Substituent effects, inductive

A familiar feature of the electronic theory is the classification of substituents, in terms of the inductive and conjugative or resonance effects, which it provides. Examples from substituents discussed in this book are given in table 7.2. The effects upon orientation and reactivity indicated are only the dominant ones, and one of our tasks is to examine in closer detail how descriptions of substituent effects of this kind meet the facts of nitration. In general, such descriptions find wide acceptance, the more so since they are now known to correspond to parallel descriptions in terms of molecular orbital theory ( 7.2.2, 7.2.3). Only in respect of the interpretation to be placed upon the inductive effect is there still serious disagreement. It will be seen that recent results of nitration studies have produced evidence on this point ( 9.1.1). 

Ingold introduces the terms substrate field effect and reagent field effect to describe those aspects of the direct field effect numbered (z) and (3) in 9.1.2. His description of the substituent effect of the trimethylammonio group is thus given substantially in terms of the substrate field effect and the TT-inductive effect, i.e. it is an isolated molecule description. The reagent field effect is seen to be significant in nitration and to produce qualitatively the same 226... 

The quatemization reaction of the thiazole nitrogen has been used to evaluate the steric effect of substituents in heterocyclic compounds since thiazole and its alkyl derivatives are good models for such study. In fact, substituents in the 2- and 4-positions of the ring only interact through their steric effects (inductive and resonance effects were constant in the studied series). The thiazole ring is planar, and the geometries of the ground and transition states are identical. Finally, the 2- and 4-positions have been shown to be different (259. 260). 

Since substituent effects in aliphatic systems and in meta positions in aromatic systems are essentially inductive in character, cr and cr values are often related by the expression cr = 0.217cr — 0.106. Substituent effects fall off with increasing distance from the reaction center generally a factor of 0.36 corresponds to the interposition of a —CHj— group, which enables cr values to be estimated for R—CHj— groups not otherwise available. 

Fig. 4.3. Resonance, field, and inductive components of substituent effects in substituted benzenes.

The general chemical reasonableness of the results in Table 7-7 is gratifying, but this does not constitute a demonstration that the separation of substituent effects into inductive effects and resonance effects is quantitatively possible, for these effects may interact so as to be nonadditive. Ritchie and Sager express reservations about the approach in general, and other authors " have criticized results based on Eqs. (7-33) and (7-34). 

Research on the nature of substituent constants continues, with results that can bewilder the nonspecialist. The dominant approach is a statistical one, and the main goal is to dissect substituent effects into separate electronic causes. This has led to a proliferation of terms, symbols, and conclusions. A central issue is (here we change terminology somewhat from our earlier usage) to determine the balance of field and inductive effects contributing to the observed polar electronic effect. In... 

Charton has recently examined substituent effects in the ortho position in benzene derivatives and in the a-position in pyridines, quinolines, and isoquinolines. He concludes that, in benzene derivatives, the effects in the ortho position are proportional to the effects in the para position op). However, he finds that effects of a-sub-stituents on reactions involving the sp lone pair of the nitrogen atoms in pyridine, quinoline, and isoquinoline are approximately proportional to CT -values, or possibly to inductive effects (Taft s a ). He also notes that the effects of substituents on proton-deuterium exchange in the ortho position of substituted benzenes are comparable to the effects of the same substituents in the a-position of the heterocycles. 

Substituent Reactivity Orienting effect Inductive effect Resonance effect... 

In common with a number of heterocyclic iodinations, kinetic effects are found in the iodination of indole and 2-methylindole [68AC(R)1435], When the substituent effects for the reaction are examined it is clear that any resonance effects from the fused benzene ring are only poorly relayed to the reactive 3-position, and the rates appear to be controlled by inductive effects. A 5-methyl group was more activating than 5-methoxy [69AC(R)799]. 

Arrhenius parameters for nitration of 4-aikylphenyltrimethyiammonium ions in nitric acid-sulphuric acid mixtures (Table 12). It was argued that the observed Baker-Nathan order of alkyl substituent effect was, in fact, the result of a steric effect superimposed upon an inductive order. However, a number of assumptions were involved in this deduction, and these render the conclusion less reliable than one would like it would be useful to have the thermodynamic parameters for nitration of the methyl substituted compound in particular, in order to compare with the data for the /-butyl compound, though experimental difficulties may preclude this. It would not be surprising if a true Baker-Nathan order were observed because it is observed for all other electrophilic substitutions in this medium1. 

The magnitude of the electrical effect is comparable to that of the trans-heterovinylene sets. The difference in magnitude between the a values for the syn and anti phenyl ketoximes is significant and suggests that the inductive effect alone cannot account for the observed substituent effect. If the inductive effect were operating by itself, the a values for syn and anti sets would be the same. 

A rival analysis of substituent effects into field (equivalent to inductive) and resonance components was proposed many years ago by Swain and Lupton °, was later slightly corrected by Hansch and colleagues and fairly recently has been substantially modified... 

The most frequently encountered hydrolysis reaction in drug instability is that of the ester, but curtain esters can be stable for many years when properly formulated. Substituents can have a dramatic effect on reaction rates. For example, the tert-butyl ester of acetic acid is about 120 times more stable than the methyl ester, which, in turn, is approximately 60 times more stable than the vinyl analog [16]. Structure-reactivity relationships are dealt with in the discipline of physical organic chemistry. Substituent groups may exert electronic (inductive and resonance), steric, and/or hydrogen-bonding effects that can drastically affect the stability of compounds. A detailed treatment of substituent effects can be found in a review by Hansch et al. [17] and in the classical reference text by Hammett [18]. 

Introduction of 3,5-dimethyl and 4-substituent on the Phebox skeleton revealed a weak substituent effect on the degree of asymmetric induction (Scheme 15) [28,29]. When trimethylsilyl acrylate was used as enolate source, the (3-hydroxy carboxylic acid was obtained directly upon mild acid hydrolysis. In the production of carboxylic acid 49, an enantiomeric excess of 96% ee was attained using the NC -substituted Phebox-Rh catalyst. 

---