Evaluating Model Chemistries

Calculation of thertnochetnical quantities like those we have just considered are a widely-used method for evaluating the accuracy of theoretical methods and models. In this section, we will look at the Gaussian-2 molecule set and then consider how well a variety of model chemistries perform on it. Note that our consideration of the G2 method itself will come later in this chapter. 

---

This molecule set has several strengths which make it valuable for evaluating the accuracy of a model chemistry ... 

Different isodesmic reactions will predict different values for the same heat of formation. Thus, this technique does not produce a uniquely defined value for the heat of formation it is not a model chemistry and cannot be systematically evaluated quantitatively. This effect is illustrated in the following example. 

Kraabol A.G. Konopka P. Stordal F. and Schlager FI. (2000). Modelling chemistry in aircraft plumes 1 Comparison with observations and evaluation of a layered approach. Atmospheric Environment, 34(23), 3939-3950. 

There seems to be a remarkable consistency between Buckminster Fuller s evaluation of chemistry ( chemists consider volumes as material domains and not merely as abstractions, see Chapter 1— Introduction) and Kitaigorodskii s geometrical model of crystal structures. In one of his last statements Kitaigorodskii (Figure 9-54) said (when asked about his most important achievements in science) I ve shown that the molecule is a bodyd One can take it, one can hit with it it has mass, volume, form, hardness. I followed the ideas of Democritos... [100],... 

In order to evaluate DSMC chemistry models, we require experimental and/or detailed theoretical results. Data of interest that can be measured experimentally include reaction cross sections, and rate coefficients. The most useful type of theoretical data are generated by detailed analysis of the collision and reaction dynamics using potential surfaces obtained from high level quantum chemical methods. 

The model used to evaluate surface chemistry in these systems is the constant capacitance surface complexation model. This model has been used to describe the adsorption of cations (41) and anions (4,8) onto oxides similar to those used in our experiments. A significant difference between those studies and the present study is that we have adapted the model to simulate some of the interactions that might occur between particles in a binary suspension. 

Moreover, his evaluation of chemistry changed deeply during his career. In 1938, Bachelard tended to present chemistry as an anti-model science, especially... 

Ferguson D M 1995. Parameterisation and Evaluation of a Flexible Water Model. Journal of Computational Chemistry 16 501-511. 

Frazao C, C Topham, V Dhanaraj and T L Blundell 1994. Comparative Modelling of Human Rer Retrospective Evaluation of the Model with Respect to the X-ray Crystal Structure, Pure and A Chemistry 66 43-50. 

Learning By Modeling for building examining and evaluating molecular models specific to or game chemistry... 

Evaluation of reactivity ratios from the copolymer composition equation requires only composition data—that is, analytical chemistry-and has been the method most widely used to evaluate rj and t2. As noted in the last section, this method assumes terminal control and seeks the best fit of the data to that model. It offers no means for testing the model and, as we shall see, is subject to enough uncertainty to make even self-consistency difficult to achieve. 

It is a common experience in synthetic chemistry that a truly optimal ordering of a synthetic route may not be possible in the planning stage, but may have to determined experimentally. The precise information necessary for the complete and unambiguous evaluation of each step in a possible synthesis is hardly ever available. Nonetheless it is clearly wise to try to optimize a synthetic plan on the basis of available information before the experimental approach begins. Such an effort may suggest certain preliminary or "model" experiments that can be helpful in the choice or refinement of a synthetic plan. It is also obviously desirable to devise and consider alternate or bypass paths for each problematic step of a synthetic sequence. 

Learning By Modeling for building, examining, and evaluating molecular- models specific to organic chemistry... 

Atoms are special, because of their high symmetry. How do we proceed to molecules The orbital model dominates chemistry, and at the heart of the orbital model is the HF-LCAO procedure. The main problem is integral evaluation. Even in simple HF-LCAO calculations we have to evaluate a large number of integrals in order to construct the HF Hamiltonian matrix, especially the notorious two-electron integrals... 

---