Bronsted difference from hydrogen bond catalyst

Apart from acting as effective Lewis base catalysts, the quinuclidine structure of cinchona alkaloids can also participate in the other cycloaddition reaction by a different catalytic mechanism. Calter et al. described an interesting asymmetric interrupted Feist-Benary reaction between ethyl bromopyruvates and cyclohexadione. They proposed that the protonated cinchona alkaloid would perform as a Bronsted acid to form hydrogen-bonding interaction with a-ketoester moiety, rendering it more electrophilic toward attack by either the enol or enolate of cydohexandione. Then intramolecular alkylation would afford the formal [3 + 2] cycloadduct (Scheme 10.12) [16]. 

---