Adiabatically impossible processes

If this were not the case it would be possible to construct a device for making a heat transfer from a region of the earth at a uniform temperature and using it as a continual source of mechanical power. This has never been achieved, and there seems good reason from molecular and statistical considerations to believe that it never will be achieved. 

The impossibility of which we have spoken may also be expressed as follows. Let state A of Joule s system correspond to a height of the weight and temperature of the water. Similarly, let state B correspond to and If 0s 6ji (and then it is possible 

There are, of course, a great many other examples of processes which are impossible under adiabatic conditions, and some of these are shown in Table 1. The first colunm shows a particular state A of the system, as defined by its temperature, volume and composition, and the second column shows another state By characterized by different values of some or aU of these variables. In each case experience shows that it is impossible to carry out the process without 

Now all of the processes which we have said are impossible are entirely consistent with the first law. To take the first example in Table 1, the transfer of heat between two blocks of metal takes place 

Two equal blocks of copper are connected by a wire. One block is at 20 and the other at 30 The blocks are each at 25 G 

---

Finally, it may be remarked that when we speak of a possible or impossible process the notion of time s passage is implicit. It is a question of whether a state A can precede or succeed another state B, in an adiabatic enclosure. The decision which of these states is later than or earlier than the other is based primarily on the subjective time sense of the human observer— which is not to say however that, once the second law has been seen to be true for all isolated systems, we cannot choose one such system as defining the time direction for all the rest. This can be done without reducing the law to a tautology. ... 

In this chapter, we look at the techniques known as direct, or on-the-fly, molecular dynamics and their application to non-adiabatic processes in photochemistry. In contrast to standard techniques that require a predefined potential energy surface (PES) over which the nuclei move, the PES is provided here by explicit evaluation of the electronic wave function for the states of interest. This makes the method very general and powerful, particularly for the study of polyatomic systems where the calculation of a multidimensional potential function is an impossible task. For a recent review of standard non-adiabatic dynamics methods using analytical PES functions see [1]. 

The second law of thermodynamics states that energy exists at various levels and is available for use only if it can move from a higher to a lower level. For example, it is impossible for any device to operate in a cycle and produce work while exchanging heat only with bodies at a single fixed temperature. In thermodynamics, a measure of the unavailability of energy has been devised and is known as entropy. As a measure of unavailability, entropy increases as a system loses heat, but remains constant when there is no gain or loss of heat as in an adiabatic process. It is defined by the following differential equation ... 

Second Law of Thermodynamics. There have been numerous statements of the second law. To paraphrase Clausius It is impossible to devise an engine or process which, working in a cycle, will produce no effect other than the transfer of heat from a colder to a warmer body. According to Caratheodory, the Second Law can be stated as follows Arbitrarily close to any given state of any closed system, there exists an unlimited number of other states which it is impossible to reach from a given state as a result of any adiabatic process, whether reversible or not . 

Although an optimum temperature profile may be specified from theoretical calculations, it may not be possible to achieve in practice. The maximum temperature which can be used is usually determined by the materials of reactor construction or the durability of a catalyst. Also, steep axial temperature gradients cannot be realised unless heat transfer rates are high. If heat transfer is poor and the overall process is exothermic, temperature programming of a single reactor may be impossible the reactor becomes virtually adiabatic. In cases such as these, staged reactors (discussed elsewhere in this volume) with intercoolers may be used as a compromise. 

A process from E to A is an adiabatic process from supersonic conditions to subsonic conditions and is recognized as a shock wave. The entropy for this process increases from E to A, hence the reverse process from A directly to E entails an entropy decrease and is impossible. A strong deflagration, A to D, is therefore impossible except via C, a path involving an exothermic process from C to Z), followed by an endothermic process D to E. It seems unlikely that such a combustion process would be found in nature, although it is not impossible. 

Analysis of the non-isothermal polymerization of E-caprolactam is based on the equations for isothermal polymerization discussed above. At the same time, it is also important to estimate the effect of non-isothermal phenomena on polymerization, because in any real situation, it is impossible to avoid exothermal effects. First of all, let us estimate what temperature increase can be expected and how it influences the kinetics of reaction. It is reasonable to assume that the reaction proceeds under adiabatic conditions as is true for many large articles produced by chemical processing. The total energy produced in transforming e-caprolactam into polyamide-6 is well known. According to the experimental data of many authors, it is close to 125 -130 J/cm3. If the reaction takes place under adiabatic conditions, the result is an increase in temperature of up to 50 - 52°C this is the maximum possible temperature increase Tmax- In order to estimate the kinetic effect of this increase... 

