Carbonyl chloride ions decomposition

More recently Hand et al. (ref. 9) have studied the decomposition reaction of N-chloro-a-amino acid anions in neutral aqueous solution, where the main reaction products are carbon dioxide, chloride ion and imines (which hydrolyze rapidly to amine and carbonyl products). They found that the reaction rate constant of decarboxylation was independent of pH, so they ruled out a proton assisted decarboxylation mechanism, and the one proposed consists of a concerted decarboxylation. For N-bromoamino acids decomposition in the pH interval 9-11 a similar concerted mechanism was proposed by Antelo et al. (ref. 10), where the formation of a nitrenium ion (ref. 11) can be ruled out because it is not consistent with the experimental results. Antelo et al. have also established that when the decomposition reaction takes place at pH < 9, the disproportionation reaction of the N-Br-amino acid becomes important, and the decomposition goes through the N,N-dibromoamino acid. This reaction is also important for N-chloroamino compounds but at more acidic pH values, because the disproportionation reaction... 

There s nothing wrong with the mechanism, it s just that the reaction is an equilibrium that will run backwards. Hemiacetals are unstable because they decompose back to carbonyl compounds. Chloride ion is very stable and decomposition will be faster than it is for hemiacetals. 

---