Microscopic reversibility mechanisms

The above reactions have been described in terms of substrate oxidation which is the predominant metabolic pathway. However, as enzymes are catalysts the reaction in the reverse direction - reduction of substrate by dihydroflavin - will occur by the microscopically reversed mechanisms. 

When the addition and elimination reactions are mechanically reversible, they proceed by identical mechanistic paths but in opposite directions. In these circumstances, mechanistic conclusions about the addition reaction are applicable to the elimination reaction and vice versa. The principle of microscopic reversibility states that the mechanism (pathway) traversed in a reversible reaction is the same in the reverse as in the forward direction. Thus, if an addition-elimination system proceeds by a reversible mechanism, the intermediates and transition states involved in the addition process are the same as... 

We now introduce the principle of microscopic reversibility. This states that the transition states for any pathway for an elementary reaction in forward and reverse directions are related as mirror images. The atoms are in the same places but the momentum vectors are, of course, reversed since in general the transition state is proceeding in one direction only. In other words, the forward and reverse mechanisms are identical, according to this principle. 

Application of the principle of microscopic reversibility can be used to eliminate a mechanism suggested at one time for the nucleophilic substitution reactions of square-planar platinum(II) complexes. For the sake of specificity, we take PtCl - as a typical... 

For each catalyst, the mechanism for one direction is the exact reverse of the other, by the principle of microscopic reversibility. As expected from mechanisms in which the C—H bond is broken in the rate-determining step, substrates of the type RCD2COR show deuterium isotope effects (of 5) in both the basic- and the acid -catalyzed processes. 

When the reaction proceeds by this pathway, 29 and similar intermediates are not involved and the mechanism is exactly (by the principle of microscopic reversibility)... 

This reaction is reversible and suitable p-hydroxy alkenes can be cleaved by heat (17-34). There is evidence that the cleavage reaction occurs by a cyclic mechanism (p. 1351), and, by the principle of microscopic reversibility, the addition mechanism should be cyclic too. Note that this reaction is an oxygen analog of the ene... 

Note that these mechanisms are the reverse of those involved in the acid-catalyzed hydration of double bonds (15-3), in accord with the principle of microscopic reversibility. With anhydrides (e.g., P2O5, phthalic anhydride) as well as with some other reagents such as HMPA, it is likely that an ester is formed, and the leaving group is the conjugate base of the corresponding acid. In these cases, the mechanism can be El or E2. The mechanism with AI2O3 and other solid catalysts has been studied extensively but is poorly understood. 

There is an extra complication for the associative limit of this reaction. Addition of water to the monoanion would give a species with very acidic hydrogens, so that dissociation must be expected to be concerted. By microscopic reversibility, the very similar leaving group ethanol must depart by an analogous path. Thus the mechanism becomes ... 

Perhaps the best starting point in a review of the nonequilibrium field, and certainly the work that most directly influenced the present theory, is Onsager s celebrated 1931 paper on the reciprocal relations [10]. This showed that the symmetry of the linear hydrodynamic transport matrix was a consequence of the time reversibility of Hamilton s equations of motion. This is an early example of the overlap between macroscopic thermodynamics and microscopic statistical mechanics. The consequences of time reversibility play an essential role in the present nonequilibrium theory, and in various fluctuation and work theorems to be discussed shortly. 

An expression for the equilibrium occupancy of pARt can again be obtained using the methods outlined in Chapter 1. A potential complication is that this mechanism contains a cycle, so the product of the reaction rates in both clockwise and counterclockwise directions should be equal in order to ensure the principle of microscopic reversibility is maintained. In this case, microscopic reversibility is maintained. Thus,... 

Guideline 7. A postulated mechanism for a reaction in the forward direction must also hold for the reverse reaction. This guideline is a consequence of the principle of microscopic reversibility. (See Section 4.1.5.4.) Three corollaries of this guideline should also be kept in mind when postulating a reaction mechanism. First, the rate limiting step for the reverse reaction must... 

The Principle of Microscopic Reversibility. The principle of microscopic reversibility is based on statistical mechanical arguments and was first formulated by Tolman (17) in 1924. 

Scheme 3. A disallowed mechanism that violates microscopic reversibility.

The "principle of microscopic reversibility", which indicates that the forward and the reverse reactions must proceed through the same pathway, assures us that we can use the same reaction mechanism for generating the intermediate precursors of the "synthesis tree", that we use for the synthesis in the laboratory. In other words, according to the "principle of microscopic reversibility", [26] two reciprocal reactions from the point of view of stoichiometry are also such from the point of view of their mechanism, provided that the reaction conditions are the same or at least very similar. A corollary is that the knowledge of synthetic methods and reaction mechanisms itself -according to the electronic theory of valence and the theory of frontier molecular orbitals- must be applied in order to generate the intermediate precursors of the "synthesis tree" and which will determine the correctness of a synthesis design and, ultimately, the success of it. 

An accurate knowledge of the thermochemical properties of species, i.e., AHf(To), S Tq), and c T), is essential for the development of detailed chemical kinetic models. For example, the determination of heat release and removal rates by chemical reaction and the resulting changes in temperature in the mixture requires an accurate knowledge of AH and Cp for each species. In addition, reverse rates of elementary reactions are frequently determined by the application of the principle of microscopic reversibility, i.e., through the use of equilibrium constants, Clearly, to determine the knowledge of AH[ and S for all the species appearing in the reaction mechanism would be necessary. 

The mechanism of such a reaction, represented in Scheme 3.9, comes directly from the reverse mechanism of ethane metathesis, each step being considered as microscopically reversible. In a clockwise catalytic cycle ethane metathesis occurs, whereas in the counter-clockwise catalytic cycle propane methane-ol-ysis occurs the case with heavier alkanes is of course more complicated. 

The Principle of Microscopic Reversibility and its large-scale consequence, known as the Principle of Detailed Balancing enable investigators to understand the mechanism of the reverse reaction to the same level of accuracy as that achieved for the forward reaction. 

The mechanism is in complete agreement with results from recent tryptophan fluorescence experiments (which, due to the inviolability of microscopic reversibility, also hold in the synthesis mode) that establish definitively that (i) P, cannot simply bind spontaneously, (ii) an enzyme species with all three catalytic sites occupied is the only catalytically competent species, and (iii) release of product and binding of substrate caimot be simultaneous, rather product release must precede substrate binding [38]. 

The latter condition is commonly known as microscopic reversibility or local detailed balance. This property is equivalent to time reversal invariance in deterministic (e.g., thermostatted) dynamics. Although it can be relaxed by requiring just global (rather than detailed) balance, it is physically natural to think of equilibrium as a local property. Microscopic reversibility, a common assumption in nonequilibrium statistical mechanics, is the crucial ingredient in the present derivation. 

---