Activation energy, apparent precision

The application of Absolute Rate Theory to the interpretation of catalytic hydrogenation reactions has received relatively little attention and, even when applied, has only achieved moderate success. This is, in part, due to the necessity to formulate precise mechanisms in order to derive appropriate rate expressions [43] and, in part, due to the necessity to make various assumptions with regard to such factors as the number of surface sites per unit area of the catalyst, usually assumed to be 10 5 cm-2, the activity of the surface and the immobility or otherwise of the transition state. In spite of these difficulties, it has been shown that satisfactory agreement between observed and calculated rates can be obtained in the case of the nickel-catalysed hydrogenation of ethylene (Table 3), and between the observed and calculated apparent activation energies for the... 

The plot for 19e shows precisely this behaviour, exhibiting an apparent negative activation energy at temperatures above ca 13 °C and distinct curvature over the -20 to 13 °C temperature range as the rate of product formation (k ) approaches and then surpasses that of reversion of the complex to reactants (k-c). The turnover point where kn = k-c occurs at a temperature of ca — 6°C. Since at this point roh = l/2fcc, it is possible to calculate a value of kc for the reaction of this silene with MeOH at this particular temperature. The value obtained, kc 5 x 109 M 1 s 1, is roughly a factor of three... 

The kinetics of reversible decompositions are often highly sensitive to reaction conditions [43]. For example, the values of and E, for the decomposition of CaCOj show unusually wide variations, owing to the sensitivity of reaction rate to the availability of COj [44,45]. The spread of apparent E values is considerable [46] and some values are close to the dissociation enthalpy [1]. However, Beruto and Searcy [47] concluded that, under high vacuum conditions, the constant rate of interface advance in large crystals was probably controlled by the dissociation step in the absence of a perceptible contribution from the reverse process. The decomposition activation energy (205 kJ mol ) was appreciably larger than the dissociation enthalpy (178 kJ mol ). This is probably the most precise kinetic measurement for the calcite decomposition [48]. 

The dehydration of alcohols is one of the oldest catalytic reactions and studied over kaolin, a-alumina, silica, silica-alumina, aluminium phosphate, W2O5 etc. The mononmolecular dehydration of ethyl alcohol produces ethylene and the bimolecular dehydration due to condensation of ethyl alcohol produces diethyl ether. The reported [11] apparent activation energies for the dehydration of ethyl alcohol to ethylene and condensation to diethyl ether are 13.8 and 14.2 K cal/mole respectively. These values have been precisely measured by pulse technique in the temperature range 190 to 275 C. Because of the closeness of the apparent activation energies, attainment of cent percent selectivity for ethylene by inhibition of the condensation reaction poses a great selectivity problem. However, the users are very rigid about cent percent selectivity for ethylene at a reactor temperature of 350 C. 

A disturbing question may be just how successful these criteria are in utilizing only observable quantities. For example, if we follow the letter of the statements above, the true activation energy is apparently defined as an experimentally observable quantity in the nonisothermal criteria. This would presumably be an experimental value resulting from studies in which intraparticle transport effects were absent, but this is precisely what one is trying to determine. What can we say Sometimes an active imagination plus iteration is the best course. 

Dunham et have recently summarized their spectroscopic and magnetic susceptibility results on spinach and other two-iron ferredoxins they show how the results allow a precise definition of the active centre and provide a stringent set of criteria against which any further structural information may be tested. The c.d. and absorption spectra of spinach ferredoxin and another two-iron iron-sulphur protein, adrenodoxin, suggest that the reduced forms contain a high-spin ferrous ion in a distorted tetrahedral environment. The reaction between adrenodoxin and excess 1,10-phenanthroline apparently follows zero-order kinetics under aerobic conditions but first-order kinetics under anaerobic conditions the activation energies are 3.3 and 12.6 kcal mol, respectively. A reaction sequence is proposed. ... 

Thus, it is clear what is meant by the words apparent unimolecular reaction, since the activation process can be bimolecular. A key point is the separation in time scales between the activation step and the subsequent unimolecular reaction dynamics. This was also a distinctive feature of the indirect photo-activated reactions considered in the previous section. Thus, the theoretical description of these reaction types is very similar photo-activation makes it, in particular, possible to deposit a precise amount of energy according to E = hi/. 

---