetry operations consist of various permutations of the nuclei. The correct symmetrized functions can be determined systematically only by application of results from group theory. We shall not present the details of this procedure. 

A. Cayley was also the creator of the matrix theory he made an essential contribution to the development of the group theory, i.e. those branches of mathematics which were later extensively used in physics and mathematics. Moreover, Cayley was the first to indicate the relationship between the point groups of symmetry and the permutation groups (see Chapter 6). 

Counting indistinguishable reactions. The number of indistinguishable reactions is determined by means of the enumeration polynomial whose coefficients are calculated by the graph-theoretical methods and the methods of permutation group theory. We cannot describe here the procedure of finding the coefficients of the enumeration polynomial, and so we shall consider only several concepts that are necessary for translation of mathematical results into the language of chemistry. 

Thus, valuable information concerning the possible nature of permutation isomerism reactions was obtained only by the methods of the graph theory and group theory, without analysis of electronic and nuclear densities. 

Further arguments of Menshutkin can be easily interpreted in terms of the permutation group theory. Here the number of cycles in the permutation (40) is equal to the number of disubstituted derivatives, i.e. 3 (ortho-, meta-, and para-), and the digits combined in one cycle indicate the numbers of equivalent positions in a monosubstituted derivative. 

The concept of a group had been introduced by Galois in his work on the theory of equations and this was followed up by Baron Augustin Louis Cauchy (1789-1857) who went on to originate the theory of permutation groups. Other early workers in group theory were. Arthur Cayley (1821-95) who defined the general abstract mup as we now... 

With the GT Calculator you can perform a variety of standard group theory calculations simply by entering the appropriate structure details for the molecular geometry. In addition, on the various worksheets of the calculator files, it is straightforward to determine more advanced group theoretical results, such as the numbers of isomers generated for a given structure by decoration, or to calculate and decompose the symmetric and antisymmetric powers of permutation representations. 

Counting the isomers arising by addition to, or substitution in, a basic framework is a mathematical problem with many practical applications in chemistry. In classical organic chemistry, for example, the number of derivatives of a compound was often cited as proof or disproof of structure. Point group theory that uses concepts familiar to most chemists and is easy to apply when the number of addends/substituents is small provides a unified method for deciding, for example, the number of dihydrides C70H2 of fullerene C70, or the number of trihalo-derivatives C2oHi7FClBr of dodecahedrane. All that is needed to determine such matters is the availability of the permutation character. Ter, of the atoms in the parent molecule. 

However, Group Theory can be employed in the following manner. There are N permutations of the graph vertices II, some of them leaving the adjacency matrix invariant, i. e. ... 

Another striking example of a group which leaves a physical system invariant is provided by the set of permutations of identical particles. If we have a molecule with 2 electrons, each of which may be found in either of 2 states, ip a or ipg, it would seem that the state of the whole system could be indicated in symbols by (1) (2) (electron 1 in the A state , electron 2 in the B state ). But if interchanging the electrons can make no observable difference surely u(2)t/>fi(l) (electron 2 in the A state , electron 1 in the B state ) would be equally acceptable - or even a combination of the two What group theory tells us is that the 2-electron system, described as being in state (1,2), must respond to an interchange of 1 and 2 by either (i) remaining... 

The transformed (permuted) state is necessarily in the same polyad as the nontransformed one. This means that permutation operators act by changing the order of the basis states in a given polyad. This is very important because it allows one to obtain the transformed eigenvector explicitly (i.e., the linear combination of local modes) in terms of a simple linear (permutation) transformation. By applying the well-known formula of discrete group theory for the calculation of the character, we can schematically write... 

The discussion in Chapter 4 is focused on symmetry and rigid motions. The notation e.stabli.shed in Chapter 3 for permutations is used in a mathematical investigation of the symmetries of a variety of different shapes. The symmetries of a pentagon form the basts of the very reliable Verhoeff check digit scheme presented in Chapter 5. Furthermore, the use of rigid motions to create elaborate patterns will serve as an introduction to the discussion of group theory that begins Chapter 5. 

---