C. This figure is appropriate for adiabatic polymerization, which approximates reality in reactive processing of large articles with high volume-to-surface ratios. In this case, it is impossible to remove the heat effectively and to avoid intense local temperature jumps. Therefore, it is essential to know how to calculate temperature increase for reactions proceeding in non-isothermal conditions. The time dependence of viscosity in this situation can be written as... 

Prove that it is impossible for two lines representing reversible, adiabatic processes to intersect. 

Prove that it is impossible for two lines representing reversible, adiabatic processes on a P V diagram to intersect. (Hint Assume that they do intersect, and complete the cycle witha line representinga reversible,isothennalprocess. Show thatperfonnanceof this cycle violates the second law.)... 

The change in volume of a gas again illustrates the difference between reversible and irreversible processes. The adiabatic compression of a gas (see p. 91) is reversible, as the initial state may be re-estabhshed completely by an adiabatic expansion. In practice, however, it is impossible to construct vessels absolutely impermeable to heat. No actual compression is therefore strictly adiabatic, as some of the heat produced is always lost by conduction or radiation to the surroundings. The less the permeability of the walls of the vessel, the smaller this loss in heat will be, and the more nearly will the change in volume approximate to a reversible process. 

Several types of fixed-bed reactor systems were considered for the MTG process development (ref. 9). Perhaps the easiest to scale-up is the two-reactor configuration shown in Fig. 3 this was used for bench-scale studies. Both reactors contained an axial thermowell to monitor temperature profiles. Special precautions (e.g., adiabatic heaters, insulation) were taken to ensure proper accounting of heat effects, although in small reactors it is virtually impossible to be 100% adiabatic (ref. 

How intuitive is the statement How accustomed are students to the properties and phenomena involved in the statement How directly does the statement suggest the evidence for and consequences of the law Here is where most statements of the second law fall far short of what is desired. Consider Caratheodory1s, "In the neighborhood of any prescribed initial state, there jre states which cannot be reached by an adiabatic process." Is this really a good way to express what is one of the most profound and fruitful generalizations in all of science Again, the popular impossibility statements of Kelvin and of Clausius seem to be relatively minor truths, fine perhaps as corollaries, but intuitively not very obvious. The postulates... 

It is impossible to do justice within the limited extent of one chapter to all theoretical developments. For example, I will omit methods relating to the Fokker-Planck equation representation of the dynamics. This includes the method of adiabatic elimination discussed extensively in Ref. 33 or the approach based on the Rayleigh quotient, developed by Talkner (34,35). There are a number of reviews, monographs, and special journal issues devoted to the theory of activated rate processes (5,13,14,36-40), the interested reader is urged to consult them. I will also omit any quantum theory of activated rate processes. The thread which connects the material presented in this chapter will be the use of the Hamiltonian equivalent form of the STGLE and more general forms to derive the classical theory of activated rate processes. 

The Dynamics of ElectronicaUy Adiabatic Collisions.— There are three parts to a detailed rate theory of processes occurring in electronically adiabatic collisions. First, the potential describing the molecular interaction must be calculated or estimated. Secondly, the equations of motion have to be solved for individual, fully specified, collisions. Finally, the results of calculations on single collisions must be averaged correctly to yield the required result for example, a reactive cross-section or a detailed rate constant. The procedures for the third stage were outlined in Section 2. In the forward direction, i.e. from o(n ln 6) to ic(T), this averaging presents no problems, but it is the difficulty of reversing this process which makes it impossible to obtain detailed information about the collision dynamics or potential from experimental measurements of thermal rate constants. 

The vibrational adiabatic potential Vadiab was created for a given set of the vibrational quantum numbers Vk, fixed during the reaction process. Therefore, it is impossible to exchange energy between the vibrational modes (we assume, therefore, that the Coriolis coupling constants Bkk = 0), as well as between the vibrational modes and the reaction path (we assume that the curvature coupling constants Bks = 0). This would mean a change of Vk s. 

It is impossible to create an isothermal process in plug flow reactors as it requires the variation of thermal transfei along the reactor length, according to the kinetics of heat emission. Therefore, plug flow reactors run under adiabatic conditions or at least imder nonisothermal mode conditions with external heat removal. The heat balance equation for steady state conditions for the micro volume of a reactor can be written in the form [4] ... 

Continuous plug flow reactors are also unsuitable for these purposes because it is usually impossible to obtain an isothermic mode in such reactors, even for reactions with a relatively low rate of reaction. Plug flow reactors usually operate in adiabatic or intermediate modes, which are far from isothermic even with an external heat removal modification. In can be stated that almost all industrial reactors employed for fast processes are not optimally designed and are therefore ineffective. The quality of products is also far from optimal and the processes are generally not perfect from an engineering, economical, or social point of view (decrease of final product yield and quality, increase of nonrecyclable wastes, excessively high consumption of raw materials and low energy efficiency). 

---