Isotopic substitution, reactive intermediate

The use of other isotopically labelled compounds may be of great value in the study of unstable intermediates in all cases, however, due allowance should be made for the differing chemical reactivities of the isotopically substituted compounds. 

Although the fate of Cr(IV) is uncertain, (cf. the alcohol oxidation), some characteristics of the intermediate chromium species have been obtained by Wiberg and Richardson from a study of competitions between benzaldehyde and each of several substituted benzaldehydes. The competition between the two aldehydes for Cr(VI) is measured simply by their separate reactivities that for the Cr(V) or Cr(IV) is obtained from estimation of residual aldehyde by a C-labelling technique. If Cr(V) is involved then p values for oxidation by Cr(VI) and Cr(V) are 0.77 and 0.45, respectively. An isotope effect of 4.1 for oxidation of benzaldehyde by Cr(V) was obtained likewise. 

Disilenes react with ketones, aldehydes, esters and acid chlorides by formal [2 + 21-cycloaddition to yield the corresponding disiloxetanes (equation 73)8,16. The reaction is non-concerted and proceeds through the initial formation of a 1,4-biradical intermediate, as has been shown by the products of reaction of tetramesityldisilene (110) with the cyclopropyl aldehyde 117 (equation 90)163. The absolute rate constants listed in Table 19 indicate there to be a significant difference in reactivity between the monophenyl-substituted disilene 103 and the 1,2-diphenyl-substituted derivatives 104, consistent with a steric effect on the rate of formation of the biradical intermediate. As would be expected, no kinetic deuterium isotope effect is discernible from the relative rates of addition of acetone and acetone- to these compounds. 

These fundamental aspects of epoxide ring opening were established by kinetic and isotopic labeling studies2 The dominant role of bond cleavage in acidic hydrolysis is indicated by the increase in rates with additional substitution. Note in particular that the 2,2-dimethyl derivative is much more reactive than the cis and trans disubstituted derivative, as expected for an intermediate with carbocation character. 

---