Ethyl carbocation, electrostatic

Ethyl carbocation, electrostatic potential map of, 196 molecular orbital of, 196... 

Compare electrostatic potential maps for ethyl, 2-propyl, 2-methyl-2-propyl and 2-butyl cations. Does the extent to which positive charge is localized at the carbocation center parallel proton affinity Explain. 

It is unlikely that free carbanions exist in solution. Like carbocations, they usually exist as either ion pairs or they are solvated. " Among experiments that demonstrated this was the treatment of PhCOCHMe with ethyl iodide, where was Li ", Na", or K" . The half-lives of the reaction were for Li, 31 x 10 Na, 0.39 X 10 and K, 0.0045 x 10 , demonstrating that the species involved were not identical. Similar results were obtained with Li, Na, and Cs triphenylmethides (PhsC M Where ion pairs are unimportant, carbanions are solvated. Cram " demonstrated solvation of carbanions in many solvents. There may be a difference in the structure of a carbanion depending on whether it is free (e.g., in the gas phase) or in solution. The negative charge may be more localized in solution in order to maximize the electrostatic attraction to the counterion. ... 

Figure 6.10 Electrostatic potential maps for (a) tert-butyl (3°), (b) isopropyl (2°), (c) ethyl (1°), and (d) methyl carbocations show the trend from greater to lesser delocalization (stabilization) of the positive charge. (The structures are mapped on the same scale of electrostatic potential to allow direct comparison.)...

Begin by performing an AMI geometry optimization on methyl, ethyl, isopropyl, and ferf-butyl carbocations. These carbocations are built as described in Part C of Experiment 20A. Don t forget to specify that each one has a positive charge. Also select a density surface for each one with the electrostatic potential mapped onto the surface. 

---