Acid-base catalysis detection

Much of the study of kinetics constitutes a study of catalysis. The first goal is the determination of the rate equation, and examples have been given in Chapters 2 and 3, particularly Section 3.3, Model Building. The subsection following this one describes the dependence of rates on pH, and most of this dependence can be ascribed to acid—base catalysis. Here we treat a very simple but widely applicable method for the detection and measurement of general acid-base or nucleophilic catalysis. We consider aqueous solutions where the pH and p/f concepts are well understood, but similar methods can be applied in nonaqueous media. 

If it can be assumed that the Bronsted relation remains approximately valid for the ions and molecules of the solvent, it is possible to make some interesting deductions about the possibility of detecting general acid-base catalysis. The point is best illustrated by taking a particular example, e.g., acid catalysis in an aqueous solution 0.1 A with respect to both acetic acid and acetate ions. We assume that the catalytic effect of acids (without reference to charge or structure) is given approximately by... 

These early views envisaged reactions which could take place in the absence of a catalyst, but which were facilitated by its presence. Evidence gradually accumulated to show that many of the reactions subject to acid-base catalysis could not take place at all in the complete absence of catalysts, apparently spontaneous reactions being often due to catalysis by acidic or basic solvent molecules, or by some adventitious acidic or basic impurity. This seemed to indicate that the catalyst took a fundamental part in the reaction, possibly in a chemical sense. It was soon realized that the essential property of acids and bases was their power respectively to lose and to add on a proton, and enquiry also showed that substrates involved in acid catalysis could always be supposed to have some basic properties, while those in base-catalyzed reactions could always in principle act as acids, though the acid-base properties of the substrates were often so weak as to elude detection by ordinary means. This led to the suggestion that acid-base catalysis always involves an acid-base reaction between the catalyst and the substrate. Such a reaction is also often termed a protolytic reaction, since it involves the transfer of a proton between the two reacting species. 

The results of the above analysis of reactions involving two proton transfers may be compared with those for reactions in which only a single transfer is kinetically relevant (Sec. III.3.a). For a single transfer the existence of an equilibrium between catalyst and substrate always produces the appearance of specific catalysis by hydrogen or hydroxyl ions, and the detection of general acid-base catalysis therefore excludes... 

Photfrfysis of a-Diazo Carbonyl Compounds - Some recent advances in the matrix photochemistry of diazoketones, including some heterocyclic species, have been reviewed. Flash photolysis of 10-diazo-9(10//)-phenanthrenone (35) in aqueous solution led to the detection of two transient species on the pathway to the final product, fluorene-9-carboxylic acid. These were identified, from solvent isotope effects and the nature of the observed acid-base catalysis, as fluorenylideneketene (36, X = CO) and the enol of fluorene-9-carboxylic acid (36, X = C(0H)2), formed by hydration of the ketene. In related studies, fluorenylideneketene was found to react with amines to give ylides as intermediates on the route to the amide final products. The product distribution from the photochemical reactions of 2-diazo-3-oxo-5,10,15,20-tetraphenylchlorins with alcohols strongly depends on the central metal ion of the irradiated diazoketones. ... 

The existence of Br nsted relationships affects the experimental problem of detecting general acid or base catalysis. This is clearly shown by an example given by Bell. Consider the reaction under study as carried out in an aqueous solution containing 0.10 M acetic acid and 0.10 M sodium acetate, and suppose that the Br nsted equation applies. Three catalytic species are present these are HjO, with = - 1.74 H2O, pKa 15.74 and HOAc, pTiT 4.76. -pp i7i-3 93.pp.9i-5 9s concentrations of these acids are 1.76 x lO- M, 55.5 M, and 0.10 M, respec-... 

General-base catalysis was also detected in this reaction and attributed to general-acid catalysis of breakdown of the monoanion (18). The Bransted P-value was 0.57 and so the a-value for expulsion of the alcohol from the ionized form is 0.43. The point for the water-catalysed reaction lies on the Bransted plot for catalysis by other bases which supports the view that these reactions proceed by similar mechanisms as formulated in (17) and (18). 6... 

In order to detect a general acid or general base catalysis, it is necessary to do a series of kinetic experiments in which [H+] or [OH-] and the ionic strength are kept constant while [HA] or [B] are varied in such a way that the buffer ratio remains unchanged within the same series. Details of studies of this type have been adequately described in the literature [1, 3, 4]. 

A reaction with mechanism (99) should show general base catalysis but under some conditions this catalysis is difficult to detect and the rate may be dominated by hydroxide ion catalysis. However, recent work has now been carried out on the detritiation of chloroform in which general base catalysis by amines was observed [171(a)]. In the work with chloroform in which general base catalysis was not detected [114], since it was not possible to obtain a Bronsted exponent by measuring catalytic coefficients for a series of bases, an alternative procedure first suggested by Bell and Cox [172] was used. The rate of detritiation of chloroform was measured in a mixed solvent of water with varying amounts of dimethylsulphoxide and a constant concentration of hydroxide ion. As discussed briefly in Sect. 4.4 an acidity function (H ) has been determined for these solvent... 

---