Application of the Symmetry Rule

Recently, a symmetry rule for predicting stable molecular shapes has been developed by Pearson Salem and Bartell . This rule is based on the second-order, or pseudo, Jahn-Teller effect and follows from the earlier work by Bader . According to the symmetry rule, the symmetries of the ground state and the lowest excited state determine which kind of nuclear motion occurs most easily in the ground state of a molecule. Pearson has shown that this approximation is justified in a large variety of inorganic and small organic molecules. 

---

Next, we consider the application of the symmetry rule to the prediction of the geometrical structures of some other related systems. 

These simplified VSEPR rules may seem a far cry from the more elegant application of symmetry and molecular orbitals to the beryllium hydride molecule and the nitrite ion (Chapter 5). or the BH2 molecule (Problem 6.27). Although the molecular orbital approach can rationalize these structures, the direct application of the VSEPR rules is by far the easier way to approach a new structure. 

For the three-spin system there are 23 basis functions that can be formed as products without regard to any symmetry considerations. These can be classified into four sets according to the values offz, as indicated in Table 6.3. Application of the selection rule Afz = 1 shows that there are 15 allowed transitions. 

In addition to selection of the structure of the monomer as the basis for defining the internal coordinates of the repeat unit, the possible structures are usually further constrained by taking advantage of any symmetry possessed by the unit cell. The symmetry is derived from the systematic absence of reflections which are forbidden by the selection rules for a particular space group. In the case of cellulose, the simplification usually introduced is the application of the symmetry of space group P2, which includes a twofold screw axis parallel to the direction of the chains. The validity of this simplification remains the subject of controversy, however, because the reflections which are disallowed under the selection rules of the space group are in fact frequently observed. 

Derivative of Same Symmetry. In case the isotopic substitution does not change the symmetry, the application of the product rule is, as pointed out in Sec. 8-5, relatively simple. Therefore the form of the product rule for such a case (CeDe compared with CeHe) will be given first. 

With the application of the symmetry selection rules, both lattice structure and orientation can be obtained from Raman experiments with different scattering geometries and polarizations The presence of a phonon peak in the Raman spectra depends on the selec-... 

The last decade has witnessed an unprecedented strengthening of the bone between theory and experiment in organic chemistry. Much of this success may be credited to the development of widely applicable, unifying concepts, such as the symmetry rules of Woodward and Hoffmann, and the frontier orbital thee>ry of Eukui. Whereas the the ore tical emphasis had historically been on detailed structure and spectroscopy, the new methods are de signe d to solve pre)blems e>f special importance to organic chemists reactivity, stereochemistry, and mechanisms. 

An application of the variational principle to an unbounded from below Dirac-Coulomb eigenvalue problem, requires imposing upon the trial function certain conditions. Among these the most important are the symmetry properties, the asymptotic behaviour and the relations between the large and the small components of the wavefunction related to the so called kinetic balance [1,2,3]. In practical calculations an exact fulfilment of these conditions may be difficult or even impossible. Therefore a number of minimax principles [4-7] have been formulated in order to allow for some less restricted choice of the trial functions. There exist in the literature many either purely intuitive or derived from computational experience, rules which are commonly used as a guidance in generating basis sets for variational relativistic calculations. 

The contents of this chapter are fundamental in the applications of molecular orbital theory to bond lengths, bond angles and molecular shapes, which are discussed in Chapters 3-6. This chapter introduces the principles of group theory and its application to problems of molecular symmetry. The application of molecular orbital theory to a molecule is simplified enormously by the knowledge of the symmetry of the molecule and the group theoretical rules that apply. 

The averaging of SCF energy expressions to impose symmetry and equivalence restrictions is a straightforward, if sometimes tedious, application of the Slater-Condon rules for matrix elements between determinants of orthonormal orbitals. This matter is discussed in detail elsewhere. The most general SCF programs can handle energy expressions of the form... 

A preliminary analysis of the absorption spectrum was given in Example 5.4-1 as an illustration of the application of the direct product (DP) rule for evaluating matrix elements, but the analysis was incomplete because at that stage we were not in a position to deduce the symmetry of the electronic states from electron configurations, so these were merely stated. A more complete analysis may now be given. The molecular orbitals (MOs)... 

Theoretical chemistry rates some special mention in this context. Nowadays this activity tends to be quite mathematical [1], but history shows us that theoretical chemistry need not be mathematical at all. From the first years of the crystallization of chemistry as a subject distinct from alchemy, chemists have utilized theory, in the sense of disciplined speculation. Nonmathematical examples are found in the structural theory of organic chemistry [2] and in most applications of the powerful Woodward-Hoffman orbital symmetry rules [3]. 

Kenichi Fukui and Roald Hoffmann won the Nobel prize in 1981 (Woodward died in 1979 and so couldn t share this prize he had already won the Nobel prize in 1965 for his work on synthesis) for the application of orbital symmetry to pericyclic reactions. Theirs is an alternative description to the frontier orbital method we have used and you need to know a little about it. They considered a more fundamental correlation between the symmetry of all the orbitals in the starting materials and all the orbitals in the products. This is rather too complex for our consideration here, and we shall concentrate only on a summary of the conclusions—the Woodward-Hoffmann rules. The most important of these states ... 

---