Differential reaction rate methods

Mottola, H. A. Catalytic and Differential Reaction-Rate Methods of Chemical Analysis, Crit Rev. Anal. Chem. 1974, 4, 229-280. Mottola, H. A. Kinetic Aspects of Analytical Chemistry. Wiley New York, 1988. 

As [R] decreases further, the kinetics again approach pseudo-first-order rates (Region VI), but now with respect to R. As [R] ([A] + [B]) (Region VII), a pseudo-first-order rate again applies, and general differential reaction-rate methods have been developed for this situation. There are also differential methods based on measurements of initial reaction-rates, where the kinetics become pseudo-zero-order. 

Kinetic methods have been classified according to a number of criteria. One classification distinguishes between catalytic and noncatalytic methods (see Table 1). The former are further divided according to the type of reaction involved, while the latter are categorized according to whether they are used to determine a single species or several components in mixtures (differential reaction-rate methods)... 

For determination of multicomponents (differential reaction-rate methods)... 

Differential reaction-rate methods are based on the different rate at which two or more species react with a common reagent and allow the determination of several components without the need for a prior separation. 

Noncatalytic reactions are less frequently used in kinetic-based determinations than are those involving a catalytic effect. However, recent advances in instrumentation mean that noncatalytic kinetic methods are powerful alternatives to equilibrium (nonkinetic) methods. This type of reaction is of especial relevance to the analysis of mixtures of closely related compounds, for which a munber of differential reaction rate methods have been developed. Whether for individual or joint determinations of species, the main field of application of noncatalytic reactions is organic analysis, unlike catalytic reactions, where a metal ion usually acts as the catalyst this has also contributed to their current wide acceptance. 

Very promising is the application of micelles for differential reaction rate methods. Micelles can alter the rate constant ratio of two or more species that interact with a common reagent. Simultaneous kinetic determination of nickel and cobalt based on the complex formation with 5-octyloxymethyl-8-quinolinol in the nonionic micellar medium of Triton X-100 is effective as this surfactant decreases the rates of formation of both complexes compared with an aqueous medium, so permitting their spectropho-tometric monitoring. In the micellar medium the formation of the Co complex is 44 times faster than that of Ni, and determinations of both ions in the lO moll range are possible. 

Perez-Bendito D (1990) Approaches to differential reaction-rate methods. Plenary Lecture. Analyst 115 689-697. 

The reaction rate equations give differential equations that can be solved with methods such as the Runge-Kutta [14] integration or the Gear algorithm [15]. 

Direct-Computation Rate Methods Rate methods for analyzing kinetic data are based on the differential form of the rate law. The rate of a reaction at time f, (rate)f, is determined from the slope of a curve showing the change in concentration for a reactant or product as a function of time (Figure 13.5). For a reaction that is first-order, or pseudo-first-order in analyte, the rate at time f is given as... 

The principal techniques used to determine reaction rate functions from the experimental data are differential and integral methods. 

Prepare a plot of reaction rate (-dC /dt) versus f(C ). If the plot is linear and passes through the origin, the rate equation is consistent with the data, otherwise another equation should be tested. Figure 3-17 shows a schematic of the differential method. 

Differential temperature method. A differential method has been applied to a study of the iodination of acetone, a pseudo-zeroth-order reaction when [(CHj)2CO] [I2].26 It allows the determination of AW to much higher accuracy than otherwise. The reaction rate is expressed mathematically as... 

The inhibition method has found wide usage as a means for determining the rate at which chain radicals are introduced into the system either by an initiator or by illumination. It is, however, open to criticism on the ground that some of the inhibitor may be consumed by primary radicals and, hence, that actual chain radicals will not be differentiated from primary radicals some of which would not initiate chains in the absence of the inhibitor. This possibility is rendered unlikely by the very low concentration of inhibitor (10 to 10 molar). The concentration of monomer is at least 10 times that of the inhibitor, yet the reaction rate constant for addition of the primary radical to monomer may be less than that for combination with inhibitor by only a factor of 10 to 10 Hence most of the primary radicals may be expected to react with monomer even in the presence of inhibitor, the action of the latter being confined principally to the termination of chain radicals of very short length. ... 

In practice, the process regime will often be less transparent than suggested by Table 1.4. As an example, a process may neither be diffusion nor reaction-rate limited, rather some intermediate regime may prevail. In addition, solid heat transfer, entrance flow or axial dispersion effects, which were neglected in the present study, may be superposed. In the analysis presented here only the leading-order effects were taken into account. As a result, the dependence of the characteristic quantities listed in Table 1.5 on the channel diameter will be more complex. For a detailed study of such more complex scenarios, computational fluid dynamics, to be discussed in Section 2.3, offers powerful tools and methods. However, the present analysis serves the purpose to differentiate the potential inherent in decreasing the characteristic dimensions of process equipment and to identify some cornerstones to be considered when attempting process intensification via size reduction. 

Methods based on simplification of the reaction rate expression. In these approaches one uses a vast excess of one or more of the reactants or stoichiometric ratios of the reactants in order to permit a partial evaluation of the form of the rate expression. They may be used in conjunction with either a differential or integral analysis of the experimental data. 

Differential Methods for the Treatment of Reaction Rate Data... 

Since data are almost invariably taken under isothermal conditions to eliminate the temperature dependence of reaction rate constants, one is primarily concerned with determining the concentration dependence of the rate expression [0(Ct)] and the rate constant at the temperature in question. We will now consider two differential methods that can be used in data analysis. 

ILLUSTRATION 3.1 USE OF A DIFFERENTIAL METHOD TO DETERMINE A PSEUDO REACTION RATE EXPRESSION FOR THE IODINE CATALYZED BROMINATION OF m-XYLENE... 

Initial Rate Measurements. Another differential method useful in the determination of reaction rate expressions is the initial rate approach. It involves a series of rate measurements at different initial reactant concentrations but restricted to very small conversions of the limiting reagent (5 to 10% or less). This technique differs from those discussed previ-... 

Techniques for the Analysis of Reaction Rate Data that are Suitable for Use with Either Integral or Differential Methods... 

Determine the reaction order and rate constant for the reaction by both differential and integral methods of analysis. For orders other than one, C0 will be needed. If so, incorporate this term into the rate constant. 

The first point to be established in any experimental study is that one is dealing with parallel reactions and not with reactions between the products and the original reactants or with one another. One then uses data on the product distribution to determine relative values of the rate constants, employing the relations developed in Section 5.2.1. For simple parallel reactions one then uses either the differential or integral methods developed in Section 3.3 in analysis of the data. 

Because of the complexity of biological systems, Eq. (1) as the differential form of Michaelis-Menten kinetics is often analyzed using the initial rate method. Due to the restriction of the initial range of conversion, unwanted influences such as reversible product formation, effects due to enzyme inhibition, or side reactions are reduced to a minimum. The major disadvantage of this procedure is that a relatively large number of experiments must be conducted in order to determine the desired rate constants. 

From the resulting reactions a set of coupled differential equations can be derived describing the deactivation of P, L and PI and the reaction rate constants can be derived from storage stability data by the use of parameter estimation methods. The storage stability data give the concentration of P+PI (it is assumed that the inhibitor fully releases the protease during analysis due to fast dynamics and the extensive dilution in the assay) and L as a function of time. 

---