Acylium ions decarbonylation

Drawbacks as known from the Friedel-Crafts alkylation are not found for the Friedel-Crafts acylation. In some cases a decarbonylation may be observed as a side-reaction, e.g. if loss of CO from the acylium ion will lead to a stable carbenium species 8. The reaction product of the attempted acylation will then be rather an alkylated aromatic compound 9 ... 

Sometimes acylium ions lose carbon monoxide to generate an ordinary carbonium ion. It will be recalled that free acyl radicals exhibit similar behavior at high temperatures. Whether or not the loss of carbon monoxide takes place seems to depend on the stability of the resulting carbonium ion and on the speed with which the acylium ion is removed by competing reactions. Thus no decarbonylation is observed in Friedel-Crafts reactions of benzoyl chloride, the phenyl cation being rather unstable. But attempts to make pivaloyl benzene by the Friedel-Crafts reaction produce tert-butyl benzene instead. With compound XLIV cyclization competes with decarbonylation, but this competition is not successful in the case of compound XLV in which the ring is deactivated.263... 

Upon acylation of some benzyl carbonyl compounds (25, R = H, Me 51, R = OH) dibenzo[a,tropylium salts 65 have been isolated in low yields (5-15 %) along with the major products, 2-benzopyrylium salts. Veratryl acetone 25 (R = Me) as well as homoveratric aldehyde 25 (R = H) (or carboxonium ions 31 which are formed from them) may undergo an oxidative a-cleavage, resulting in the benzyl cation 64. The formation of the same cation from homoveratric acid 51 is the result of decarbonylation of the acylium ion 63. Further interaction of the benzyl cation 64 with the substrate, followed by cyclization and oxidation, results in the polycyclic tropylium salts 65 (82ZOR589). 

Alkyl cations can also be generated by decarbonylation of tertiary acylium ions, like the pivaloyl cation 26 [Eq. (3.20)].91 This reaction corresponds to the reverse of Koch-Haaf acid synthesis, which is known to involve carbocation intermediates. Indeed the reaction of the terf-butyl cation with carbon monoxide gives the pivaloyl cation.91 135... 

Alkyl cations can also be generated by decarbonylation of tertiary acylium ions, like the Pivaloyl cation 1521). 

---