Concerted reaction substitution

The first three chapters discuss fundamental bonding theory, stereochemistry, and conformation, respectively. Chapter 4 discusses the means of study and description of reaction mechanisms. Chapter 9 focuses on aromaticity and aromatic stabilization and can be used at an earlier stage of a course if an instructor desires to do so. The other chapters discuss specific mechanistic types, including nucleophilic substitution, polar additions and eliminations, carbon acids and enolates, carbonyl chemistry, aromatic substitution, concerted reactions, free-radical reactions, and photochemistry. 

The results are critically dependent on the level of theory. However, a stepwise mechanism with closed shell structures along the reaction path was found to be lower in energy than a concerted reaction. An all-cw conformer of 172 is reported to be a transition state rather than an intermediate. Similarities of the conformational isomers of the intermediate 2-butenedithial 172 with the dinitrosoethylenes discussed in Section IV,c are evident. 3,6-Diamino-substituted dithiins are predicted to be more stable in the open-chain bisthioamide structure [95JST51]. The... 

But in the substituted dienes like cis-1-substituted dienes, the. v-cis conformation is disfavoured with respect to the. v-cis form of corresponding transform due to the nonbonding interactions between the substituent and the 4-hydrogen. In a concerted reaction the trans isomer should be therefore more reactive than the cis-derivative. 

The practical usefulness of Equations 11.46 through 11.53 has been demonstrated for the malic enzyme catalyzed conversion of L-malate to pyruvate (Equation 11.72). Table 11.1 lists experimentally determined isotope effects for this reaction. Comparison of carbon kinetic isotope effects for protio and deutero-malate substituted at position 2 (the carbon that undergoes sp3 to sp2 transition) rules out the possibility that the hydride transfer and the decarboxylation events are concerted. This conclusion follows from Equation 11.48 which, for a concerted reaction, predicts that 13(V/K) should be smaller than 13(V/K)D, which is opposite to the order observed experimentally. 

Similar qualitative relationships between reaction mechanism and the stability of the putative reactive intermediates have been observed for a variety of organic reactions, including alkene-forming elimination reactions, and nucleophilic substitution at vinylic" and at carbonyl carbon. The nomenclature for reaction mechanisms has evolved through the years and we will adopt the International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry (lUPAC) nomenclature and refer to stepwise substitution (SnI) as Dn + An (Scheme 2.1 A) and concerted bimolecular substitution (Sn2) as AnDn (Scheme 2.IB), except when we want to emphasize that the distinction in reaction mechanism is based solely upon the experimentally determined kinetic order of the reaction with respect to the nucleophile. 

The change from a stepwise preassociation mechanism through a triple ion intermediate to an uncoupled concerted reaction occurs as the triple ion becomes too unstable to exist in an energy well for the time of a bond vibration ( 10 s). The borderline between these two reaction mechanisms is poorly marked, and there are no clear experimental protocols for its detection. These two reaction mechanisms cannot be distinguished by experiments designed to characterize their transition states, which lie at essentially the same position in the inner upper right hand corner of Figure 2.3. Only low yields of the nucleophilic substitution product are obtained from both stepwise preassociation and uncoupled concerted reactions, because for formation of the preassociation complex in water is small... 

Nucleophilic Substitution at Benzyl Derivatives. The sharp break from a stepwise to a concerted mechanism that is observed for nucleophilic substitution of azide ion at X-l-Y (Figs. 2.2 and 2.5) is blurred for nucleophilic substitution at the primary 4-methoxybenzyl derivatives (4-MeO,H)-3-Y. For example, the secondary substrate (4-MeO)-l-Cl reacts exclusively by a stepwise mechanism through the liberated carbocation intermediate (4-MeO)-T, which shows a moderately large selectivity toward azide ion ( az/ s = 100 in 50 50 (v/v) water/ trifluoroethanol). The removal of an a-Me group from (4-MeO)-l-Cl to give (4-MeO,H)-3-Cl increases the barrier to ionization of the substrate in the stepwise reaction relative to that for the concerted bimolecular substitution of azide ion. The result is that both of these mechanisms are observed concurrently for nucleophilic substitution of azide ion at (4-MeO,H)-3-Cl in water/acetone solvents. These concurrent stepwise and concerted nucleophilic substitution reactions of azide ion with (4-MeO,H)-3-Cl show that there is no sharp borderline between mechanisms for substitution at primary benzylic carbon, but instead a region of overlap where both mechanisms are observed. 

The transition states for the stepwise (fej, Fig. 2.3) and concerted (fecon) reactions of (4-MeO,X)-3-Y lie at distinct well-separated positions on the More O Ferrall diagram and show different sensitivities to changes in solvent polarity, meta substituents X at the aromatic ring, and the leaving group Y. For example, in 50 50 (v/v) water/trifluoroethanol (4-MeO,H)-3-Cl reacts with azide ion exclusively by a stepwise mechanism through the primary carbocation intermediate (4-MeO,H)-3" with a selectivity for reaction with azide ion and solvent of feaz/ s = 25 However, two-thirds of the azide ion substitution product obtained from the reaction of (4-MeO,H)-3-Cl in the less polar solvent 80 20 acetone/water forms by concerted bimolecular substitution and only one-third forms by trapping of the carbocation intermediate (4-MeO,H)-3 with a selectivity of k z/h = 8 The preferred... 

Generally, only a single stepwise or concerted pathway for aliphatic nucleophihc substitution is detected by experiment because of the very different activation barriers for formation of the respective reaction transition states for these reactions. The description of the borderline between stepwise and concerted nucleophilic substitution reactions presented in this chapter has been obtained through a search for those rare substrates that show comparable barriers to these two reactions and through the characterization of the barrier for nucleophile addition to the putative carbocation intermediate of the stepwise reaction in the region of this change in mechanism. 

The description of the borderline between stepwise and concerted nucleophilic substitution remains murky in cases where there is no significant stabilization of the transition state for the concerted reaction through the coupling of bond cleavage and formation. The reason is that there are no simple experimental protocols to detect the point at which the energy well for the carbocation intermediate of the stepwise reaction in the upper right hand corner of Figure 2.3 is transformed into... 

---