Refinement of data

A field of application of MD that is beginning to bear fruit is the refinement of data from nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) and from diffraction experiments. High-resolution NMR at frequencies around 500 MHz is able to resolve individual proton resonances of biological macromolecules in solution with molecular weights exceeding 10,000... 

Fig. 1. Stereo figure of the Mn(III) environment in Mn SOD from Thermus thermo-philus. The coordinates were derived from partial refinement of data at 1.8-A resolution. (Dr. M. L. Ludwig, personal communication.)...

Figure 17.2 shows the relative abundance of the elements of the universe and of the earth. The abundances are approximate, as a consequence of die difficulties in their assessment and limitations of experimental techniques. The abundances in the universe (based on spectral measurements on stars and interstellar matter) are used as a refinement of data obtained for the solar system. Stellar light is divided in spectral classes depending on the surface temperature of the star, see Fig. 17.1. The various classes (Harvard Spectral Classification) show lines of the elements as listed below in approximately decreasing intensity ...

One of the objectives of LACTOZ has been to provide absorption cross-sections and quantum yields so that photolysis rates can be calculated under atmospheric conditions. Emphasis has been on (a) refinement of data for the simple, well-characterised molecules (O3, HCHO) involved in HOx radical production, and (b) determination of data for photolysis of organic compounds formed as products in the degradation of alkanes, alkenes and selected multifunctional VOCs, mainly carbonyl compounds and nitrates, which produce HOx indirectly. 

A particularly important application of molecular dynamics, often in conjunction with the simulated annealing method, is in the refinement of X-ray and NMR data to determine the three-dimensional structures of large biological molecules such as proteins. The aim of such refinement is to determine the conformation (or conformations) that best explain the experimental data. A modified form of molecular dynamics called restrained moleculai dynarrdcs is usually used in which additional terms, called penalty functions, are added tc the potential energy function. These extra terms have the effect of penalising conformations... 

The greatest value of molecular dynamic simulations is that they complement and help to explain existing data for designing new experiments. The simulations are increasingly useful for structural refinement of models generated from NMR, distance geometry, and X-ray data. 

A vast amount of research has been undertaken on adsorption phenomena and the nature of solid surfaces over the fifteen years since the first edition was published, but for the most part this work has resulted in the refinement of existing theoretical principles and experimental procedures rather than in the formulation of entirely new concepts. In spite of the acknowledged weakness of its theoretical foundations, the Brunauer-Emmett-Teller (BET) method still remains the most widely used procedure for the determination of surface area similarly, methods based on the Kelvin equation are still generally applied for the computation of mesopore size distribution from gas adsorption data. However, the more recent studies, especially those carried out on well defined surfaces, have led to a clearer understanding of the scope and limitations of these methods furthermore, the growing awareness of the importance of molecular sieve carbons and zeolites has generated considerable interest in the properties of microporous solids and the mechanism of micropore filling. 

The analysis of siUcon carbide involves identification, chemical analysis, and physical testing. For identification, x-ray diffraction, optical microscopy, and electron microscopy are used (136). Refinement of x-ray data by Rietveld analysis allows more precise deterrnination of polytype levels (137). 

Subsequently, Calvert (R-19, p. 228) has combined mathematical modehng with performance tests on a variety of industrial scrubbers and has obtained a refinement of the power-input/cut-size relationship as shown in Fig. 14-130. He considers these relationships sufficiently reliable to use this data as a tool for selection of scrubber type and performance prediction. The power input for this figure is based solely on gas pressure drop across the device. 

Performance data have been reported by Kennedy et al. (The Purification of Inorganic and Organic Mateiials, Marcel Dekker, New York, 1969, p. 261) for continuous-zone refining of benzoic acid. 

Contributions in this section are important because they provide structural information (geometries, dipole moments, and rotational constants) of individual tautomers in the gas phase. The molecular structure and tautomer equilibrium of 1,2,3-triazole (20) has been determined by MW spectroscopy [88ACSA(A)500].This case is paradigmatic since it illustrates one of the limitations of this technique the sensitivity depends on the dipole moment and compounds without a permanent dipole are invisible for MW. In the case of 1,2,3-triazole, the dipole moments are 4.38 and 0.218 D for 20b and 20a, respectively. Hence the signals for 20a are very weak. Nevertheless, the relative abundance of the tautomers, estimated from intensity measurements, is 20b/20a 1 1000 at room temperature. The structural refinement of 20a was carried out based upon the electron diffraction data (Section V,D,4). 

The distance of each reflection from the center of the pattern is a function of the fiber-to-film distance, as well as the unit-cell dimensions. Therefore, by measuring the positions of the reflections, it is possible to determine the unit-cell dimensions and, subsequently, index (or assign Miller indices to) all the reflections. Their intensities are measured with a microdensitometer or digitized with a scanner and then processed.8-10 After applying appropriate geometrical corrections for Lorentz and polarization effects, the observed structure amplitudes are computed. This experimental X-ray data set is crucial for the determination and refinement of molecular and packing models, and also for the adjudication of alternatives. 

We passed then to a particular olefin, adamantylideneadamantane, whose reaction with Br2 had been shown to stop at the stage of bromonium ion formation because of steric hindrance to backside nucleophilic attack. An UV-Vis spectrophotometric study (ref. 10) has shown that the complicated equilibrium reported in Scheme 4 is immediately established on mixing the olefin and Br2 in DCE. Equilibrium (1) could be isolated by working at low Br2 and ten to hundred fold higher olefin concentrations. A Scott plot followed by a NLLSQ refinement of the data gave a Kf = 2.89 x 10 (4.0) M-l. It is worth noting that conductimetric measurements showed the non-ionic nature of the 1 1 adduct, consistent with a CTC intermediate, but not with a bromonium-bromide species. 

Another issue is the development and refinement of the testing protocols used in mesocosms. Mesocosms could have a more important role in environmental risk assessment if the data coming from them could be better interpreted. The use of biomarker assays to establish toxic effects and, where necessary, relate them to effects produced by chemicals in the field, might be a way forward. The issues raised in this section will be returned to in Chapter 17, after consideration of the individual examples given in Part 2. 

Following an assessment of the criteria in Table 3.2 it may become evident that there is only one viable route, but more probably two or three options will be difficult to choose between. In this case the alternatives should be screened experimentally to refine the data in Table 3.2 and to complete a pro-forma similar to that shown in Table 3.3. 

---