Ruthenium complexes, reactions cluster catalysis

Although ruthenium is significantly less expensive than rhodium and although its use has been recommended since 1960 (7) for the oxo synthesis, complexes of this metal have not been developed as catalysts. However, many papers and patents have referred to the results obtained employing various ruthenium complexes. The purpose of this article is to analyze the work done involving ruthenium compounds, restricting the scope only to the hydroformylation reaction and not to the carbonylation reaction, which would demand to too lengthy an article. In this review we examine successively mononuclear ruthenium complexes, ruthenium clusters as precursors, photochemical activation, and supported catalysis. 

Rhodium-based catalysis suffers from the high cost of the metal and quite often from a lack of stereoselectivity. This justifies the search for alternative catalysts. In this context, ruthenium-based catalysts look rather attractive nowadays, although still poorly documented. Recently, diruthenium(II,II) tetracarboxylates [42], polymeric and dimeric diruthenium(I,I) dicarboxylates [43], ruthenacarbor-ane clusters [44], and hydride and silyl ruthenium complexes [45 a] and Ru porphyrins [45 b] have been introduced as efficient cyclopropanation catalysts, superior to the Ru(II,III) complex Ru2(OAc)4Cl investigated earlier [7]. In terms of efficiency, electrophilicity, regio- and (partly) stereoselectivity, the most efficient ruthenium-based catalysts compare rather well with the rhodium(II) carboxylates. The ruthenium systems tested so far seem to display a slightly lower level of activity but are somewhat more discriminating in competitive reactions, which apparently could be due to the formation of less electrophilic carbenoid species. This point is probably related to the observation that some ruthenium complexes competitively catalyze both olefin cyclopropanation and olefin metathesis [46], which is at variance with what is observed with the rhodium catalysts. 

The mechanism of this interesting reaction is also discussed. Since kinetic studies suggest that the rate-determining step of the catalysis is C H activation of pyridine, this reaction requires an excess of pyridine. An active key intermediate depicted below is isolable (Figure 10.3). Although a mononuclear ruthenium complex cannot be ruled out as the active catalyst, the cluster framework remains intact during the course of the catalysis. 

E3.19 Base-promoted ruthenium carbonyl cluster complexes from fundamental reactions to catalysis... 

---