Geranyl pyrophosphate cation cyclization

The metabolism of 7-endo-fenchol to ci-fenchone in fennel has been studied in quite some detail by Croteau and co-workers (Croteau and Felton, 1980). Croteau et al. (1980a) later reported a soluble enzyme preparation from the leaves of fennel which catalysed the cation-dependent cyclization of both geranyl pyrophosphate and neryl pyrophosphate to the bicyclic rearranged monoterpene 1-enc/o-fenchol. Croteau et al. (1980b) found that (+)-(lS)-fenchone, an irregular bicyclic monoterpene ketone thought to be derived... 

The previous view on the biosynthesis of monoterpenes is that the cyclization of the geranyl pyrophosphate proceeds via a common cationic precursor, which in turn is further transformed into the various monoterpenes, as shown in Fig. (2). 

Two elements of the cyclization have yet to be addressed the isomerization of geranyl pyrophosphate to linalyl pyrophosphate (or the equivalent ion-pair) and the construction of bicyclic skeleta. Studies on the biosynthesis of linalool (61), and on the analogous nerolidyl system in the sesquiterpene series (52), have shown this allylic transposition to occur by a net suprafacial process, as expected. On the other hand, the chemical conversion of acyclic or monocyclic precursors to bicyclic monoterpenes, under relevant cationic cyclization conditions, has been rarely observed (47,62-65) and, thermodynamic considerations notwithstanding (66), bicyclizations remain poorly modeled. 

Curiously, certain cyclases, notably (+)-bornyl pyrophosphate cyclase and (-)-endo-fenchol cyclase, are capable of cyclizing, at relatively slow rates, the 3S-linalyl pyrophosphate enantiomer to the respective antipodal products, (-)-bornyl pyrophosphate and (+)-endo-fenchol (74,75). Since both (+)-bornyl pyrophosphate cyclase and (-)-endo-fenchol cyclase produce the designated products in optically pure form from geranyl, neryl and 3R-linalyl pyrophosphate, the antipodal cyclizations of the 3S-linalyl enantiomer are clearly abnormal and indicate the inability to completely discriminate between the similar overall hydrophobic/hydrophilic profiles presented by the linalyl enantiomers in their approach from solution. The anomalous cyclization of the 3S-enantiomer by fenchol cyclase is accompanied by some loss of normal regiochemical control, since aberrant terminations at the acyclic, monocyclic and bicyclic stages of the cationic cyclization cascade are also observed (74). The absolute configurations of these abnormal co-products have yet to be examined. 

---