Connectivity potential energy surfaces

Static properties of some molecules ([193,277-280]). More recently, pairs of ci s have been studied [281,282] in greater detail. These studies arose originally in connection with a ci between the l A and 2 A states found earlier in computed potential energy surfaces for C2H in symmetry [278]. Similar ci s appear between the potential surfaces of the two lowest excited states A2 and B2 iit H2S or of 82 and A in Al—H2 within C2v symmetry [283]. A further, closely spaced pair of ci s has also been found between the 3 A and 4 A states of the molecule C2H. Here the separation between the twins varies with the assumed C—C separation, and they can be brought into coincidence at some separation [282]. 

Let S be any simply connected surface in nuclear configuration space, bounded by a closed-loop L. Then, if 4>(r,R) changes sign when transported adiabatically round L, there must be at least one point on S at which (r, R) is discontinuous, implying that its potential energy surface intersects that of another electronic state. 

In principle, energy landscapes are characterized by their local minima, which correspond to locally stable confonnations, and by the transition regions (barriers) that connect the minima. In small systems, which have only a few minima, it is possible to use a direct approach to identify all the local minima and thus to describe the entire potential energy surface. Such is the case for small reactive systems [9] and for the alanine dipeptide, which has only two significant degrees of freedom [50,51]. The direct approach becomes impractical, however, for larger systems with many degrees of freedom that are characterized by a multitude of local minima. 

An IRC calculation examines the reaction path leading down from a transition structure on a potential energy surface. Such a calculation starts at the saddle point and follows the path in both directions from the transition state, optimizing the geometry of the molecular system at each point along the path. In this way, an IRC calculation definitively connects two minima on the potential energy surface by a path which passes through the transition state between them. 

We have already considered two reactions on the H2CO potential energy surface. In doing so, we studied five stationary points three minima—formaldehyde, trans hydroxycarbene, and carbon monoxide plus hydrogen molecule—and the two transition structures connecting formaldehyde with the two sets of products. One obvious remaining step is to find a path between the two sets of products. 

The IRC calculation verifies that the transition structure does indeed connect these two minima. Here is an illustration of the potential energy surface for this reaction ... 

Part 3, Applications, begins with Chapter 8, Studying Chemical Reactions and Reactivity, which discusses using electronic structure theory to investigate chemical problems. It includes consideration of reaction path features to investigate the routes between transition structures and the equilibrium structures they connect on the reaction s potential energy surface. 

A minimum on a potential energy surface represents an equilibrium stracture. There will invariably be a number of such local minima, and we can imagine a number of paths on the surface that connect one particular minimum to another. If the highest-energy point on each path is considered, the transition structure can be defined as the lowest of these maxima. The reaction path is the lowest-energy route between two minima. 

At R > 400 pm the orientation of the reactants looses its importance and the energy level of the educts is calculated (ethene + nonclassical ethyl cation). For smaller values of R and a the potential energy increases rapidly. At R = 278 pm and a = 68° one finds a saddle point of the potential energy surface lying on the central barrier, which can be connected with the activated complex of the reaction (21). This connection can be derived from a vibration analysis which has already been discussed in part 2.3.3. With the assistance of the above, the movement of atoms during so-called imaginary vibrations can be calculated. It has been attempted in Fig. 14 to clarify the movement of the atoms during this vibration (the size of the components of the movement vector... 

As explained above, the QM/MM-FE method requires the calculation of the MEP. The MEP for a potential energy surface is the steepest descent path that connects a first order saddle point (transition state) with two minima (reactant and product). Several methods have been recently adapted by our lab to calculate MEPs in enzymes. These methods include coordinate driving (CD) [13,19], nudged elastic band (NEB) [20-25], a second order parallel path optimizer method [25, 26], a procedure that combines these last two methods in order to improve computational efficiency [27],... 

Figure 3 Crystal field states (left-hand panel) and potential energy surfaces (right-hand panel) for an octahedral complex of nickel(II) in the 3Tig/1Eg energy range. Calculated spectra for the transition to each electronic state are shown in the central panel. Lines with markers connect electronic states and their corresponding calculated spectra. The total calculated spectrum (calc.) is obtained as the sum of the four individual spectra and is compared to the experimental spectrum of Ni(H20)62+ measured at 5K336 (reprinted with permission from ref. 336 1998, American Chemical Society).

In the following sections, studies of isomeric ions are reported in which the ions are reactively probed. Where calculations are available, information on potential energy surfaces is given. This is usually the structure of the stable isomeric forms and transition states and their relative energies thus only points on the potential surface are known. The detailed form of the potential surface is almost never available nor is the connectivity between the various states usually established theoretically (chemical intuition is often used to connect the states). Pertinent experimental data on CID and metastable ions, isomers produced in binary reactions, and potential surfaces probed by binary reactions (with the excited isomeric ion as the reaction intermediate) are also given. 

Figure 4. Part of the potential energy surface of CHsO+ calculated by Chunxiano et al.69 (solid lines) and constructed from thermochemical data in the literature.27-30 The dashed lines indicate that the connected species are coupled by binary reactions, as determined experimentally. It is not meant to imply that there are no barriers between...

Figure 8. Potential energy surface for the C3H6N+ system, showing stable structures, transition states and dissociation limits. The information is from the work of Bouchoux et al.,95,96 Smith et al.94 and Wilson et al.93 An additional part of the potential surface connecting the stable forms, C2HsCNH+ and C2HsNCH+ (not shown) has been calculated by Bouchoux et al. This a higher energy pathway than that illustrated in the figure.

---