Failure Free energy

Early Successes and Failures of Free Energy Calculations... 

The calculation of the affinity scale, in terms of differences in free-energy content between the various ionic forms of these materials, implies that one is dealing with equilibrium systems and that the reaction is both reversible and stoichiometric, i.e., hydrolysis phenomena are absent in the zeolite. Within certain limits, these conditions are generally met however, it is apparent that some discrepancies between experimental data have sometimes been attributed (1) to a failure in the fulfillment of one or more of these basic prerequisites. 

A more detailed understanding of the failure of the moment free energy beyond phase coexistence can be gained by comparing with the formal solution of the exact phase coexistence problem. Assume that the parent p (phases numbered by a = 1... p. The condition (48), which follows from equality of the chemical potentials p(cr) in all phases, implies that we can write their density distributions pM(cr) as... 

The smaller expansion factor predicted by the theory of Hoeve originates from neglecting the tail portions of the adsorbed polymer chain, while the larger expansion factor predicted by Jones and Richmond is due to their failure of correctly evaluating the elastic free energy, as has been pointed out by Kawaguchi and Takahashi74. ... 

An analysis of these results in terms of solvent effects leads to the observation of similarities with Ritchie s work on the N+ relation. Thus the constant selectivities obtained in the solvolysis reactions of certain methyl derivatives (Table 9) may indicate the existence of a basic similarity between the rate-determining process in these reaction and in the electrophile-nucleophile combination reactions correlated by the IV+ relation. The failure of the methyl halides to conform to this pattern might suggest that their substitution reactions are fundamentally different, and that the free energy of activation is dependent on factors other than desolvation. 

Various compounds were shown to sensitize the photochemical decomposition of pyridinium salts. Photolysis of pyridinium salts in the presence of sensitizers such as anthracene, perylene and phenothiazine proceeds by an electron transfer from the excited state sensitizer to the pyridinium salt. Thus, a sensitizer radical cation and pyridinyl radical are formed as shown for the case of anthracene in Scheme 15. The latter rapidly decomposes to give pyridine and an ethoxy radical. Evidence for the proposed mechanism was obtained by observation of the absorption spectra of relevant radical cations upon laser flash photolysis of methylene chloride solutions containing sensitizers and pyridinium salt [64]. Moreover, estimates of the free energy change by the Rehm-Weller equation [65] give highly favorable values for anthracene, perylene, phenothiazine and thioxanthone sensitized systems, whilst benzophenone and acetophenone seemed not to be suitable sensitizers (Table 5). The failure of the polymerization experiments sensitized by benzophenone and acetophenone in the absence of a hydrogen donor is consistent with the proposed electron transfer mechanism. 

---