Norcaradiene, from methylene

The formation of norcaradiene derivatives with naphthalene [reaction (22)] lends some support to this scheme. This mechanism resembles a bimolecular two-step process suggested for the reaction of chloromethyl-aluminum compounds with olefins (199-201). On the other hand, a bimolecular one-step methylene transfer mechanism is generally accepted for the formation of cyclopropane derivatives by the reaction of halo-methylzinc compounds with olefins. This difference between the mechanism proposed for the cyclopropane formation from olefin and that for the ring expansion of aromatic compound may be ascribable to the difference in the stability of intermediates the benzenium ion (XXII) may be more stable than an alkylcarbonium ion (369). 

---