Mills-Nixon hypothesis

The Mills-Nixon hypothesis that small ring annelation on benzene would induce bond fixation (bond alternation) by trapping out one Kekul6 tautomer is a casualty of early twentieth century structural chemistry. Due to a lack of direct methods for analyzing molecular structure, structural postulates of that time were often supported by an analysis of product distributions. An experimental observable such as product selectivity or isomer count was correlated to an unobservable structural feature derived on the basis of a chemical model. Classical successes of this method are van t Hoff s proof of the tetrahedral carbon atom and Fischer s proof for the configuration of sugars. In the case of Mills and Nixon, however, the paradigm broke down. 

Nixon model, have been abandoned in all modern views of aromatic structure. Thus, given our present views of the structure of benzene, and the mechanism of electrophilic aromatic substitution, the Mills-Nixon hypothesis has no meaning. Nonetheless, the legacy of this hypothesis doggedly persists in our research discussions and should be laid to rest. ... 

The Mills-Nixon hypothesis had, as its foundation, certain differences in the chemical behaviour of indan (3) and tetralin (4) from which a localization of the aromatic 7r-bonds was predicted to occur in the direction depicted by la rather lb. The original experimental evidence upon which the effect was based was shown to be erroneous, but calculations at various levels of theory indicated that aromatic bond localization should exist and become more pronounced as the size of the annelated ring decreases In essence one can recognize that the structure of benzene has a symmetry such that both Kekule structures must contribute equally. With Q tetralin (4) (and the lower homologues) no such symmetry requirement exists and ring annelation could induce bond length alternation within the arene nucleus. As the strain imposed by the fused ring increases, the Mills-Nixon effect should increase. The hypothesis has been the subject of considerable discussion and the controversy is far from settled. 

Figure 1. The Kekule oscillation hypothesis of two rapidly equilibrating benzene isomers constructed of van t Hoff tetrahedra used by Mills and Nixon.

Figure 2. Hypothesis about the Kekule-reso nance structure fixation in indan by Mills and Nixon...

---