Hydrogen-Bond Catalysis

2 Hydrogen-Bond Catalysis or Bronsted-Acid Catalysis General Considerations 

In addition to the activation of carbonyl compounds and imines, Schreiner studied on thiourea-catalyzed acetalization reaction, in which ortho esters were activated by hydrogen bond [19]. Jacobsen has utilized the hydrogen-bond catalysis in reactions with acyliminium ions, wherein hydrogen bond activates the acylim-inium salt through complexation with chloride [20]. 

In summary, the differences between Br0nsted-acid catalysis and hydrogen-bond catalysis were discussed. Because there is a gradual transition from hydro-gen-bond catalysis to Bronsted-acid catalysis, it is not always easy to differentiate the two modes of catalysis. However, the combination of a stronger acid and an imine will be a Bronsted-acid-catalyzed reachon, while the combination of a neutral acid and an aldehyde will be a hydrogen-bond-catalyzed reaction. 

Hydrogen Bonding, Oxford University Press, Oxford. 

14 Gridnev, I.D., Kouchi, M., Sorimachi, K. and Terada, M. (2007) Tetrahedron Lett., 

---

Chemical reactivity and hydrogen bonding 320 Proton-transfer behaviour 321 Intramolecular hydrogen-bond catalysis 344 Enzyme catalysis and hydrogen bonding 354 Chymotrypsin 354 Thermolysin 355 Carboxypeptidase 355 Tyrosyl tRNA synthetase 356 Summary 366 Acknowledgements 367 References 367... 

In another estimate (Kirby and Percy, 1989), the carboxyl group in l-methoxymethoxy-8-naphthoic acid and the dimethylammonium group in the l-methoxymethoxy-8-A, A -dimethylnaphthylammonium ion are estimated to lead to rate increases by intramolecular catalysis of < ca. 900 and 1.9 X 10 compared to the value of ca. 1 x 10 calculated for the intramolecular catalytic effect of the carboxyl group in 2-methoxymethoxybenzoic acid. The salicylate ion remains the most efficient leaving group thus far discovered that can take part in hydrogen-bond catalysis of the hydrolysis of acetals. 

The mechanism of hydrolysis of 2-carboxyphenylsulphamic acid (42) might be expected to follow that for the hydrolysis of salicyl sulphate, but actually it is thought to proceed by classic intramolecular acid catalysis rather than by hydrogen-bond catalysis. Evidence for a substantial degree of proton transfer from the carboxyl group in the transition state has been obtained (Hopkins and Williams, 1982). 

To date, hydrogen bond catalysis has been successfully utilized to facilitate enantioselective Michael additions, Baylis-Hillman reactions, Diels-Alder cycloadditions, and additions of 7i-nucleophiles to imines. 

It is worth noting that use of unprotected diarylprolinol 33 provides an effective platform for the epoxidation of a,P-unsaturated ketones [148, 149]. Within these reports it was proposed that an alternative mode of activation of the substrate could be taking place. Hydrogen bonding catalysis, rather than iminium ion formation, could explain the results and would be consistent with the non-polar reaction medium adopted within these reactions. 

The difference between hydrogen-bond catalysis and Br0nsted-acid catalysis is not always clear in the literatures. In this chapter, the differences and similarities of the hydrogen-bond catalysis and Bronsted-acid catalysis will be addressed. 

Scheme 2.5 Hydrogen-bond catalysis versus Bronsted-acid catalysis.

Because there is an equilibrium between hydrogen-bond complex 5 and ion pair 6, it is not always easy to differentiate between hydrogen-bond catalysis and Br0nsted-acid catalysis explicitly. 

Because a comprehensive discussion of the transition state of hydrogen-bond catalysis will be presented by Berkessel in Chapter 3, the hydrogen bond catalyzed hetero Diels-Alder reaction of butadiene with carbonyl compounds will be discussed briefly here. Huang and Rawal reported that the hetero Diels-Alder reaction of aminodiene with aldehyde exhibited significant solvent effects (Scheme 2.7) [15]. The reaction in CHCfi was accelerated 30 times in comparison with that in THF, while that in i-PrOH was accelerated 630 times. They proposed that the Diels-Alder reaction was promoted by the hydrogen-bond activation of aldehyde. This finding resulted in the development of TADDOL catalyst [3]. 

In contrast to some related reviews, which use reaction class or electrophiles as organizational elements, this chapter is divided into three main sections according to catalyst class (i) Bronsted acid catalysis by phosphoric acid and phosphoramide derivatives, (ii) N—H hydrogen bond catalysis by organic base and ammonium systems, and (iii) combined acid catalysis including Bronsted-acid-assisted Bronsted acid, Lewis-acid-assisted Bronsted acid, and Lewis-acid-assisted Br0nsted acid systems (Figure 5.1). 

The success of their initial VMA studies led the Rawal group to further probe hydrogen bonding catalysis of the Mukaiyama aldol reaction between the highly... 

The small-molecule catalysts are covered in Chapters 5 and 6. In Chapter 5, Joshua Payette and Hisashi Yamamoto discuss the importance of polar Bronsted-acid-type catalysts as well as cooperative effects in hydrogen bonding catalysis. Chapter 6 by Mike Kotke and Peter Schreiner is then devoted to the single most popular small-molecule catalyst types, the thiourea catalysts. Chapter 6, the longest of all chapters, also provides an excellent overview of the history and development of the field of small-molecule hydrogen bond catalysis. 

---